During his years as archbishop of Washington, D.C., Cardinal Donald Wuerl said Vatican officials told him they wanted his predecessor, then-Cardinal Theodore McCarrick, to keep a lower profile and scale back his travels and public appearances.

But Cardinal Wuerl emphatically told Vatican investigators that neither church officials nor anyone else told him this was due to persistent rumors of sexual misconduct by Mr. McCarrick, and he disputed documents in church files suggesting he did know about them.

Cardinal Wuerl’s comments are part of a 449-page Vatican report released Tuesday on the case of Mr. McCarrick, the defrocked former cardinal who was promoted to the highest ranks of the American church despite years of rumors within church circles of inappropriate sexual activity. Much of the report looks at who knew what during Mr. McCarrick’s earlier career, but it also looks at his years of retirement as archbishop of Washington. Cardinal Wuerl, the former bishop of his native Pittsburgh, succeeded Mr. McCarrick in that role from 2006 to 2018.

Cardinal Wuerl said he did not hear “even a whisper in the media that McCarrick was doing anything wrong,” according to the Vatican report. “No person in this (Washington) archdiocese, no former secretary of his, no lay person, nobody, ever came to me to say that anything abusive had ever occurred, or to say that Cardinal McCarrick had engaged in any inappropriate behavior. Nothing.”

Advertise with us

Mr. McCarrick was removed from the priesthood in 2019 after church officials disclosed in 2018 he had sexually abused a minor. Previously, rumors had circulated in church circles of sexual misconduct involving adult seminarians and young priests. The new Vatican report confirms that high-ranking church officials worried that these rumors would erupt into scandal, though they never investigated them thoroughly enough to make a finding. They asked but didn’t order Mr. McCarrick take a lower profile.

In a 2008 letter, the Vatican’s diplomatic representative to the United States, the late Archbishop Pietro Sambi, told Vatican officials he discussed Mr. McCarrick’s situation with Cardinal Wuerl, including concerns about a “scandal-inducing campaign against” Mr. McCarrick.

Cardinal Wuerl, however, said Archbishop Sambi only shared concern that Mr. McCarrick was passing himself off as an official Vatican diplomat, which he wasn’t, in his foreign travels. Cardinal Wuerl also got the impression that some in the church thought Mr. McCarrick was seeking the “limelight.”

“What I do not understand is why, if they had other concerns, why did they not inform me clearly?” Cardinal Wuerl said of Vatican officials.

An internal Vatican memo from 2010 cites Cardinal Wuerl and another top U.S. bishop as sharing concern about “the possibility that the New York Times is going to publish a nasty article ... about the cardinal’s (McCarrick’s) ‘moral life’.” Cardinal Wuerl said he doesn’t recall anything about that.

Advertise with us

The report comes in the same week that Cardinal Wuerl turns 80, the mandatory retirement age for his service in various Vatican roles, which he has retained since retiring as archbishop of Washington. He was bishop of Pittsburgh from 1988 to 2006.

Cardinal Wuerl did know of one allegation before taking office in Washington.

A former priest reported in 2004 to the Diocese of Pittsburgh that he had been subjected to sexual misconduct by a Pittsburgh priest, not identified in the report, who was teaching at a Maryland seminary where the priest had studied in the 1980s.

In the course of his report, the ex-priest also told of being sexually abused as a minor by a second priest, and also of misconduct by a third, Mr. McCarrick.

The former priest said Mr. McCarrick, then a New Jersey bishop, often brought seminarians to a beach house and had “extremely inappropriate” sleeping arrangements.

Advertise with us

Mr. McCarrick would choose “a seminarian, often me, with whom he would share a double bed,” the former priest reported. “Once in bed, the cardinal would ask for a back rub or offer to give me a back rub. Given my circumstance as a seminarian under Cardinal McCarrick, I never felt able to resist his requests, and so I often complied.”

Cardinal Wuerl said that, particularly compared to the former priest’s allegations of more overt sexual misconduct against the other two priests, he considered the alleged conduct by Mr. McCarrick to be “inappropriate” but not overtly sexual.

He said, since Mr. McCarrick was a cardinal, he reported it directly to the Vatican’s U.S. diplomat in 2004.

Cardinal Wuerl told Vatican investigators it was “significant” that he heard nothing more about it.

“I never heard again from anybody about this matter, including when, later, [Holy See officials] wanted some assistance in trying to get [McCarrick] to slow down,” he said.

Advertise with us

The former priest’s report to the Pittsburgh diocese came to light months after the McCarrick scandal broke in 2018, and Diocese of Pittsburgh archives confirmed that then-Bishop Wuerl reported the matter to the Vatican representative in 2004.

While Cardinal Wuerl, and the Vatican report itself, described Mr. McCarrick’s behavior toward the former priest as not being overtly sexual, another bishop came to a different conclusion. A New Jersey bishop who learned of the same allegations said in a 2005 internal letter that Mr. McCarrick’s behavior “might well constitute sexual harassment.”

Peter Smith: petersmith@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1416; Twitter @PG_PeterSmith.