When a liver becomes available for transplant, it’s supposed to go to the sickest patient on the local waiting list.

But researchers at the University of Pennsylvania and University of Kansas Medical Center found that doctors often turn down livers for their sickest patients — perhaps because federal rules punish transplant centers for post-transplant deaths but do not punish them when candidates die on waiting lists.

“I think part of it is risk aversion,” said David Goldberg, assistant professor at Penn’s Perelman School of Medicine, who was lead author of the study findings published online by the Journal of Hepatology.

Dr. Goldberg said he also believes doctors sometimes pass on a good organ in hope of getting a better one for a very sick patient.

Advertise with us

While the transplant community since June 2014 has wrangled over how to ease geographic inequities in access to livers, the article suggests another barrier may be overly conservative doctors.

Nearly 15,000 people nationwide are waiting for liver transplants, including 74 at Allegheny Health Network and 156 at UPMC.

The article brought mixed reaction from the transplant community. Christopher Hughes, surgical director of liver transplantation at UPMC, called the findings “a stretch” that’s based on “an oversimplification” of the acceptance process.

“It’s not so much saying yes or no” as carefully weighing donor and candidate characteristics to determine whether a liver will work for the patient, Dr. Hughes said.

Goran Klintmalm, chief and chairman of the Simmons Transplant Institute at Baylor University Medical Center in Texas, said medical centers can’t be expected to take organs they would be uncomfortable using. “What kind of infrastructure do you have? Do you have what it takes to do this right?” he added.

Advertise with us

But Dr. Goldberg said acceptance rates varied even after researchers accounted for such factors as organ quality, center size and donor characteristics. “It didn’t change things,” he said.

The researchers reviewed 23,700 liver offers and found that organs were accepted for the first-ranked patient 37.4 percent of the time. Individual centers’ acceptance rates varied from 15.7 percent to 58.1 percent, with many of the passed-over candidates dying before they had another chance at a liver.

“You are at a disadvantage” at centers with low acceptance rates, said co-author Peter Abt, associate professor at Perelman.

After doctors rejected the livers for the sickest patients, the organs were transplanted into lower-ranked candidates. Many of them did well, indicating that the organs were viable.

But if patients who ultimately received the livers survived, that means doctors accurately matched organ and recipient, said Ngoc Thai, chief of abdominal transplantation for Allegheny Health Network.

Advertise with us

“That tells me the transplant community, clinically speaking, knows what it’s doing,” he said.

Dr. Thai questioned whether the group of patients passed over for livers would have had a lower mortality rate if doctors had decided to transplant.

“That might not be true,” he said. “It might be higher.”

Dr. Goldberg called for guidelines for liver acceptance and said acceptance data should be public so patients can make better decisions about where to seek transplants. While some patients choose to get on waiting lists in multiple cities, he said, some might be better off listing at multiple centers in the same city.

Seth Karp, chairman of surgery at Vanderbilt University School of Medicine in Tennessee, said the issue “should be front and center” in the transplant community’s discussion about organ allocation.

Advertise with us

“But unfortunately, the community’s energy at the moment is not on that,” he said, referring to the debate over how to ease geographic disparities.

Dr. Karp said the federal focus on post-transplant survival has made some transplant centers fear a “black mark” for pursuing less-than-ideal organs. “It should be a good mark,” he said.

David Klassen — chief medical officer for the United Network for Organ Sharing, the nonprofit that runs the transplant system — said in an email that the article “contains many different findings of interest and suggests the need for additional research in these areas. UNOS is engaged in a variety of activities looking at program evaluation metrics.”

Dr. Hughes said doctors must keep post-transplant survival rates in mind, partly because they have to keep programs operating for patients on waiting lists.

“I think there should be a way to allow transplant centers to be aggressive without penalizing them,” he said. But he said a balance must be struck to prevent overzealousness.

Joe Smydo: jsmydo@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1548.