Yvonne Hudson and her wife, Lynette Asson, have faced tough questions about why they remained members of Calvary United Methodist Church on the North Side despite not being able to exchange their wedding vows under its roof.
It’s been nearly three years since their marriage — which began as a celebration in the church before they had to leave to make it official in a secondary ceremony around the corner at the Parador Inn — off church grounds.
And while the United Methodist Church made the long-anticipated removal of its ban on LGBTQ clergy and marriages on Wednesday, Ms. Hudson, 66, of Lawrenceville, said she and her wife got tired of waiting when they decided to tie the knot in August 2021.
“We could have done it earlier, but we kept waiting, thinking, ‘Wouldn’t it be nice if we could be one of the first couples that could be official under the church roof,’” Ms. Hudson said. “We didn’t run out and do the legal wedding when the law [on same-sex marriage] changed, because we wanted to do it all right here.”
Wednesday’s news from the United Methodist Church came after church delegates, in a 692-51 vote, passed several rules without debate, including overturning both its ban on gay clergy and the penalties for holding same-sex marriages, according to the United Methodist News service. The vote came at its General Conference in Charlotte, N.C., typically held every four years.
It’s possible that the change will mainly apply to U.S. churches, since United Methodist bodies in other countries, such as in Africa, have the right to impose the rules for their own regions. The measure takes effect immediately upon the conclusion of the General Conference, scheduled for Friday.
Also approved by the delegates was a measure that forbids district superintendents — regional administrators for the church — from penalizing clergy for performing a same-sex wedding.
It also bars superintendents from forbidding or requiring a church from hosting same-sex weddings.
Applause broke out in parts of the convention hall after the vote. A group of observers from LGBTQ advocacy groups embraced, some in tears. “Thanks be to God,” said one.
Delegates are expected to vote in the coming days on whether to replace their current official Social Principles with a new framework that no longer calls the “practice of homosexuality … incompatible with Christian teaching,” now defining marriage as a union between “two people of faith” instead of between a man and woman.
“There’s still some other legislation that has to come up for a vote, but that doesn’t mean I didn’t cry,” said the Rev. Tracy Cox, pastor at First United Methodist Church of Pittsburgh in Bloomfield. “I was so happy.”
Rev. Cox said the issues within the church around same-sex marriage were a unifying factor in her congregation.
“This particular issue has been one of the threads that weaves our congregation together, standing up for inclusivity, inclusion of our LGBTQ siblings,” she said. “We are a congregation that has been called by God in the last 20 years or so to stand up and advocate for our siblings, for ordination, for marriage.”
In the lead-up to the General Conference vote, Rev. Cox said she had also seen colleagues and potential clergy members turn away from the church due to the ban on ordaining members of the LGBTQ community.
“They have gone to other denominations to be ordained or they’ve dropped out of church,” she said. “To not have to defend who God called you to be is going to be huge and that will open up doors for folks to go into the ministry.”
Others in the LGBTQ community, who have stayed, including Ms. Hudson and her wife, have been left to answer why.
“People asked, ‘Why do we stay there, it seems like you’re not welcome there,’” Ms. Hudson said. “It was about our friends, our family, our choir, things we have worked hard … and we didn’t see any reason to walk away from that.”
Ms. Hudson and her wife are not alone.
Rev. Cox said some pastors — although not her personally — have found creative ways to unite same-sex congregants despite church rules.
“I think there’s a lot of beautiful creative ways pastors and churches and communities have celebrated weddings,” she said. “There are some extra steps that had to be taken for what should be one of the best days of a couple’s life.”
At Calvary United Methodist Church, Brian Burns’ wedding in 2014 to Kenneth Elliott under the roof of the church was the first and only time that had happened. The reaction it received led to more inventive ways around the church ban on same-sex marriages.
Mr. Burns, the current music director at the church, said former Pastor Larry Homitsky agreed to marry him and his husband despite the church ban, leading to backlash from the UMC community outside his congregation.
“The word got out we were doing this and people got upset,” said Mr. Burns, 47. “The people who got upset were conference leaders and people from the conservative party of the UMC at large who had it out for Larry [Homitsky]. Larry’s always been an edge-pusher.”
Since then, Calvary United Methodist Church has not seen any official unions under its roof, something that left Mr. Burns feeling conflicted at times.
“I always felt that we got to get married in the church and no one else did — almost a guilt from that,” He said. “That was a little difficult for me to navigate personally.”
The issues surrounding the LBGTQ community in the Methodist Church have led to a schism including the loss of nearly a fifth of its over 30,000 churches between 2019 and 2023.
In the first half of 2023 alone, more than 4,170 churches disaffiliated with the nation's second-largest Protestant denomination, including almost 300 from the Western Pennsylvania Annual Conference.
Now, however, Wednesday’s decision brings hope to those who remain.
“I want to just put an ‘Open for Business’ sign out and officially be able to tell everybody that, as we’ve said for years, everyone is welcome here,” Mr. Burns said.
The Associated Press contributed to this report.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.