WASHINGTON — Chief Justice John Roberts Jr. emerged Wednesday as the pivotal, if inscrutable, key to whether a more conservative Supreme Court is ready to reconsider its precedents protecting abortion rights.
The court’s four liberals appeared convinced that the Louisiana law at issue, requiring admitting privileges at nearby hospitals for abortion-clinic doctors, is identical to one from Texas that the Supreme Court struck down four years ago.
That appeared to leave Chief Justice Roberts, now at the court’s ideological center, holding the deciding vote.
As the case was argued, he asked a variation of the same question to all three lawyers addressing the justices: Should the court undertake a fact-dependent, state-by-state analysis when reviewing such restrictions?
That could indicate he felt he could distinguish Louisiana’s law from the Texas statute. Or it could mean he agreed with challengers that similar laws were doomed because of the court’s precedent from 2016. Chief Justice Roberts, a dissenter in the Texas case, did not indicate what he believed was the proper answer.
The justices’ examination of the Louisiana law could be momentous if it signaled that the court was ready to revisit past decisions. And whatever it decides before the end of June will come in the midst of a heated presidential election in which Democrats have made abortion rights a priority and President Donald Trump has said his ultimate goal is to overturn Roe v. Wade.
Mr. Trump has said his judicial nominees will oppose abortion, and it was the first major abortion case for his Supreme Court choices, Neil Gorsuch and Brett Kavanaugh.
Justice Gorsuch did not ask a question during the hour-long oral arguments. Justice Kavanaugh’s questioning was similar to that of Chief Justice Roberts, as he wondered whether different conditions in states could afford different outcomes than in the 2016 case, Whole Women’s Health v. Hellerstadt.
“Are you saying admitting-privileges requirements are always unconstitutional, such that we don’t have to look at the facts state by state?” Justice Kavanaugh asked attorney Julie Rikelman after posing a hypothetical about a state with 10 clinics and 20 doctors, all with the necessary credentials. Justice Kavanaugh had previously voted to allow the Louisiana law to go into effect, saying it was unclear whether doctors had worked hard enough to secure the privileges.
Ms. Rikelman, senior litigation director of the Center for Reproductive Rights, replied that “the burdens may vary, but a law that has no benefit and serves no valid state interest, which is what this court held in Whole Woman’s Health, is much more likely to be an undue burden” on a woman’s right to abortion.
Justice Kavanaugh pressed: “Could an admitting-privileges law of this kind ever have a valid purpose, in your view?”
“No, your honor,” Ms. Rikelman replied. “The medical consensus against these laws is clear.” Later, she noted that the federal government has dropped such a requirement from its regulations of surgery centers nationwide.
If the debate inside the courtroom was reminiscent of four years ago, the atmosphere inside and outside the court was emblematic of the decades that the Supreme Court has wrestled with one of the country’s most divisive issues.
Members of Congress packed the crowded courtroom, and lawyers who have litigated the issue from both sides filled the pews. Among Wednesday’s spectators was Chief Justice Roberts’ wife, Jane Roberts, who before the chief justice joined the court was legal counsel for Feminists for Life of America, a group that opposes abortion.
At a rally of abortion rights supporters outside the court, Senate Majority Leader Charles Schumer, D-N.Y., called out Justice Gorsuch and Justice Kavanaugh by name.
“You have released the whirlwind, and you will by the price,” Mr. Schumer said. “You won’t know what hit you if you go forward with these awful decisions.”
Mr. Schumer’s remarks prompted a rare public rebuke from Chief Justice Roberts, who issued a statement hours later calling the criticism from the highest levels of government in the midst of arguments “inappropriate” and “dangerous.”
Inside the courtroom, Justice Stephen Breyer acknowledged the contentious public divide.
“In the country, people have very strong feelings and a lot of people morally think it’s wrong and a lot of people morally think the opposite is wrong,” said Justtice Breyer, adding, “I think personally the court is struggling with the problem of what kind of rule of law do you have in a country that contains both sorts of people.”





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.