Jim Busis had a wrenching choice to make on the Saturday morning a shooter gunned down worshippers at the Tree of Life synagogue in Squirrel Hill.
Mr. Busis, chief executive and publisher of the Pittsburgh Jewish Chronicle, lives a few blocks from Tree of Life where he attended Hebrew school and became a bar mitzvah.
His first instinct on Oct. 27, 2018, was to walk over and start taking notes and photos for the Chronicle.
But his Jewish faith informed his decision to stay away — at least during the initial hours of the tragedy in which 11 died and six were wounded.
The Chronicle’s staff follows Jewish law that stipulates no work be done on Shabbat, the Sabbath that is observed from sundown on Friday until after sundown on Saturday.
Not only could he not rush to the scene to gather information, he couldn’t ask his two reporters, both Jewish, to go either.
One is an Orthodox Jew who does not carry or answer a phone on Saturdays and would not be reachable.

Mr. Busis briefly pondered using an exception to the no-work rule on Shabbat reserved for those saving lives.
But he knew first responders were at Tree of Life and recognized that wasn’t his role.
So while his phone buzzed incessantly, filling with texts and emails from friends and family around the world seeking information on the shootings, Mr. Busis did what he did every Saturday: he took his elderly parents to lunch.
“I knew our lives had been turned upside down and the newspaper we were planning for the next week was out the window,” he recalled. “But I decided to wait until sunset to contact everybody … and then we were going to get and tell this story.”

Beginning that evening and for the next three days until its print deadline, the Chronicle’s small staff poured all of its resources into putting out the shocking news that thrust Pittsburgh and its Jewish community into the global spotlight.
The weekly has a print circulation of about 11,500 and typically focuses on features and events about the Jewish community in the Pittsburgh region. It publishes wire reports about national and international Jewish news.
Its tabloid print edition is delivered on Fridays and it also has a website.
Facing a Tuesday deadline after the Tree of Life shootings, and with two reporters who take their own photos — it has since added a third reporter — Mr. Busis realized the Chronicle couldn’t compete with the volume of stories being churned out by other local print and web publications, radio and television outlets, and national media who descended on Pittsburgh in the hours after the incident.
So they prioritized their coverage on the shooting victims, the three congregations housed at the Tree of Life synagogue, and the impact the incident would have on the Pittsburgh Jewish community.
The most significant element of the story, Mr. Busis believes, is that it was an act of anti-Semitism — the deadliest attack on Jews in U.S. history.
But the Chronicle did no original reporting on the accused gunman, Robert Bowers, who had targeted Jews in social media postings.
His staff could not add anything unique to reporting being done on Bowers by other media, Mr. Busis said.
“We had this fire hose of stories we should be covering and we had two reporters,” he said. “We had to make tough decisions about what we’re going to cover.”

Also, he sensed from conversations with members of the Jewish community and Chronicle readers that “they didn’t want us to dwell on the shooter.”
Chronicle stories included his name and attributed information about him to other news sources.
The aftermath
Saturday evening after the attacks, Mr. Busis and Adam Reinherz, a Chronicle staff writer who also lives in Squirrel Hill, covered an interfaith, candlelight vigil for the shooting victims held at Forbes and Murray avenues and attended by thousands.
Toby Tabachnick, senior staff writer, talked that evening by phone with the Chronicle’s editor, who was based in Philadelphia, to begin planning stories including an overview of the incident and profiles of each of the 11 people who died.
Sunday morning, she attended a briefing at the Jewish Community Center in Squirrel Hill that included leaders of local synagogues and Jewish organizations, corporate executives, elected officials and an Israeli government representative.
Ms. Tabachnick, who lives in Mt. Lebanon, lost five pounds in five days as she worked the phone to get information on victims and attend their funerals.
“Nobody was sleeping,” Mr. Busis said.

The Chronicle added pages for its first edition after the attacks to accommodate extra stories, photos and tributes to the victims from individuals, businesses and other organizations.
Its printer, the Indiana Gazette in Indiana County, pushed back the press run for so the staff had more time to finish that edition.
As its deadline approached, Mr. Busis’ wife arrived to help proof pages, and the Chronicle’s board chair, Evan Indianer, brought in dinner for the group.
The Jewish Week, a New York publication, sent a reporter to Pittsburgh who worked out of the Chronicle’s office in Congregation Beth Shalom’s building on Beacon Street, Squirrel Hill.
The papers shared stories and content.
Reflecting on that first edition, Mr. Busis said he would have done some things differently such as sending Mr. Reinherz to cover protesters who marched near Tree of Life on Oct. 30 when President Donald Trump visited the synagogue.
Mr. Reinherz instead joined the press pool that traveled with the president, First Lady Melania Trump, his daughter Ivanka Trump and son-in-law Jared Kushner as they visited the synagogue and UPMC Presbyterian in Oakland where they met victims wounded in the attacks.
“The anti-Trump rally turned out to be larger than we expected,” said Mr. Busis.
Though the reporter from Jewish Week staffed the protests for the Chronicle, “Adam would’ve known people there and it would’ve been a richer story,” said Mr. Busis.
While Mr. Trump and his entourage were inside the synagogue and the hospital, reporters were not permitted to join them.
“It was disappointing because I thought [the President] would make public remarks and there would be interactions with the crowds and officials on the record that we could report.
No normalcy
A year later, normalcy has yet to resume at the Chronicle as the staff churns out a steady stream of follow-up reports on survivors, victim memorials, fundraising efforts, and events held in the aftermath of the attacks.
“It completely changed my whole life as a journalist,” said Ms. Tabachnick.
The edition originally planned for the week after the shootings was supposed to feature a party planning guide.
That has yet to be published “and we won’t do it for the foreseeable future,” said Mr. Busis.
“The community is not ready for it.”
Lauren Rosenblatt, now a reporter with the Post-Gazette and formerly digital content manager for the Chronicle until two weeks before the Tree of Life attacks, returned “on loan” from the Post-Gazette in early November to post reports to the web and social media and to help on stories.
Several other Post-Gazette staffers also contributed reports.
The Chronicle newsroom after the attacks “was sobering,” said Ms. Rosenblatt. “They were very tired and overworked and writing about this horrible thing in their community. And they didn’t really have a chance to process it and grieve.”
Mr. Busis credited the staff for “a yeoman’s job with very few resources to put out as much news coverage as we have.”
“To a large extent, everybody who lived in Pittsburgh was shocked and felt affected and traumatized,” he said. “But we really felt it. This was our community, our friends, our neighborhood. It could’ve been any of us.”
Mr. Busis began attending synagogue weekly after the attacks and has attended daily since the deaths last spring of his parents, both in their 90s. Sidney and Sylvia Busis were well-known leaders at Rodef Shalom Congregation in Shadyside, and in many Jewish organizations.
Reporting and writing about events so deeply intertwined with her faith and community forced Ms. Tabachnick “to compartmentalize a great deal,” she said.
“But if you’re a human being with a heart, you can’t really separate yourself out completely. I get choked up a lot. But now I’m at a point where I think that’s OK.”
Joyce Gannon: jgannon@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1580.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.