In a room at West Penn Hospital on Nov. 30, Susan Madigan and her daughter, Cailynn, held hands as they napped — Susan in her hospital bed and Cailynn in a recliner pulled next to the bed.
The women slept as they both recovered from preventive double mastectomies — their surgeries on back-to-back days — hoping to avoid the breast cancer that killed Susan’s father and Cailynn’s grandfather.
“They are always together, come to all their appointments together and support each other,” said plastic surgeon Andrea Moreira, a member of their surgical team. “As a mother, it’s so touching that they chose to go through that journey together.”
Their story actually started more than 10 years ago, when Richard Howard, Susan’s father, noticed some discoloration on his chest in 2012. A few months later, he felt a lump there while he was showering. For about a year, he ignored it.
“And when he did finally go to the doctor, and they said that they wanted to biopsy it, he almost refused,” said Susan, “because he thought, ‘I can’t get breast cancer — I don’t have breasts.’ And they said, ‘Well, actually you do.’”
Male breast cancer is rare, accounting for only 1% of breast cancer diagnoses in the United States, and develops in the small amount of breast tissue that men are born with. About one in 833 men will develop breast cancer in their lifetime.
By the time a biopsy discovered Howard’s cancer, it had already spread to his lymph nodes. He underwent a mastectomy and lymph node removal, followed later by radiation and eventually chemotherapy.
Because male breast cancer is so rare, Howard went through extensive medical testing, including genetic testing, which revealed that he carried the BRCA2 gene mutation. The BRCA1 and BRCA2 genes function to help suppress tumors. When those genes have mutations, as they do in about one in every 500 American women, they aren’t as effective in suppressing cancer.
About half of women with a BRCA gene mutation will get breast cancer by the time they turn 70 years old, versus seven out of 100 women in the general U.S. population. About three in 10 will get ovarian cancer by the time they turn 70, compared to less than one out of 100 U.S. women generally.
The BRCA genes were only discovered in the mid-1990s and, in 2012, BRCA testing was more difficult than it is now — costing $4,000 or $5,000 when it wasn’t covered by insurance. When her father tested positive for the mutation, Susan qualified to be tested as well, and also tested positive.
“It was heartbreaking,” she said. “The first time they told us, my dad was still alive, and he just was crushed by it. So I was less worried about me and more worried about him. And then by extension of that my children. I was terrified for my kids.”

As Susan helped care for her father, who died in 2015, she learned about the option for a mastectomy from an unlikely source: actress Angelina Jolie, who went public in 2013 with her decision to get a double mastectomy after finding out that she carried the BRCA1 gene. Jolie’s mother died of breast and ovarian cancer in 2007, and Jolie had her ovaries and fallopian tubes removed as well in 2015.
When Susan explored getting a mastectomy herself, she was told that her insurance at the time wouldn’t cover it, in part because she was at lower risk because she had already had her ovaries removed due to cervical cancer and endometriosis.
So she decided to wait.
Susan’s youngest daughter, Cailynn, 24, hadn’t gotten tested for the gene mutation when her mother did. But in 2020, she woke up one day and decided that she was ready to find out.
Children with a parent who has a BRCA gene mutation have about a 50% chance of having it as well. Cailynn knew that if she tested positive for BRCA2, she would get a mastectomy. She was just 17 when her grandfather died, and, before he passed, they would frequently sit and talk on the family’s porch.
“He would tell me all the time that he was going to beat this, he's going to be the one that does it. And he had so much faith in beating it. And then in the end, he didn't,” she said. “So that kind of discourages you a lot. But when you get the choice to take control of a part of your life that you can take control of, you take it and hold on to it and you do it.”
Many people who test positive for a BRCA mutation opt for frequent monitoring rather than getting a mastectomy, which doesn’t eliminate the possibility of breast cancer but reduces the risk of contracting it by up to 90%.
Cailynn got the phone call that she had the BRCA2 mutation while she was shopping in the Walmart craft aisle. She held it together in the store and then ran out to her car. “I lost my absolute mind,” she said. “I bawled like a baby.”
When she told a doctor, at age 22, that she wanted a double mastectomy, the doctor suggested a year of therapy first to make sure that she was fully considering her decision. While some of her friends had trouble understanding why she would get a mastectomy if she didn’t have cancer, Cailynn never doubted her choice. She doesn’t plan on having children, but is comfortable with the idea that if she does, she won’t be able to breastfeed them.
“It kind of felt like I would rather be alive for my children than breastfeed them anyway,” she said. “I guess my mind was kind of made up. I think watching somebody you loved so much go through that really changes everything.”
With Cailynn so determined, Susan started to reassess her own options. Her husband had retired from the military and they now had different insurance, which was willing to cover the mastectomy — if Susan still wanted it.

“You start thinking, no big deal, it’s just a mastectomy,” she said. “But it’s more than that. It’s an organ — you are losing organs from your body — and it’s deeply personal. I breastfed all of my children and it was one of my favorite memories, and it made it difficult.”
She decided to proceed. And on parallel tracks, accompanying each other to their appointments with the same surgeons, mother and daughter prepared for surgery. For hours upon hours, they discussed their upcoming procedures with someone who could understand.
“I wish all the patients had the kind of support that they do, what they do for each other,” said Moreira, the plastic surgeon who performed both of their breast reconstructions. “It’s actually beautiful.”
“It’s who you have around in your journey,” added surgeon Alessia Tandin, who did their mastectomies. ”You can face big things.”
While they didn’t initially intend for their surgery dates to be back-to-back, a last-minute change to Susan’s date meant that she got scheduled for Nov. 29, the day after Cailynn.
Susan rode in the car as Cailynn drove herself early on Nov. 28, coming home after she saw Cailynn in recovery. Early the next morning, she went back again as her husband drove, and she was already in surgery as Cailynn was discharged. The next day, Cailynn returned to see her mother, who had had some surgical complications that landed her in the ICU. Together, they napped in the hospital, holding hands.
Both women have future surgeries scheduled as part of a multistep breast reconstruction procedure. And they aren’t the only ones. Susan’s older daughter, Mallory, is scheduled for a mastectomy in June. That same month, Cailynn is planning on getting her fallopian tubes removed. And one of their brothers has also tested positive for the BRCA2 gene mutation and is planning on surgery.
As his breast cancer progressed, Susan’s father started speaking at men’s groups to warn them of the dangers of ignoring breast changes.
“We didn't know until it directly affected us,” said Cailynn. “And most people don't know until it's directly affecting them. So it's like if maybe one person hears this and maybe takes that lump a little more seriously, then that helps.”
Anya Sostek: asostek@post-gazette.com





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.