Of the countless variables that Stephen Connell, the facilities director for Pittsburgh Public Schools, has swished around in his brain over the past seven months, energy efficiency wasn’t among them.
This is not a year where he’s concerned about energy cost.
Mr. Connell’s focus has been on the health and safety of teachers and students returning to the classroom next month in the midst of an airborne pandemic.

This year, the traditional tension between energy efficiency and fresh air has a clear winner. With everyone from doctors to building consultants urging allowing in more outdoor air to mitigate the spread of COVID-19 — that’s more air that needs to be heated or cooled to the right temperature — energy efficiency consciousness might take a short-term hit.
At Pittsburgh Public Schools, which is preparing to begin in-person classes on Nov. 9 for a limited number of students, teachers are being encouraged to keep windows open, weather permitting. Building managers have been instructed to begin running their air ventilation systems two hours before people file into schools in the morning and keep them humming for two hours after they leave in order to “flush” the space.
That means if an elementary school is usually open for eight hours daily, its HVAC system would be working for 12 hours.
Read More
“We will see increased costs,” Mr. Connell said.
While some of the increase might be offset by the energy saved by having no students in school since March, and through decreased water and sewer costs due to occupancy limits, the issue is more an afterthought than a decision factor.
It hasn’t always been that way.
Mr. Connell, an architect by training, has seen how energy efficiency dominated discussions of building design — leading to superinsulated buildings and more recirculated air.
Keeping energy costs low became a critical consideration in the 1970s and early 1980s, following skyrocketing oil costs and Soviet-style lines for gasoline.
But the calculus has been changing in recent years.
“We realized that when you tighten up all the buildings and you don’t allow air exchanges, the air quality suffers,” Mr. Connell said.
One problem is that while there’s a lot of scholarship on the quality of air that makes people more alert and productive, and some about what keeps known virus and bacterial infections at bay, there is very little that’s known about how much fresh air is needed to meaningfully reduce the risk of catching COVID-19, especially given all the other variables at play — like masks, and social distancing, and how many people are in a space, and even whether they’re talking or singing.
“Can you go overboard in indoor air quality and then cause your energy use to spike? Yes, that can happen,” said Chris Cieslak, vice president of program strategy and impact at the Green Building Alliance, a South Side-based nonprofit focused on sustainability in building design and operations. “The jury is still out on exactly the right balance of outside air and energy use.”
Ms. Cieslak is also senior director for the Pittsburgh 2030 District, a volunteer program for Downtown building owners who want to halve their energy use by 2030.
“We have had some property owners, they’ve had almost a knee-jerk reaction to COVID, and they have put their outside air intakes to 100%, 24/7, seven days a week to basically flush their buildings,” she said.
No doubt, the move will come with an energy penalty. But energy use overall is still down about 10% over last year, she said, as some buildings have been mothballed and others have decreased the number of people inside.
For building owners, the message to bring in as much fresh air as possible has been coming from virtually all sides over the past months.
The U.S. Centers for Disease Control and Prevention urged opening air dampers to “as high as 100% to reduce or eliminate recirculation,” the agency said in guidelines for safe building operations in May.
The American Society of Heating, Refrigerating and Air-Conditioning Engineers — the professional organization that writes the codes for HVAC operations in buildings — has advised the same, although with much more detail and attention paid to things like energy penalty and the role of filters in cleaning the air.
At the University of Pittsburgh, all HVAC systems were reset to the maximum fresh air setting that each unit could handle, Dan Fisher, Pitt’s assistant vice chancellor for operations and maintenance, told PittWire in July.
Pittsburgh Public Schools doesn’t have the goal of 100% fresh air at any of the district’s buildings. That would be too inefficient, Mr. Connell said, and the equipment wasn’t designed for that anyway.
On average, the air inside district schools is 50% outside air and 50% recirculated, although there’s a wide range depending on the school vintage and mechanical particulars.
Pete Jefferson, a Pittsburgh-based principal at the building consultancy BranchPattern, headquartered in Nebraska, likes to qualify that not “all recirculated air is bad.” Not even during a pandemic.
“I would rather have a bunch of recirculated air if it goes through the right filters,” he said.
BranchPattern’s motto is that “true sustainability sits at the intersection of human experience and environmental stewardship.” If there’s a silver lining to people having to rethink what we require of our indoor spaces, Mr. Jefferson said, it’s that a piecemeal approach to well-intentioned goals will end in sacrifice.
“If we [just] design buildings to be energy efficient, there’s no guarantee they’ll work well for people,” he said. Yet, “most of the things that we do for human health actually have energy benefit.”
Anya Litvak: alitvak@post-gazette.com







Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.