Three-and-a-half years after the 2018 Tree of Life massacre, federal prosecutors and lawyers for accused shooter Robert Bowers sparred once again Wednesday over a trial date before a judge who recently took over the case and wants to get up to speed.
The government proposed October.
The defense said it won't be ready until late 2023.
At a status conference on Zoom, U.S. District Judge Robert Colville urged the parties to come up with an agreement about what can be accomplished in the next six months, saying he wants to move the case along.
It was his first time meeting the various lawyers on both sides since taking over for Judge Donetta Ambrose, who retired.
Judge Colville encouraged the parties to proceed in a "thoughtful and productive manner" but didn't impose any deadlines, asking the lawyers to file briefs on what they anticipate.
Read More
Bowers is accused of gunning down 11 worshippers at Tree of Life synagogue in October 2018. The Justice Department is seeking the death penalty. The defense wants a plea deal for life in prison.
The parties have tangled for years over everything from the substantial, such as the constitutionality of the death penalty, to the minor, such as whether FBI agents should be allowed to wear their guns during an evidence review (they are required to).
The case has seen numerous delays and plenty of acrimony, mostly over accusations by the prosecution team that the defense has been unnecessarily dragging out the proceedings.
Assistant U.S. Attorneys Soo Song and Troy Rivetti told the judge that most of the pre-trial motions have been resolved by Judge Ambrose.
The judge already ruled, for example, that the death penalty does not violate the constitution. She also ruled that statements Bowers made at the scene about wanting to kill Jews will not be suppressed.
And Judge Colville last month rejected an attempt by the defense to get the trial moved out of Pittsburgh because of publicity.
Ms. Song said the prosecution will be ready to start picking a jury on Sept. 12 with a trial to start Oct. 19. Some of those dates could be adjusted to account for Jewish holidays, she said.
Mr. Rivetti pointed out that the Boston Marathon bombing case, also a federal capital prosecution, went to trial within two years because the presiding judge in Boston set deadlines and enforced them.
Ms. Song said that in the Bowers case, the defense has been unwilling to set dates.
Elisa Long, one of Bowers' lawyers, said the reason for that is because the prosecution wants to execute her client. She also cited the sheer volume of government evidence, ranging from ballistics to dozens of seized electronic devices, and blamed the COVID pandemic for having hampered defense efforts. She said the new COVID variant could further delay proceedings.
"We are a long way from having a trial-ready presentation," she told the judge.
Pressed to come up with some kind of trial date, she said late 2023.
Bowers is only the fourth person to ever face the federal death penalty in the history of the Western District of Pennsylvania. None of the other three were executed.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.