An independent obstetrician-gynecologist based in Shadyside says Highmark representatives have been calling his patients, suggesting they may want to find another physician because he won’t be in Highmark’s provider network next year once the Pittsburgh insurer’s contract with UPMC ends.

“That’s absolutely not true,” said Dean Pollack, who fired off a “cease and desist” email to a Highmark provider relations representative on Thursday demanding that the insurer stop “this unethical (and possibly illegal) activity.”

UPMC, meanwhile, has been sending out robocall invitations from Chief Medical and Scientific Officer Steve Shapiro, inviting consumers to participate in a telephone town hall “to make sure you have continued access to world-class care.”

In almost election-style campaign style, the Highmark-UPMC battle for patients and their health insurance policies has taken on a more personal, more direct tone.

Advertise with us

“We knew this day would come,” said Stephen Foreman, associate professor of economics and health administration at Robert Morris University. “Basically, people must now either change their insurance carrier or change their doctor. We knew that, but here it is.

“I think they’ve both gone over the edge, personally.”

It’s playing out in situations like that facing Dr. Pollack, who said five of his patients have called in the past week “desperate to know why I’m not on the Highmark provider list.”

“I've been practicing 28 years. I am a solo, private practitioner. They can’t call my patients and say they need to find another Highmark obstetrician,” he said, adding that he believes patients are being intentionally diverted to doctors employed by Highmark’s Allegheny Health Network.

Highmark spokesman Aaron Billger on Thursday acknowledged that Dr. Pollack has privileges at West Penn. “We don’t know why his patients would be receiving these calls.”

Advertise with us

Part of the confusion may stem from Dr. Pollack’s office location on the UPMC Shadyside campus, although he delivers babies at both West Penn Hospital in Bloomfield and Magee-Womens Hospital of UPMC in Oakland. He said he performed a gynecological procedure on a patient at West Penn earlier this week.

But there can be no confusion about the larger dynamic taking place during this crucial open enrollment period in which patients are choosing insurance health plans: Both Highmark and UPMC are bypassing physicians and contacting patients directly to keep them in their respective networks.

Before the robocall invitations from Dr. Shapiro, UPMC ran full-page newspaper ads listing physicians who would no longer be in Highmark’s network after Dec. 31, a list that Millvale family physician Malcolm Harris said wrongly included his name.

The stepped-up marketing efforts by both parties “are raising concerns that these recruitment campaigns are interfering with physician-patient relationships,” said John Krah, executive director of the Allegheny County Medical Society which represents local physicians.

“We appreciate that they are attempting to reach out to insureds and patients to provide information about the changing relationships, but in some cases they are raising the anxiety level and creating confusion,” said Mr. Krah. “Many physicians are disappointed at being pulled into the fight over what they perceive as business issues that do not contribute to providing medical care to individuals."

Advertise with us

Mr. Billger said Highmark has been reaching out to members to inform them about what to expect come Jan. 1, as the transition plan calls for employing “a variety of tools” including phone calls to members who “have recently seen UPMC specialists or are currently in treatment at UPMC.”

UPMC spokesman Paul Wood, meanwhile, said that Highmark “has been actively calling and writing to our pregnant patients as well to say they’ll need to switch doctors.”

He cited a Sept. 24 letter in which he said Highmark told members that while they can continue to see their UPMC obstetrician through their pregnancy, Magee-Womens Hospital of UPMC will be considered out of network in January so they might want to find a new in-network doctor and hospital.

“Not only is this false, it’s a violation of the consent decrees” which include continuity of care provisions that will allow patients to continue seeing their UPMC doctor at in-network rates through 2015, he said. “Highmark is yet again agitating the very types of patients who were meant to find assurance and clarity in the consent decrees.”

He added that UPMC received “overwhelmingly positive feedback” on the Dr. Shapiro-led telephone town halls that he said included more than 50,000 senior households.

Advertise with us

It will be weeks, if not months, before a clearer picture emerges as to which side has done a better job of winning the hearts and minds of local health consumers. For RMU’s Mr. Foreman, however, the end result of this battle of the health giants seems all too predictable.

“There are no winners in this. If you think it through in the near term, whether you’re UPMC or Highmark, you’re going to lose a hunk of your patients. This is going to disrupt physician practices all over the place.”

Steve Twedt: stwedt@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1963.