Saying it is “imperative” that they take action, Pennsylvania Sens. Pat Toomey and Bob Casey on Monday jointly sent a letter to the head of the Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services asking the agency to report back to them within a month about how the federal government is getting the nation’s worst nursing homes to slow the spread of COVID-19
“The worsening circumstances at the Life Care Center of Kirkland in Washington State, the site of the first COVID-19 outbreak, make clear that it is essential to ensure nursing facilities are prepared to prevent the virus's spread and treat emerging cases,” the senators jointly wrote in their letter to CMS Administrator Seema Verma on Monday.
4 6 20 Letter to CMS SFF Nursing Homes RPC PT Signed (PDF)
4 6 20 Letter to CMS SFF Nursing Homes RPC PT Signed (Text)
The letter is a pandemic-related follow-up to the senators’ join report last June that revealed a previously secret list of the nation’s worst nursing homes — a list that includes the Brighton Rehabilitation and Wellness Center in Beaver County, a nursing home now dealing with a massive COVID-19 outbreak with at least 42 residents infected, and five deaths. In addition, at least 10 staff members have tested positive.
Mr. Casey, a Democrat, and Mr. Toomey, a Republican, crafted the report in June after forcing CMS to give them a list of so-called “candidate” nursing homes — typically about 400 or more homes — for CMS’ annual and public Special Focus Facilities list of the worst homes — typically about 90 homes.
Read More
The SFF program, as it’s known, lists nursing homes that “substantially fail” to meet CMS’ care standards. But as the senators pointed out, the 400 or so nursing homes that had typically been included on the SFF candidate list, and kept secret, perform just as poorly as the 90 or so nursing homes included on the public list each year.
Last year’s SFF candidate list included Brighton Rehabilitation, plus two other Pittsburgh-area homes: Corner View Nursing and Rehabilitation Center in Pittsburgh and William Penn Care Center in Jeannette.
In addition, The Grove at North Huntingdon, which is owned by the same group of owners — going by the name Comprehensive Healthcare — who own Brighton Rehabilitation, was included on the shorter and public, SFF list, as was an unrelated nursing home, Twin Lake Rehabilitation and Health Care Center in Greensburg.
A February, 2020, update of those lists by CMS showed that Brighton Rehabilitation remains on the candidate list, as does Corner View Nursing, though William Penn Care Center is no longer on the candidate list. The Grove at North Huntington “graduated” from the SFF list due to improvements, but Twin Lake remains on the SFF list.

“With hundreds of COVID-19 cases now reported in the Commonwealth and thousands across the U.S., it is imperative that we take action to protect those older adults and individuals with underlying health conditions who are most at risk,” the senators wrote Ms. Verma. “Given our commitment to fostering improvement among the nation's poorest performing nursing homes, we are writing to request information about your efforts to slow the spread of COVID-19 in nursing homes affiliated with the Special Focus Facility (SFF) program,, and to urge you to take appropriate measures to ensure that these facilities are meeting the needs of their residents.”
They noted that CMS has already suspended routine nursing home inspections to focus inspections on infection control and complaints of immediate harm unrelated to COVID-19.
The senators asked Ms. Verma to provide them with a briefing about “how CMS is addressing oversight in these underperforming facilities as it carries out its response to COVID-19” before May 4.
Aides to Mr. Toomey said his hope with the letter “is to make sure CMS is paying particular attention to these nursing homes, knowing historically they don’t comply with CMS regulations.”
Though both highly-rated and poorly-rate nursing homes have had COVID-19 outbreaks, an aide said that “when you have a subset of homes you know is already not meeting CMS regulations, we can assume they might have a problem if there is a COVID case, and have difficulty controlling that spread.”
Mr. Casey said in emailed answers to questions that he wanted CMS to “take proactive measures to prevent the spread of COVID-19 in nursing homes and mitigate outbreaks that have already taken place. I fought for and secured $100 million to prevent and react to situations just like the one at Brighton Rehabilitation and Wellness Center. I want to know how CMS will spend those dollars. With this letter, I want to hear how the agency plans to prioritize infection control in those nursing homes with a persistent record of poor performance.”
He said he would also like the federal government to provide more information about COVID-19 cases in nursing homes.
“”This information should not be dependent upon the state in which someone lives,” he wrote, in part. “Right now, it’s been reported that residents, their families, first responders and even some nursing home employees do not have access to information about which nursing homes have had a patient or worker test positive for COVID-19. This is information that could help slow the spread of COVID-19, and it is information that the federal government is a unique position to provide.”
Sean D. Hamill: shamill@post-gazette.com or 412-263-2579 or Twitter: @SeanDHamill
This story was originally published with images that are no longer available.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.