As the capital case of Robert Bowers, accused of killing 11 at Tree of Life synagogue, grinds towards a federal trial later this year, another Pittsburgh synagogue is offering a lecture series exploring the death penalty in Judaism.

Congregation Beth Shalom, a Conservative synagogue a half-mile from Tree of Life, will hold three lectures this month and next discussing how Jews have dealt with capital punishment in the Torah, the Talmud and in modern times.

Rabbi Mark Asher Goodman, the synagogue's adult education director and the coordinator, said the idea is to take an "intellectual and educational approach" to capital punishment with the Bowers case as a backdrop.

The 2018 massacre is the worst assault on Jews in U.S. history, and the legal case has been marked by continual sparring and acrimony between the defense and the U.S. attorney's office.

Advertise with us

The defense team, including an anti-death penalty lawyer who has taken on the federal government in other cases, wants a plea deal that will spare Bowers his life.

The prosecution has refused to make a deal, despite President Joe Biden stating publicly that he opposes capital punishment.

The defense team has lost the major pretrial motions, most notably an attempt to have the death penalty declared unconstitutional and another to suppress Bowers' comments to police at the scene about wanting to kill Jews.

The case is slated for trial before U.S. District Judge Robert Colville in July. Three other defendants have faced the federal death penalty in the history of the Western District of Pennsylvania, but none were executed.

The Beth Shalom program will not delve into the legalities of the Bowers prosecution, but rather offer a more general overview of the issue.

Advertise with us

"We're not going to try him in these lectures," Rabbi Goodman said. "It's about the Jewish traditional idea of what capital punishment is and when it should be used."

While some Jews undoubtedly think Bowers deserves death, one of the congregations at Tree of Life, Dor Hadash, sent a letter to U.S. Attorney General Merrick Garland asking him to let Bowers plead and spend his life in prison.

In citing Judaic texts, the letter noted that "even though capital crimes are enumerated in the Torah, our sages and rabbis developed a legal system that made it almost impossible for a death verdict to be rendered. Justice must be tempered by mercy."

Jews had their own criminal and civil courts long before the American legal system existed.

The Torah, the first five books of the Hebrew Bible, and the later Talmud, the main text of Jewish religious law, both deal with capital punishment, as have subsequent legal codes.

Advertise with us

The first Beth Shalom lecture, held Feb. 27, will be taught by Danielle Kranjec, director of campus initiatives for Shalom Hartman Institute of North America, and focus on the Torah.

The Torah calls for death for a number of sins, including murder, idol worship, desecrating the Sabbath and even repeatedly disobeying parents. The most common form of execution was death by stoning. For such offenses as incest, it was death by fire.

The lecture by Ms. Kranjec will examine this harsh eye-for-an-eye world view.

"It's going to be a little severe," said Rabbi Goodman.

He will give the second lecture on March 6 focused on the Talmud, which he said "dials back that biblical approach a bit."

Advertise with us

The rabbis of the Talmud set up legal barriers that made carrying out death sentences difficult. For instance, capital cases had to be decided by a council of 23 judges. If the decision was unanimous and rendered quickly, the defendant was acquitted on the assumption that the judges didn't take enough time to consider that maybe the offender didn't do it. The rabbis also said that the offense had to be witnessed by two people who had warned the culprit that the act was a capital crime.

Such hurdles make executions rare.

Rabbi Goodman said a big concern in the Jewish tradition, then and now, is "getting it wrong" and executing an innocent.

The third lecture, on March 13, will be taught by Marshall Dayan, adjunct professor at Pitt's law school, and examines capital punishment in the modern era.

Rabbi Goodman said it will focus on the death penalty from a "Jewish cultural and moral perspective."

Advertise with us

Surveys have shown Jews divided on the issue.

One 2014 survey by the Public Religion Research Institute found that 33% of Jews favored death for murderers, while 54% favored life in prison.

The Beth Shalom lectures will be offered online and in person at 2 p.m. for those vaccinated against COVID-19. It's free for Beth Shalom members and $5 for everyone else.

For more details, visit: bethshalompgh.org/capital-punishment-in-jewish-law.

Torsten Ove: tove@post-gazette.com