The World Health Organization tried its best to throw a scare into consumers and sellers of processed and red meats Monday by issuing the strongest warnings yet that these foods raise the risk of developing cancer.

But the carnivores of Pittsburgh, and the restaurants and farms that sell them their favorite bacon, ham, steak and hamburgers, gave a collective shrug to the news that had the national meat industry mad as a bull.

“I think for lunch, or a baseball game, once in a while it’s OK to have a hot dog,” said Doug Basinksi, a Downtown government employee, after eating a $4 all-beef hot dog at his favorite spot for a quick bite, Wiener World on Smithfield Street. “Maybe [eating hot dogs] could affect your health. But, you’ve got to have some fun in life, right?”

Others felt the same way, noting that though the WHO declaration was new, the science behind it was not to most people.

Advertise with us

“These kinds of studies upset me because they’re all about generalizations: ‘Don’t eat too much processed bacon.’ Duh,” said Brent Young, who is about to open a meat-centric restaurant, the Whitfield in the Ace Hotel in East Liberty. “Just eat in moderation.”

The study by the WHO’s International Agency for Research on Cancer brought together 22 scientists who reviewed more than 800 epidemiological studies from around the globe that looked at whether red or processed meat was associated with cancer in people.

The study’s conclusion was that processed meat — hot dogs, bacon, sausage and other meat transformed to improve its flavor or preserve it — was “carcinogenic to humans” because of evidence that it causes colorectal cancer and has a positive association with stomach cancer. The study’s authors placed processed meat in Group 1, its most serious ranking, meaning WHO believes it is as closely associated with cancer as smoking or asbestos.

The study found, for example, that eating 2 ounces of processed meat a day — equivalent to three strips of bacon — increases your risk of developing cancer by 18 percent.

Red meat — defined as “mammalian muscle meat, such as beef, veal, pork, lamb, mutton, horse and goat” — was associated with colorectal, pancreatic and prostate cancer. It was placed in “Group 2A,” a lower ranking, which means it is “probably carcinogenic to humans,” a category that includes the common weed-killer ingredient glyphosate.

Advertise with us

Despite a world in which Wendy’s restaurants proudly serve the “Baconator” (with six strips of bacon), chains sell bacon ice cream and a new restaurant has opened in Carnegie called Bakn, many said people have been taking the science behind the study into account for a long time.

“I think people are pretty well-schooled in that already,” said Ken Macieski, general manager for Hyde Park Prime Steakhouse on the North Shore. “That’s why we sell a lot of fish, too.”

Hannah Russell, a therapist who works Downtown, stopped for a quick cheeseburger at McDonald’s on Stanwix Street on Monday afternoon before catching a bus home. She said she does watch her diet.

“I try to eat as little red meat as possible; maybe a cheeseburger or a roast twice a week,” she said. “And I’m not a breakfast eater. But bacon is good.”

Two farmers who raise the cattle that provides some of the locally available beef said the study did not prove anything to them.

Advertise with us

“A relationship to cancer? I’m just not sure,” said Mark Smith, owner of PittsBurgher Highland Farm, a small, grass-fed beef farm near New Stanton.

Mr. Smith and another local, grass-fed cattle farmer, Robert Reed, who owns Overlook Farms near Karns City, noted that the study was silent on any health difference between consuming factory-raised, corn-fed red meat and grass-fed, pasture-raised red meat, like they sell.

“Naturally raised pork and beef? I don’t see a problem with it,” said Mr. Reed, who added his customers are “educated, health-conscious people.”

“At this point, I think [the WHO study] is a lot of hooey,” he said.

But others were cheering the WHO study.

Advertise with us

“Oh, yeah, I really do think it will help us,” said Hilary Zozula, chef and co-owner of Eden, a 4-year-old vegetarian and vegan restaurant in Shadyside. “Any information on what is healthy for you always helps us.”

Sean D. Hamill: shamill@post-gazette.com or 412-263-2579.