VATICAN CITY – Pope Francis declared an “all-out battle” against sexual abuse on Sunday as he concluded a high-stakes summit that Catholic bishops hailed as a turning point for the church, even as victims lamented that little had actually been accomplished during the unprecedented four-day meeting.
But amid the criticism, church officials have hinted that concrete policy changes were on the horizon, especially on issues of transparency and bishop accountability that were discussed during the meeting.
In a closing address in the Apostolic Palace’s opulently frescoed Sala Regia, the pontiff declared priests who abuse children to be “tools of Satan” and described their crimes as “utterly incompatible with [the church’s] moral authority and ethical credibility.” Both, he said, had been further damaged by the hierarchy’s own history of cover-up and inaction.
“In the people’s justified anger, the church sees the reflection of the wrath of God – betrayed and insulted by these deceitful consecrated persons,” Pope Francis said. “This cry will shake the hearts of those dulled by hypocrisy and power.”
He said that eradicating the scourge required more than legal processes and “disciplinary measures.”
Much of the pope’s lengthy speech, however, focused outside the Vatican’s walls, citing abuse in families and other institutions while condemning the spread of internet pornography and “ideological disputes and journalistic practices that often exploit … the tragedy.”
Read More
But Mark Coleridge, the archbishop of Brisbane, Australia, who delivered a homily before Pope Francis’ speech, laid blame for the scandals that have plagued the church directly at the hierarchy’s feet.
“We have been our own worst enemy,” he said. “We have shown too little mercy, and therefore we will receive the same. We will not go unpunished.”
He called for a “Copernican Revolution” in Church leaders’ thinking on the issue, referencing the 15th-century paradigm shift in which the world abandoned past notions that the sun revolved around the Earth.
“Those who have been abused do not revolve around the church, but the church around them,” he said.
Whether the conference that played out over the past week was enough to cement that change remains to be seen.
The roughly 200 bishops and superiors of religious orders in attendance will return home with no immediate solutions, despite the pope’s call at the conference’s opening for “concrete and effective measures” to be put in place.
Still, several church leaders said their eyes had been opened by the summit’s speakers – including an African nun who condemned the church’s male hierarchy for hypocrisy and a Mexican TV journalist who vowed the press would continue to be “your worst enemy” unless they changed their ways.
Cardinal Daniel DiNardo, the president of the United States Conference of Catholic Bishops, said Saturday that he was “very pleased” with the meeting, even though specific action still needed to be determined.
“This went far better than I think some of us had hoped,” he said. “Now you have the bishops all saying it’s ubiquitous” when, at first, some countries did not want to admit that they had the same issues as the United States.
All the while, dozens of victims kept constant vigil outside the cloistered meeting hall, near St. Peter’s Square, demanding that their voices be heard. Many of them found little comfort in Pope Francis’ words Sunday.
“There hasn’t been any firm commitment to eject from the church the perpetrators of this crime,” said Peter Saunders, a sex abuse victim from the United Kingdom and former member of the pope’s pontifical commission for the protection of minors.
Anne Barrett Doyle, a leader of BishopAccountability.org, also weighed in: “Pope Francis’ talk today was a stunning letdown, a catastrophic misreading of the grief and outrage of the faithful. As the world’s Catholics cry out for concrete change, the pope instead provides tepid promises, all of which we’ve heard before.”
Archbishop Eamon Martin, the president of the Irish Bishop’s Conference, said that the onus for making concrete changes to protect children in the church fell on the world’s bishops.
“I am always frightened about the thought that somehow safeguarding can be commanded from Rome,” he said on Saturday. He argued that the meeting itself had sent a strong message of what was expected of bishops, even those skeptical of how widespread the crisis is.
As a result of the meeting, he said, the world’s bishops have moved “much closer” to implementing universal zero-tolerance norms removing abusers from ministry.
Pope Francis has asked the summit’s organizers -- a hand-picked committee that includes American Cardinal Blase Cupich, archbishop of Chicago – to remain behind in Rome to begin translating some of the measures discussed during the week into concrete policies.
“We’re not going to delay things,” said summit moderator the Rev. Federico Lombardi. “Tomorrow starting at 9 a.m., we will be there and will start working."
Among the possible reforms are 21 points that Pope Francis distributed to the prelates at the start of the summit, including expanding roles for Catholic laity in investigations and requiring prelates to report abuse to civil authorities in their countries – a measure already adopted by bishops in the United States.
The pope laid out another eight priorities during his speech Sunday, calling for an end to the knee-jerk defensiveness of some members of the hierarchy and a vow to end cover-ups in all forms.
At an afternoon news conference, Father Lombardi outlined a handful of additional measures that he said the Vatican was prepared to adopt within months, including issuing guidance to bishops on how to handle abuse claims and establishing a task force to assist bishops in shoring up protocols to bring them in compliance with church edicts.
What’s more, he said, the Holy See is close to finalizing its own child-protection policy – a development that it had ordered every bishops’ conference in the world to complete seven years ago.
“We want the church to once again be absolutely credible and reliable in her mission of service and education for the children,” the pope said later during his weekly appearance before throngs of tourists and faithful in St. Peter’s Square.
Cardinal Cupich along with Cardinal Sean O’Malley, archbishop of Boston, said Friday that Vatican officials were hoping to strengthen a 2016 edict that was supposed to make negligence in handling abuse claims a fireable offense. (Cardinal Cupich has floated his own proposal for dealing with bishops accused of mishandling abuse cases or facing sexual misconduct allegations themselves.)
That aspect of the crisis has emerged as a particular problem in the United States, where a series of scandals over the last year, including the defrocking of Cardinal Theodore McCarrick earlier this month and the landmark Pennsylvania grand jury report on clergy sex abuse, have prompted law enforcement in more than a dozen states to launch civil and criminal probes.
U.S. bishops were prepared last fall to vote on their own set of reforms to better hold themselves accountable – including the establishment of a panel led by Catholic laity to investigate problem prelates. But the Vatican blocked their efforts, fearing that the suggestion would run afoul of church law.
In Cardinal Cupich’s proposal, floated in an address to the summit Friday, he suggested responsibility for investigating negligent and abusive bishops be placed with regional authorities, like the archbishop of the closest metropolitan area.
Speaking Saturday, Cardinal DiNardo said it was likely that the nation’s prelates would vote on some combination of Cardinal Cupich’s proposal and the lay-led board at their next general meeting in June.
“When I get back home, I think I can go before … all the bishops and say that I think there is some affirmation from this meeting of what we wanted to do,” said Cardinal DiNardo, archbishop of Galveston-Houston, in an interview with Crux, a news outlet that covers the Catholic Church.
But as Archbishop Coleridge closed out his homily Sunday he starkly described the stakes of any further missteps.
“We will do all in our power to make sure the horrors of the past are not repeated, and the church is a safe place for all,” he said. “All this will take time. But we don’t have forever, and we dare not fail.”
The New York Times contributed.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.