The Roman Catholic Diocese of Greensburg is pledging to release a list of clergy who faced credible allegations of child sexual abuse. The list will be posted on the diocese website on the same date of the imminent release of a grand jury report into it and five other dioceses.
In a lengthy report released on its website, the diocese offered a “sincere and open apology to the survivors of sexual abuse and to all those impacted by the grievous failures of the Catholic Church.”
The Pittsburgh diocese announced plans last week to release a similar list when the report comes out, and the Allentown and Scranton dioceses say they will, too. The Harrisburg and Erie dioceses recently posted such lists on their websites.
The Greensburg list will include names of some priests already known for their alleged offenses, but it will also include names that “may not be familiar,” Bishop Edward Malesic said.
He did not specify whether the list would include only diocesan priests or whether it would include those in religious orders who have worked in the diocese.
No one on the list is currently in ministry, Bishop Malesic said.
Read More
The diocese says it has improved its response to youth protection over the years and is committed to the Catholic Church’s national “zero tolerance” policies toward abusers.
That any man “who wears the same clothes I do as a priest harmed these innocent children, robbed them of their innocence and in some cases of their faith, that makes me angry,” Bishop Malesic said in a phone interview Thursday. He offered apologies on behalf of himself and the 140,000 Catholics in the diocese’s counties of Westmoreland, Armstrong, Indiana and Fayette.
Since Bishop Malesic took office in 2015, the diocese had two reviews of its files conducted, one by a retired Westmoreland County judge and the other by its legal counsel after it was subpoenaed by the attorney general’s office during the grand jury investigation.
The diocese says it immediately reports all allegations to law enforcement authorities and suspends anyone from ministry while an allegation is investigated. The diocese cited two recent cases as examples.
It said it was informed by the Westmoreland County district attorney’s office of an allegation against the Rev. John Sweeney in 2016, when it suspended him. It said there was no indication in Sweeney’s file of any prior allegation. Normally the diocese would tell parishioners why a priest was being suspended but did not do so in his case at the request of law enforcement officials until Sweeney was arrested in 2017.
The case was transferred to the statewide grand jury, and Sweeney pleaded guilty this month to indecent assault on a minor under 14 after admitting he subjected a 10-year-old boy to a sex act.
Another case involved an allegation dating back 50 years against the Rev. James W. Clark, whom it placed on leave in June. The diocese turned the matter over to law enforcement, and Bishop Malesic said the church had “substantiated” the allegation.
“While we are not proud of our past failures in this regard, we are proud of our diocese’s ongoing and continually evolving response, our efforts to protect, and our determination to help survivors heal,” the diocesan statement said. “Our parishioners can be confident of the processes and procedures we have in place today to protect children and report to law enforcement any abuse of which we become aware, no matter when it occurred.”
Parishioners will be getting fact sheets at Mass on how the diocese has responded, and Bishop Malesic has recorded a message on video to be posted the day the report is released.
The 40th statewide grand jury has prepared a report of more than 800 pages that looks back 70 years into the handling of abusive clerics and others by dioceses. The state Supreme Court ordered the release of a redacted version of the report, omitting references to about two dozen clergy until it can hear their challenges to their depictions in the document.
The diocese says it’s “committed to transparency” and that it supports the release of the grand jury report. Diocesan attorney Mark Seiberling reiterated Thursday that the diocese is not a party to the individuals’ challenges.
The diocese’s report did not address the effort by the Greensburg and Harrisburg dioceses in 2017 to discharge the statewide grand jury on the grounds that it was improperly impaneled, a motion denied by the grand jury’s supervising judge in a ruling unsealed earlier this year.
The motion would have shut down the investigation before a statewide report could be completed. Mr. Seiberling reiterated the dioceses’ stance that jurisdiction for the matter should be with county district attorneys. Mr. Seiberling said it would be a matter of speculation whether individual DAs would have taken up such investigations.
Catholic dioceses in Pennsylvania cover multiple counties. One of the criteria for a statewide grand jury under Pennsylvania law is to investigate matters that cross borders. Philadelphia is the only county-level jurisdiction in Pennsylvania to have had such a grand jury investigation into abuse in Catholic settings.
The Greensburg diocese trains all clergy, lay employees and volunteers on recognizing and responding to child abuse, and all are also screened for any record of such offenses. “Our people who love our church can be proud of what we’re doing,” Bishop Malesic said.
A Post-Gazette review of news archives has identified seven priests who worked in the Greensburg diocese who have faced allegations of direct sexual abuse of minors or of using child pornography. The cases range from the 1980s to this year. Three were convicted, while others were accused in lawsuits or in information that church officials deemed credible. None are in ministry now.
Peter Smith: petersmith@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1416; Twitter @PG_PeterSmith.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.