When Bottom Dollar Food on Penn Avenue opened in Friendship in June 2014, the line snaked around the block. The bordering neighborhood of Garfield hadn’t had a full-service grocery store for 27 years.
And then, all of a sudden, it closed in January, bought out by Aldi, with almost a year before the new store would open.
“Now we’re back in the same dilemma,” said Jeanette Coleman.
Ms. Coleman has lived on the Garfield side of Penn for at least 10 years, but she has been in Pittsburgh her whole life. She spent her childhood in Oakland, attended school here (she met her now-husband, Douglas, at Robert Morris University), and eventually taught K-5 in in Garfield.
“Growing up in Pittsburgh was OK,” she said. “I guess in today’s definition it might be considered lower class, but I didn’t consider my lifestyle being lower class, because my parents were able to provide everything I needed.
“Given that I am an African-American, we have a little more challenge in terms of what’s available to us in education, what’s available to us for jobs.”
Read More
Today, however, without access to a car, Ms. Coleman has few options to shop for food.
“She’s pretty much right about that,” said Rick Swartz, executive director of Bloomfield-Garfield Development Corp.
Aldi is expected to open before Thanksgiving.

Finding those at risk
In the meantime, residents have had to rely on the Giant Eagle that is 1½ miles away on Shakespeare Street, a half-hour walk or 15-minute straight-shot bus ride. There’s a Giant Eagle Market District on Centre Avenue in Shadyside 1.1 miles away, and an Aldi nearby on Baum Boulevard, but there’s no bus route that will take her directly there. What adds time is that the bus takes longer outside of rush hour, and residents may have to wait an hour between buses.
“What becomes crippling is the winter time,” Mr. Swartz said, “when you’re lugging groceries back to the community and then you’ve got a long walk up the hill if you live in the Garfield Commons Development. So it’s not a very pleasant prospect if you do not have a car. And that’s the issue for hundreds of residents in Garfield.”
Around the corner, across from where Bottom Dollar had been, there is a Family Dollar where Ms. Coleman can get milk, hot dogs and staples such as toothpaste. But there are few meats or vegetables there, and she says that those that are available are marked up.
“Going to Family Dollar is more, because you’re not shopping at price, and you have to accept what’s there,” Ms. Coleman said.
“I would get more for my money — maybe if I have $50 a week — if I went to Aldi or Giant Eagle,” she said. If she were more mobile, “I would take a big trip to Giant Eagle, and then I would take a small trip to Family Dollar.”
Ms. Coleman used to make the trip about once a week with her friend Connie Moore. Ms. Moore died recently and since then, Ms. Coleman has gone by herself.
This means checking the circulars for coupons, finding transportation or walking and then carrying all the bags back.
Having to walk is the biggest problem, especially when the weather is bad; she can lift only so much.
“That cuts down on the amounts of fruits and vegetables, because we have to carry those things,” she said. “Carrying a bag of apples takes up a lot of space. You’d have to take two trips.”
It ends up being the milk and meat — ground beef, pork chops, fish — that take precedence, with items like potatoes, onions and eggs secondary.
Ms. Coleman bought a grocery cart to make transporting easier, but it’s too big to fit on a bus. Only occasionally can she catch a ride in somebody’s car.
She isn’t sure what the elderly in her neighborhood do for their groceries.
Not all residents of the neighborhood felt the need for a grocery store. Four years ago, when the Bloomfield-Garfield Corp. started organizing to advocate for a grocery, Ms. Coleman volunteered to copy and pass out fliers and talk to people about the issue.
“They felt it was too much traffic, that it would be too noisy,” said Ms. Coleman. “It is believed they didn’t want a lot of traffic of African-Americans around in their area.”
Aggie Brose of the Bloomfield-Garfield Corp. said that residents in the community meetings were concerned about making the corner shop an attractive part of the neighborhood, but residents of Friendship did not necessarily see the urgency of the situation for people on the Garfield side.
“Some of the concerns with Friendship was, ‘Is there a great need for a grocery store on that corner?’ If you go down less than a mile, you have an Aldi opening up, and you have a Whole Foods and other stores,” Ms. Brose said.
Ms. Coleman was unconvinced.
“It wasn’t said out blatantly, but you know that people aren’t always blatant with discrimination,” she said. “That’s why it took so long for us to get a grocery store.”
Today, the neighborhood is in transition. The four blocks of Penn Avenue right off her street are in the middle of a $5 million reconstruction project that has been going on since 2013.
“There are a lot of art galleries and coffee shops and pizza places; well, there’s more that needs to be in the neighborhood,” Ms. Coleman said. “I feel that it’s not asking what residents want.”
Bloomfield-Garfield Corp. made compromises on the grocery store, doing away with a lighted sign, adding buffers to reduce noise pollution, and planting trees in front of walls to prevent graffiti. The group won approval from the Pittsburgh Zoning Board of Adjustment, and they stopped an appeal from opponents in Allegheny County Common Pleas Court.
Bottom Dollar even hired 53 workers from around the neighborhood: all for a grocery with a shelf life of six months.
In March, after Bloomfield-Garfield Corp. circulated a petition and both Mayor Bill Peduto and Allegheny County Executive Rich Fitzgerald courted Aldi on their behalf, the supermarket chain announced it would take over the Bottom Dollar space — along with eight other spaces around Pittsburgh.
Until Aldi opens in Garfield, Ms. Coleman will take the bus. And if you ask her what she wants for her new neighborhood store, Ms. Coleman has a grocery list.
“I’m hoping they have good customer service. I’m hoping they have good prices. I hope they have some jobs for people. I hope they have decent wages,” she said. “I hope they are welcoming to the community.”
Gabe Rosenberg, a former Pittsburgh Post-Gazette summer intern, is a senior at Wesleyan University.



Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.