Accelerating declines in Mass attendance, offertory donations and school enrollment — combined with claims for financial compensation over sexual abuse by priests — are putting heavy financial pressures on the Roman Catholic Diocese of Pittsburgh, its officials say.
“We don’t know what the future will bring. We just know this is a huge challenge,” said Msgr. Ronald Lengwin, spokesman for the diocese.
In meetings over the past week with clergy and diocesan staff, Bishop David Zubik outlined the financial challenges to the diocese, which already made staff cuts earlier this year. The diocese covers Allegheny and five surrounding counties.
Two major events, set in motion in 2018, have played central roles.
The diocese last year began implementing a plan, years in the preparation, to consolidate parishes in response to long-term declines in attendance, sacramental participation and priests. But changes in pastors and Mass times, plus looming church closures, have upset many parishioners.
In August 2018, a statewide grand jury reported on allegations of sexual abuse involving more than 90 priests over the past seven decades. Although most of the abuse occurred before 1990, much of it had not previously been revealed, and many angered parishioners stayed away from pews and offering plates.
Participation has rebounded since then, Msgr. Lengwin said. “I don’t know you can gain them all back,” he said, but some have listened as the church outlined the reforms it has undertaken in recent decades and seen it as “something the church has tried to address.”
After the report’s release, the diocese created an “independent reconciliation and compensation program” to make payments to victims of abuse.
A spokeswoman for the outside experts handling the claims said that as of mid-July, 96 people had filed claims, with 29 processed to date.
But Msgr. Lengwin said as many as 250 people have made inquiries, and based on other dioceses’ experiences of filings near deadline, up to 350 claimants may file. The deadline for filers is the end of July if they haven’t contacted the diocese before now and the end of September if they have.
He said the diocese is trying to find ways to fund compensation. It has a pending agreement to sell some of its Downtown office space. “We’re just looking at what we can do, what properties we can sell,” he said. But parish properties, including many sanctuaries and schools, are off limits for this purpose, he said.
The diocese has filed a petition in Allegheny County Orphan’s Court for permission to use a century-old bequest, known as the Toner Trust, toward such payments. The trust is designated for the “care, education, training, maintenance and treatment of neglected, emotionally disabled and needy children.” The diocese says payments for abuse victims should qualify under this fund.
The office of Attorney General Josh Shapiro, which also oversaw the grand jury report, is challenging the petition. It says the fund was to “better the lives of children, and its purposes have no correlation to the attempted use of paying victims of alleged clergy sexual abuse.”
The judge in the case set a hearing for next month.
Alan Perer, who is representing clients both in lawsuits against the Diocese of Pittsburgh and in seeking compensation through the independent fund, said he was skeptical of the extent of the diocese’s financial strains. He said he’s not aware of nearly that many victims having filed claims already, and he wanted a closer look at diocesan financial statements.
Downward trend
Attendance and offertory income both declined over the past year about 11% from the previous year, affecting parish and school budgets as well as the support that parishes can send to the diocese.
The diocese is forecasting a budget for its just-started fiscal year to be $20.5 million, down from $23.1 million in actual expenses for the year that ended June 30. It cut 32 positions from diocesan administration in recent months, with 19 of those through retirements, leaving about 142 full- and part-time positions, Msgr. Lengwin said.
Enrollment at Catholic elementary and high schools also is down, and the diocese is unable to cushion some of the costs it did in the past, such as providing loans to cover some benefits, he said. Parish schools already have been consolidating into regional schools.
The trend of decline is not new. Since at least 2000, the diocese has seen notable declines in Mass attendance and other sacramental participation, as well as in numbers of priests. Factors cited include broader trends — from scandal to secularism to demographic trends here such as an aging population, later marriages and lower birth rates.
The diocese launched its program, On Mission for the Church Alive, to respond to these trends. The first set of mergers took effect July 1.
At the outset, experts consulted by the diocese had predicted a short-term loss in attendance if it closed churches, rearranged Mass times and reassigned popular priests, Msgr. Lengwin said. But the long-term goal is to create more vibrant liturgies and parishes.
“We still live with the hope that many or most of them would return” once they saw such renewal, he said.
The Rev. Kris Stubna, pastor of St. Paul Cathedral and administrator of a four-parish grouping in Oakland, Greenfield and Hazelwood, said the parishioners have attended numerous open houses, planning sessions and other events to work toward consolidation into one parish.
He acknowledged some oppose changes such as the moving of a Spanish Mass from one church building to another.
With three priests, there has to be a reasonable schedule for how many Masses they can preside at, with the goal of having vibrant liturgies.
“We’re working hard to make the transition, but change is not easy for anyone,” he said.
He said attendance and collections have rebounded since the fallout from the grand jury report.
“I’m not feeling we’re in a crisis in this moment,” he said.
Peter Smith: petersmith@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1416; Twitter @PG_PeterSmith.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.