HARRISBURG — A state judge ruled Thursday that the exclusion of UPMC physicians and hospitals from a low-cost Highmark insurance plan for seniors does not violate an agreement state regulators brokered between the feuding Pittsburgh health giants.

Pennsylvania insurance and health officials had argued that the new, narrow-network Medicare Advantage “Community Blue” plan from Highmark violated protections for “vulnerable populations,” such as seniors, in the so-called consent decrees that in June codified ongoing connections between the entities after their contract expires Dec. 31.

The state argued in court last week that those agreements require Highmark to provide seniors with in-network access to UPMC care. Highmark countered that it is required to offer seniors an option with that access but also could offer Medicare Advantage products without UPMC in the network.

In an opinion issued Thursday, President Judge Dan Pellegrini agreed.

Advertise with us

“Nowhere in the text of the provision is there a requirement that Highmark include UPMC in all of its Medicare-Advantage products,” he wrote.

State officials said they were reviewing the ruling.

“The Commonwealth will continue to aggressively hold both parties accountable when any of the protections of the consent decrees are jeopardized,” J.J. Abbott, a spokesman for Attorney General Kathleen Kane, said in a statement. “We are reviewing the court’s decision and evaluating our next steps to best protect Western Pennsylvania patients.”

Rosanne Placey, a spokeswoman for the state Insurance Department, said the same, adding that the state would work to ensure consumers understand the limited network provided by the plan.

A spokesman for UPMC said the decision raises questions about what protections really are provided by the consent decrees.

Advertise with us

“Based on the court’s decision today, it appears that the Commonwealth did not secure all of the protections for Highmark subscribers that it believed it had secured when the consent decrees were signed on June 27,” UPMC spokesman Paul Wood said in an email. “Now there’s more uncertainty than ever about the consent decrees’ protections and the in-network access to UPMC that Highmark subscribers will have when the existing contracts expire in two months.”

Among the materials considered by the judge were the results of an automated telephone survey conducted by FLS Connect, a national marketing firm, at the direction of UPMC’s public-relations firm, to assess whether seniors understood that the Community Blue plan does not provide in-network access to UPMC doctors and facilities. The survey, conducted from Oct. 10 to Oct. 17, found that about 17 percent of respondents incorrectly believed UPMC care was included in the plan, and about 70 percent were unsure. Only 13 percent understood those facilities were excluded.

The president of Highmark Health Plan praised the ruling as allowing consumers more options in selecting a plan.

“We are pleased that the Commonwealth Court’s decision has validated our continued support of providing choice for seniors,” Deborah Rice-Johnson said in a statement. “Highmark is working to provide members with the power to choose the care, place and price that is right for them.”

Medicare policy holders are two weeks into an open enrollment period in which they may select a new health plan for the coming year. Twenty percent of people who have enrolled in a Highmark product so far have chosen the Community Blue plan, said Aaron Billger, a spokesman for Highmark. Last year, the corporation enrolled 462,412 Medicare Advantage members in Western Pennsylvania, he said.

Advertise with us

About 39 percent of Pennsylvanians on Medicare have a Medicare Advantage plan, through which private insurers manage the hospital and doctor services that otherwise would be provided through traditional, government-run Medicare. Medicare Advantage plans can also offer vision, dental and drug coverage.

State regulators also asserted that Highmark had been misleading in its advertising about the new plan, but the judge ruled that claim was superseded by approval from federal authorities, and that materials promoting the new plan were clear about the coverage offered.