After Roman Catholic Bishop Lawrence Persico of Erie said Wednesday he would “forgo any legal challenges to the grand jury process and its work,” two more Pennsylvania dioceses quickly pledged the same on Thursday.
But two others, the dioceses of Pittsburgh and Harrisburg, would not explicitly rule out a legal challenge. They said they are cooperating with 40th statewide grand jury, which has been investigating sexual abuse by priests and others associated with the church over the past seven decades.
But they are not expressly disavowing some sort of challenge.
“Each diocese is separate and faces a different situation,” said a statement from the Diocese of Harrisburg. “We continue to consider all of our options in law as we move forward.”
On Friday, the diocese added that it “wants to be clear that we strongly support the release of the grand jury report. However, we are also concerned about due process rights. It’s important that we get this report right.”
The Rev. Nicholas Vaskov, executive director of communications for the Diocese of Pittsburgh, said Thursday the diocese has fully cooperated with the attorney general’s office and is “guided by the protection of children” as its highest priority. Asked if the diocese was mounting or planning a challenge to the grand jury report, he said, “We can’t comment on anything we haven’t seen.”
Read More
The Diocese of Greensburg initially declined to comment Thursday on grand jury proceedings, beyond saying it is cooperating with the probe, but spokesperson Jerome Zufelt added in a statement later Thursday: “The Diocese of Greensburg supports the release of the grand jury report with due process.”
Attorney General Josh Shapiro, whose office is overseeing the investigation through the grand jury, said in a statement:
“The position of Bishop (Joseph) Bambera of Scranton, Bishop (Alfred) Schlert of Allentown and Bishop Persico of the Erie diocese to not mount any challenge that would silence the voices of victims of sexual abuse within the Catholic Church is the right decision. All dioceses should support victims of sexual abuse in this way.”
In fact, the Greensburg and Harrisburg dioceses have already been pushing back against one part of the grand jury process.
On Tuesday, the state Supreme Court heard arguments from their attorneys that the grand jury imposes too strict an oath of secrecy on lawyers representing grand jury witnesses, preventing them from adequately representing their clients. The oath forbids the attorneys from discussing anything pertaining to the grand jury outside of its proceedings.
The judge overseeing the 40th statewide grand jury last year denied the dioceses' challenge to the oath of secrecy, saying that the secrecy involves lawyers representing witnesses not defendants. The appeal is pending.
That appeal may only be part of a larger pushback, however.
If a diocese wanted to challenge a grand jury process, it could do so by challenging its legal underpinning, alleging some sort of denial of due process or some constitutional violation.
The current grand jury emerged from a previous one that investigated the Diocese of Altoona-Johnstown and issued blistering reports in 2016 that cited a history of covering up abuse in the diocese and in a Hollidaysburg-based Franciscan province, two of whose superiors were convicted for misdemeanors related to their supervision of an abusive friar.
When more people called a hotline to the attorney general’s office in the wake of that report, a new statewide grand jury based in Pittsburgh began a broader investigation. Documents from six dioceses were subpoenaed. The grand jury is believed to have concluded its term in April, with its report expected soon.
The grand jury’s supervising judge, Norman Krumenacker III, defended the secrecy oath in a 2017 ruling, saying that a grand jury is an “investigative tool” rather than a trial and that grand juries only have witnesses, not defendants in a criminal proceeding.
It was not immediately clear from the documents in that court record, some of them redacted, what the implications would be if the dioceses succeeded in their appeal — whether it would merely expanding their attorneys’ ability to discuss matters outside the grand jury, or whether it would entirely invalidate the proceedings.
The office of Attorney General Shapiro is defending the secrecy provision as not hindering attorneys’ ability to represent their clients.
The matter is now before the state Supreme Court. The case was first identified in the court docket by the Erie Times-News.
The oral arguments took place a day before Mr. Shapiro met with Erie Bishop Lawrence Persico on Wednesday. Afterward, the bishop stated he would “forgo any legal challenges to the grand jury process and its work.”
On Thursday, the Allentown and Scranton dioceses issued nearly identical statements expressly saying they “will not challenge the release of the report.”
Mark Rush of the law firm K&L Gates, representing the Erie diocese, said Bishop Persico recognizes “real reform has to begin with an acknowledgment of the past.”
After the Erie diocese publicly listed 51 priests and others associated with the church on its website, naming those credibly accused of sexual abuse or failure to protect children over the decades, about two dozen more survivors of abuse have come forward to tell their stories. The list of those credibly accused may grow as the diocese follows up and confirms new allegations, he said.
Peter Smith: petersmith@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1416; Twitter @PG_PeterSmith.



Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.