When Stephanie Hacke changed jobs a handful of weeks ago, her former co-workers chipped in for a few parting gifts.

As a writer and public relations professional, a Mont Blanc pen or leather-bound journal might have been fitting choices but, instead, the office staff laughed and hugged over a coffee mug, a container of iced coffee and a wind chime reading, “Coffee is always a good idea.”

It was a nod to the group’s daily 10 a.m. jaunts to the coffee machine or walks to the local coffee shop, where they bonded over new roasts and seasonal flavored syrups.

But for Hacke, 40, of Scott, those mid-morning hits of caffeine were already the second in her days, with another coffee, tea or caffeinated lemonade or two (or three) remaining before heading to bed that night.

Advertise with us

“I became addicted when I was a reporter,” she said. “I was working late nights, would have to get home and write, and get up first thing in the morning to get to work.”

Now she’s a full-time, work-from-home mom to a 10-month-old daughter, a fiancé, a home owner and dog parent. And her daughter wakes up one, two or three times each night, and stays awake for an hour or two, creating a sleep deficit for Hacke that is patched with caffeine.

The commonness of that choice makes it an obvious one. Most people know that “coffee wakes you up,” which is helpful for the one in three Americans reporting inadequate sleep. But what isn’t well understood by the midday and mid-evening sippers among us is how consistent (or inappropriate) caffeine use exerts cumulative effects on sleep, turning a mother’s helper into an achiever’s antagonist.

“Caffeine can mitigate the acute effects of sleep deprivation. It’s going to keep you awake, and get you over that hump for the short-term while you’re driving to Atlanta or writing a term paper. But it’s no substitute for sleep,” said Daniel Shade, director of Allegheny Health Network’s Sleep Disorders Center. “There’s a performance benefit, but it’s going to decrease the longer you’re awake. Eventually, all the caffeine in the world isn’t going to help you, and it’s going to start hurting you then.”

Here’s why.

Advertise with us

The longer we stay awake, the more adenosine builds up in our bodies. When that neurotransmitter binds to receptors in the brain, we feel tired. The more adenosine, the more binding, and the more tired we feel.

Unless you ingest caffeine.

That chemical is an antagonist — a competitor — for the same receptors that bind to adenosine.

“It’ll go in there ahead of adenosine, and say, ‘Sorry, this spot’s taken,’” Shade said.

The more that happens, the more receptors the body will create, knowing how much adenosine is looking for a seat in that round of musical chairs.

Advertise with us

Each additional hit of caffeine will mask those sensations of fatigue in the short-term, potentially leading the user to stay up longer and accumulate more sleep debt. The boost in performance and alertness will trick the user into thinking they’re well rested, but the underlying fatigue can turn dangerous.

“Sleep deprivation is frightening because, what we’ve seen is, your performance deficits increase in a straight line as a factor of how long you’re awake,” Shade said. “The kicker is how you feel about it is a lie: You can fool yourself into thinking you’re performing well, but the truth is it’s almost like a drunk driver thinking they can drive.”

Being awake for 17 hours causes the same level of impairment as someone with a blood alcohol content of .05%, which is above the legal limit in some cases.

Short-term sleep deficits — after one, or a few, nights of less than seven hours of sleep — can result in increased stress responsive, body pain, reduced quality of life, emotional distress and mood disorders, and cognitive, memory and performance deficits.

Chronic sleep deficits — which are recognized after weeks or months of sub-seven-hour nights of sleep — can result in increased risk of hypertension, diabetes, obesity, depression, heart attack and stroke.

Advertise with us

That’s the bad news.

On the perky side, Sunday, Oct. 15 kicks off Pittsburgh Coffee Week, and “If you don’t have heart disease, rapid heart rate, high blood pressure — which are among the main effects of high doses of caffeine — then you can have two to three cups of coffee per day, or its equivalent, up to 150mg of caffeine,” Shade said. “And there are a lot of beneficial health effects of coffee and/or caffeine at moderate doses.”

Though “the literature isn’t great on it,” Shade said, some doses of coffee may ward off certain types of cancer. It helps with memory and concentration. It can assist digestion and improve workouts, and there’s some early data that show a slowing of brain aging, which can lead to dementia.

“Right now, in this season of life, I need it, or I view it as I need it,” Stephanie Hacke said of her relationship with caffeine as she navigates being a new mom to Izzy. (Courtesy of Stephanie Hacke)

Hacke said she’s “always had to play games” with caffeine. Ingested at the right time, it can help her ward off migraines, improve her work performance and provide a medium for socializing with coworkers, friends and family. But too many chai or espresso lattes, and her thoughts are foggy, and she’ll get a case of the jitters.

That emphasizes Shade’s overarching advice: When it comes to caffeine, it’s all in how you use it.

Advertise with us

Some tips

1. Know what you’re drinking.

Don’t rely on averages for amounts of caffeine in coffee, tea or energy beverages. Read the label, Shade said.

“The problem with some of the newer drinks out — the sports and energy drinks — is a lot of them have more caffeine than what’s recommended,” Shade said. “When someone drinks four or five of those in a day, that’s way too much.”

Also, know that even some foods contain caffeine. (Here’s looking at you, chocolate.)

Shade said that those who are used to ingesting caffeine may tolerate higher amounts just fine but, “If you’re getting over 200 mg per day, you should probably start to keep an eye on it.”

Advertise with us

2. Know yourself.

Genetics determine how quickly people process any drug, caffeine included. If that morning cup of joe seems to provide a boost all day long, pay attention to those signals. It’s possible you’re a “slow metabolizer.”

3. Consider alternatives.

For those interested in a caffeine cut-down, or cut-out, Shade has two recommendations for alternative energy boosts.

First, move around, which activates the sympathetic nervous system to increase alertness. Or, take a cat nap, less than 20 minutes long.

Advertise with us

“Taking a longer nap, you run the risk of getting into deeper stages of sleep, and feeling groggy when you wake up,” he said.

4. Timing is everything.

While a cup of coffee or tea might provide an initial jolt, know the caffeine can stick with you for about eight hours on average, Shade said, which can not only delay sleep, but decrease sleep quality.

That means avoiding caffeine starting at 3 p.m. if you lie down for bed at 11 p.m., though, “Most people don’t do that,” he said with a laugh.

Halting caffeine consumption by mid-afternoon may not be common, but perhaps predictably, neither are good nights of sleep, with an estimated 50 to 70 million Americans suffering from a chronic sleep disorder, which doesn’t include the regular Joes whose shaky sleep habits may not warrant a formal diagnosis.

Advertise with us

Hacke’s workload — professional and personal — compels her to drink caffeinated beverages well past that 3 p.m. mark. Consistent with Shade’s caveats, they’re temporary plugs in the dam that allow for a few additional hours of productivity before Hacke makes it to bed.

It’s not ideal, she knows, but for now, it’s a way to cope with the demands on her time.

“Right now, in this season of life, I need it, or I view it as I need it,” Hacke said, as she haggled with whether to pop a K-Cup in the machine at 9 p.m. “Once my daughter starts sleeping better, I’ll probably be more cognizant of how much caffeine I’m taking in, but at this point, we’re in the thick of it, and it’s a comfort for me.”

Abby Mackey is a registered nurse, and can be reached at amackey@post-gazette.com and IG @abbymackeywrites.