Westmoreland County District Attorney John W. Peck will not prosecute a priest accused of inappropriate contact with a minor in the early 1990s, Mr. Peck announced Thursday.
A mother alleged in August that the Rev. Joseph E. Bonafed had inappropriate contact with her child — a minor — on one occasion in 1991 or 1992, according to Mr. Peck’s office.
Investigators with the office found the alleged offense falls outside a statute of limitations that was in effect at the time, the office said. That statute required that a criminal complaint be filed within two years of a victim’s 18th birthday or before 2002, according to the office.
In the claim against Rev. Bonafed, the alleged victim was the sole witness, Mr. Peck’s office said. The person had an unclear and inconsistent recollection during an interview with an investigator, “making a successful prosecution of the alleged incident doubtful,” according to the office.
“It is expected that the authority entrusted to prosecutors not be used to pursue a case where it is concluded a conviction cannot be obtained,” Mr. Peck said in a statement. “Since the prosecution is barred by the statute of limitations and since a successful prosecution is unlikely, I respectfully decline to prosecute the case.”
The Roman Catholic Diocese of Greensburg said in August that it had put Rev. Bonafed on leave pending investigation of a claim against him. He was pastor of Holy Family Parish in West Newton and St. Edward Parish in Herminie.
“Now that the district attorney has completed his investigation, the diocese will follow the next phase of its policy, which is examining the allegation in relation to church law,” diocesan spokesman Jerome Zufelt said in a statement Thursday. “This is called a canonical investigation, which has already begun. We expect it to be completed quickly.”
Rev. Bonafed himself was not commenting this week, Mr. Zufelt said.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.