It was during a Sunday school class in Milford, Del., when Bishop Sandra Steiner Ball got a “pretty clear call” that serving the United Methodist Church was her life path, she said.
When her teacher asked the senior high school students to meditate on what God wanted them to do with the rest of their lives, she wrote a list of options and in the middle a word came up that was not entirely expected.
“The word pastor appeared, which was a little bit of a surprise to me," Bishop Steiner Ball said. “I had not experienced a female pastor before, but I grew up with parents who told me that I could do anything that God had gifted me to do. I pretty much knew that's the road that I was going to end up traveling.”
The oldest of three children, growing up under her father’s textile recycling business that she might have taken over one day, she was not sure if she should follow the call.
Then, in her senior year at Dickinson College, in Carlisle, Pa., she decided to finally pursue what she knew was her journey. While “in the depths of the library” working on a research project, she felt it was time to join a ministry, she said.
“I left the library, and I called my hometown pastor and said to him, ‘God is calling me. What do I do now?’ He was thrilled and I was a bit scared,” Bishop Steiner Ball continued. “But within several weeks, he had arranged for me to have a meeting with the Pastor Parish Relations committee and a dinner conference where I was called upon to share my call into ministry. And so I shared that call publicly.”
Read More
In July, the United Methodist Church announced that Bishop Steiner Ball, 62, has been appointed to lead the Western Pennsylvania Conference in Pittsburgh. With experience serving conferences in different capacities in Delaware and West Virginia, she aims to bring connection and hope to the region that has been fractured due to differences within the congregation, including the split with churches that have left over changes on LGBTQ issues.
‘A different setting’
Attending Duke Divinity School, in North Carolina, Bishop Steiner Ball met her now husband and got engaged after graduating in 1987, she said during a recent interview. She was then appointed to the Peninsula Delaware Conference as an associate pastor.
In that role she learned personal relationship skills, working collaboratively within the church, and becoming a leader. She also spent time working at the local church, where she helped those “who were on the margins to give them opportunities that other places in the world may not give them,” she said.
From there, Bishop Steiner Ball went to St. Luke’s Methodist Church in St. Michaels, Md., as acting pastor, following an incident of misconduct of the former pastor, she said.
“I was brought in to do healing, to bring some new structure, hope, and to reorient that congregation,” she continued. “So that was a different kind of ministry, but it fed right into putting things back together after they had kind of broken apart.”
Her work caught the attention of the bishop serving the Peninsula Delaware Conference, who asked Bishop Steiner Ball to serve as the superintendent of the Dover District, where her parents lived, she said. Working there for 10 years in different capacities, she was able to be close to her family, her two children and two grandchildren, and connect with her community.
During this time, she was approached on multiple occasions to put her name on the ballot to be ordained and serve as a bishop, but would decline for various reasons, she said.
Then, in 2012, she finally decided to give it a shot.
“I said yes, I would allow my name to go forward, but also that people needed to understand that I was not going to campaign,” she continued. “I had plenty of ministry to do in the Peninsula Delaware Conference and if I was elected, that would be a sign of a movement of spirit.”
Bishop Steiner Ball was ultimately consecrated and appointed to the West Virginia Conference, which is where she “felt called to serve,” she said.
And after 12 years in West Virginia, Bishop Steiner Ball was appointed to Pittsburgh to now serve the Western Pennsylvania Conference, taking over the role that Bishop Cynthia Moore-Koikoi served for the last eight years. Bishop Moore-Koikoi has been appointed to serve the Eastern Pennsylvania and Greater New Jersey Conferences of the United Methodist Church.
“I think it was time for me to move on from West Virginia,” she said. “It's been a wonderful ministry, but it's time for somebody else to come in behind me, share those gifts and build the ministry in West Virginia in new and different ways. And in the same way, I'm looking forward to coming to Pittsburgh, the Western Pennsylvania area, and sharing my gifts to help and build on what previous bishops have shared there.”
This is her first time living in Pittsburgh, and she is excited to experience the city’s culture, she said.
A baseball fan and a lover of the arts, she looks forward to going to Pirates games, seeing shows Downtown, and learning about the different people that make up the city.
“My experience in ministry has been in rural, small town areas and so, Pittsburgh is a different setting for me,” she continued. “But I'm really looking forward to it. I've been in and out of Pittsburgh, I've had some opportunities to experience the ministry and mission here, so I'm excited.”
‘We have to do some healing’
But Pittsburgh’s newly appointed bishop is fully aware that she is coming into the Western Pennsylvania Conference after a tumultuous few years for the United Methodist Church.
In 2019, there were over 30,000 United Methodist churches in the United States. But due to pushback on same-sex marriage and clergy rules, over 7,000 of those churches have been approved to disaffiliate from the nation’s second-largest Protestant denomination.
Across all United Methodist regional bodies, called annual conferences, 5,462 disaffiliations were approved in 2023, with almost 300 being from the Western Pennsylvania Annual Conference.
Churches that disaffiliated from the UMC have become independent or affiliated with another denomination, such as the more traditionalist Global Methodist Church created in 2022.
In May, UMC delegates passed the removal of its bans on LGBTQ clergy and marriages in a 692-51 vote. Several rules were passed without debate, including overturning both its ban on gay clergy and the penalties for holding same-sex marriages, according to the United Methodist News service. The vote came at its General Conference in Charlotte, N.C., typically held every four years.
But even with the schism, Bishop Steiner Ball wants individuals to “get excited about the possibilities ahead of us,” she said.
“There are still those who are struggling with poverty, addiction, violence, mental health issues, and the whole purpose of the church is to reach those who are not here yet,” she continued. “I think as we move forward, yes, we acknowledge the struggle of the past and the challenges of the past; we have to acknowledge some of the pain that comes with that, and we have to do some healing.
“But [we] also need to recognize that our responsibility is to not be stuck in that and paint a picture that people can see, touch, feel and know. A picture that is full of new life and resurrects transformation.”
Bishop Steiner Ball’s intentions going into her new appointment touch on the same themes, she added. In her position, she will be connecting with schools, first responders, hospitals and outreach ministries within the community in different ways.
Additionally, she hopes to build relationships with the many “Lighthouse Congregations,” which are local churches within the Western Pa. conference that welcome those from closed or disaffiliated churches.
“I'm really desiring to get in there and work with those who want to be Lighthouse Congregations, those who want to share best practices and training resources,” she said.
To start, Bishop Steiner Ball wants to focus on alleviating the anxiety that comes with questioning one’s beliefs, what’s to come with the upcoming presidential election, the current polarization within society and the overall stress of everyday life.
Further, she looks to highlight connection within the Western Pennsylvania Conference to help them “discover that we are better together,” she said.
“I think for far too long we’ve skipped over and somehow got wrapped up in what went wrong,” she continued. “That's not where I want to spend my time. I do not want to focus on what's not going well. I think biblically, people are called to good news, and so I want the Western Pennsylvania Conference to work with me, to partner with me, collaborate so that we can bring the good news to this world. The good news that people need in order to live in hope and to develop a quality of life for all people.”





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.