WHEELING, W.Va. — Whether in a basement press conference or in a Mass for church employees, all eyes Tuesday were on the slight, wiry, white-haired man who is becoming the new spiritual leader for West Virginia’s Catholics as their small diocese tries to emerge from big scandals.
First impressions were positive as Bishop Mark Brennan — who spent most of his ministry as a parish priest before becoming an auxiliary bishop in Baltimore in 2016 — met his new flock at the headquarters of the Diocese of Wheeling-Charleston.
Bishop Brennan spoke candidly about the “disappointment and pain” many endured in the scandals of sexual harassment and lavish financial spending under former Bishop Michael Bransfield, which which were revealed over recent months since the latter’s abrupt departure from office in September.
Bishop Brennan, speaking hours after his official appointment by Pope Francis, lauded West Virginia’s Catholics for persevering in “the vital work of faith, worshiping and praying together, teaching the faith, providing critical services and support to those mired in addictions or in need of food, clothing, shelter or medical care.”
He sought to emphasize his connections to this inland region even if he was raised in Boston and then Washington, D.C. — recalling visits to his parents’ retirement home in West Virginia and earlier to his grandparents’ home in nearby Washington, Pa.
And like everyone else, Bishop Brennan sought to puzzle out why, at age 72, when most bishops are getting ready to retire from their jobs, he was picked to start a new one.
Bishop Brennan said that when he was named to the auxiliary position in Baltimore in 2016, he asked the papal representative then, “Do you know how old I am?” Still appearing fit and energetic, Bishop Brennan raised the same issue with the Vatican nuncio this time.
“It appears from what he said that, assuming good health and I don't croak in the meantime, that they'll leave me on beyond the normal retirement” age of 75, he said in the low-key, conversational tone that also marked his preaching and public remarks. He said Pope Francis “has shown a certain penchant for appointing pastors of parishes as bishops.”
Ordained a priest in 1976, Bishop Brennan spent most of his ministry as a parish priest in the Archdiocese of Washington before taking on the auxiliary or assistant role in the Archdiocese of Baltimore.
He pledged to help the diocese heal but added, “I’m not a magician. ... I’m your brother in Christ.”
At a Mass attended by about 50 diocesan employees and clergy in a modern chapel in the diocesan office building, he noted that some of the church’s administrators were removed and others left voluntarily. “But you have stayed,” he told them. “I thank you for persevering in your service to the Lord and his people in these difficult times.”
He added: “I’ve heard stories of the suffering you have gone through.”
He struck the right notes for church workers.
“We need a good, kind leader, and it looks like we may have gotten one,” said Karen Kovacs, who works in information technology.
“And he’s strong, also, he’s addressing it right up front and working with us to get this corrected,” added colleague Darlene Littleton, who works in finance.
Pope Francis had abruptly accepted the resignation of Bishop Bransfield in September, just days after he offered it as required upon his 75th birthday. It was unusual that his resignation was accepted so soon and without a successor in place.
Allegations soon became public of alleged sexual harassment of adults and of financial impropriety by Bishop Bransfield. The pope appointed Baltimore Archbishop William Lori to administer the diocese temporarily.
A subsequent investigation by a diocesan commission found the harassment allegations to be credible and that Bishop Bransfield had spent excessively on his residence, tapping oil royalties that had been given to the diocese. He had also given significant financial gifts to several fellow bishops, including Archbishop Lori, according to the Washington Post.
Pope Francis earlier this month imposed sanctions on Bishop Bransfield which included prohibitions on presiding at Mass publicly or living in West Virginia. He will be required to make amends, with details to be determined by his successor.
“There is no excuse or adequate explanation for how such behavior and actions were allowed to go on for so long,” Bishop Brennan told his new flock. “Undoubtedly they harmed individuals. They also harmed this community of faith, this local church. My highest priority is to work with you, to open our hearts and minds to the power of Christ’s unconditional love.”
Bishop Brennan said he would consult with clergy and lay leaders on restitution. Some wanted his predecessor defrocked, but since he’s still a priest, “the church has some leverage with him to get him to cooperate,” Bishop Brennan said. “And I intend to use that.”
Bishop Brennan will be formally installed at 2 p.m. Aug. 22 at the Cathedral of St. Joseph in Wheeling.
The diocese has about 75,000 Catholics, a small percentage of the state’s population, particularly compared to its much larger Protestant numbers. The diocese has 95 parishes and 34 smaller missions and chapels.
Peter Smith: petersmith@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1416; Twitter @PG_PeterSmith.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.