The Rev. Tyler Domske borrowed from one of the most notable memes of 2020 when he opened Sunday services last week — Wexford Community Presbyterian Church’s first in-person gathering since March.
“Please sing inside your heart,” he told the North Hills congregation of several dozen masked, socially distanced, sitting-in-chairs-brought-from-home parishioners last weekend. Humming is OK.
An amusement park near Tokyo inadvertently captured the zeitgeist when it prohibited visible excitement on roller coasters to avoid the spread of COVID-19 and instead urged patrons to “please scream inside your heart.”
Rev. Domske had the same goal in mind and a nifty algorithm to back it up. His church in Pine had formed a reopening committee and invited church elder Pete Jefferson, whose team at the building consultancy BranchPattern had developed an online tool to model infection risk indoors, to be part of it.
Called the Facility Infection Risk Estimator, the online tool allows users to input the characteristics of a space — i.e., ceiling height, heating, ventilation and air-conditioning system, how many people are in this room for how long, and what they’ll be doing there — and then play around with other parameters such as mask wearing to calculate the rate of COVID-19 transmission.
Using that formula, this is what the tool showed for Hiland Presbyterian Church, a historic building in Ross with no mechanical ventilation that sits farther south on Perry Highway from Mr. Jefferson’s church:
Read More
If two infected people showed up for an hourlong singing service with 50 other people, 99.8% would emerge infected by the end, BranchPattern’s algorithm calculated.
If everyone wore masks, the infected rate would go down to 25.9%. And if they wore masks and no one sang, it would sink further to 4.7%.
“You do all of those things and you add portable [air] purifiers — get four of them — and it goes to 0.9%,” Mr. Jefferson told the Rev. Elisabeth Hartwell, Hiland’s pastor.
“When I do this, I sort of think of the congregationalist that is asking all these questions: ‘Why do we have to wear masks?’ or ‘Why can’t we sing?’” Mr. Jefferson said.
“It was super exciting to be able to articulate it in a way that was so plainly not debatable,” Rev. Domske said.
While the Oct. 4 service was held outside, Rev. Domske still spoke with a mask and led with an instrumental musical number instead of the frequent singing that usually accompanies his services. When the congregation moves back inside, he’ll probably have a singer stand with the band in the glassed-walled hallway outside the meeting room.
Calculating flu risk
BranchPattern, which is headquartered in Nebraska and has offices in Pittsburgh and a half-dozen other U.S. cities, had the bones of the tool for more than a decade.
The company’s sweet spot is somewhere between engineering, design, public health, and environmental stewardship.
In 2009, it launched “Happe,” or health and productivity performance estimator, which uses inputs like temperature, humidity, and lighting to calculate the impact on workers’ productivity and health.
In 2018, BranchPattern was helping a financial services company on the East Coast figure out if the benefits of installing a nontraditional ventilation system were worth the cost. It used the Happe tool and, for the first time, built in a model for flu infection.
The calculation showed that the more expensive ventilation option decreased the risk of flu by 16%, which would allow the company to avoid $1.1 million in lost productivity a year. The client thought that made for a convincing case to shell out the extra bucks.
When the COVID-19 pandemic hit, BranchPattern dusted off the flu infection algorithm and used it as a proxy for the novel coronavirus as it gathered data from studies and made refinements.
Research on the efficiency of masks in preventing COVID-19 transmission became a variable to plug into the tool. So did new data on air filters.
“We’re working with the best data we’ve got at this point,” Mr. Jefferson said.
As the data changes, so will the model, he said. BranchPattern has updated it three times so far.
Initially, Mr. Jefferson said the tool was primarily a way to focus his clients on how to spend their resources, amid a flurry of emerging technologies that promised to kill the virus.
But in July, BranchPattern released it for free to the public. It’s the rare occasion when Mr. Jefferson wants his competitors to know what he knows.
By early October, the company had enough information about COVID-19 to stop using the flu as a proxy. It renamed the tool the “facility infection risk estimator.” Now users can choose between either the flu or COVID-19 to model risk.
‘Everybody cares now’
In his work, Mr. Jefferson has used the tool to inform a $500 million modernization project at a Midwestern airport and to model virus exposure at schools in Colorado — some of which are considering mechanical renovations and others that are limiting the amount of time kids spend in the classroom.
Another client, a large state university in the South, used the tool not to figure out how to change its facilities but rather how to better move people around in those facilities to minimize infection risk, which the school decided was acceptable at 10% and below.
To get to that number, the university limited the number of people in a room and put up signs that restricted meetings to, say, 30 minutes or less.
Mr. Jefferson has been preaching about indoor air quality for longer than people were interested in hearing it, which is why even the COVID-19 risk estimator has tangible metrics like number of days an employee would be expected to miss work if infected and how much money the company would lose paying the sick worker not to work.
The pandemic has brought air quality considerations to the surface.
“Everybody cares now, all of a sudden,” Mr. Jefferson said.
Anya Litvak: alitvak@post-gazette or 412-263-1455.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.