A 1983 Pittsburgh Post-Gazette feature article opens with heart-warming words that — 35 years later — now chill the blood:
“The Rev. Lawrence A. O’Connell, pastor of St. Gabriel of the Sorrowful Virgin Church in Whitehall, wishes only to live out his remaining years near his beloved elementary school and its children.”
The longtime parish pastor, officially retiring at age 77, said he hoped “to remain here to teach religion and stay active with the children. … I used to greet them all as they came in the door.”
O’Connell died of a heart attack in 1986, his public good name intact.
In 2004, a different narrative emerged.
That year, two women sued the Roman Catholic Diocese of Pittsburgh to say that in those hallway greetings when they were young students in the 1950s and 1960s, O’Connell would for years put his arms around them, fondle their breasts and force them to kiss him.
Read More
A third plaintiff said when she was between 12 and 15 and she had a job at the church, O’Connell would regularly fondle her breasts and genitals and those of two other girls forced to watch each others’ abuse. They and victims of other priests settled their lawsuits with the Diocese of Pittsburgh in 2007.
Horror stories like these have emerged the world over for more than three decades now, of Roman Catholic priests and others associated with the church exploiting their positions of trust to gain access to children they would molest.
Often, such priests stayed in ministry under knowing bishops and other church higher-ups who put a premium on minimizing scandal and often thought that predators’ criminal impulses could be controlled through spiritual or therapeutic means.
It was 1984 that the first such scandal of not just an abusive priest but of an enabling bishop erupted in Louisiana. By 2002, the scandal reached a global crisis ignited by revelations in Boston that are chronicled in the Oscar-winning 2015 movie “Spotlight.”
By now, it may seem there’s little more to reveal.
But a statewide grand jury is testing that proposition.
The grand jury, believed to have concluded its work at the end of April, has spent nearly two years investigating Pittsburgh’s and five other Roman Catholic dioceses across the width of Pennsylvania.
There’s no telling when, or even if, the grand jury will take further actions beyond its indictments so far of one priest each in the dioceses of Erie and Greensburg.
But it could offer the most complete look ever into the extent of past abuse in the Diocese of Pittsburgh, which covers six southwestern Pennsylvania counties, and other dioceses.
It could answer basic questions still unknown. We know many of the abusers’ names, but we don’t know all of them or how many. We know how church officials responded in some cases, but not others.
To date, the most comprehensive report on Pittsburgh came in 2004, when then-Bishop Donald Wuerl reported that the diocese had received credible claims of abuse against 45 priests and deacons between 1950 and 2002 — or just under 2 percent of the more than 2,200 who served in the diocese in that time.
That report came in conjunction with a national survey conducted by the John Jay College of Criminal Justice, which found a 4 percent rate of alleged offending clerics across the country.
The Diocese of Pittsburgh did not identify the 45 clerics. Some were already named in court documents.
But as of May 2018, the total number of Pittsburgh clerics publicly known by name to be credibly accused of sexual misconduct with a minor still doesn’t come close to 45.
Bishop David Zubik has declined to publish a list similar to Erie’s, saying the Pittsburgh diocese’s longstanding approach has worked successfully, including zero-tolerance for abusers and, when an allegation arises, automatically placing the accused on leave, cooperating with law enforcement and notifying parishioners and others where the person is assigned.
A wide-ranging search of Post-Gazette archives, court documents and a watchdog group’s website, BishopAccountability.org, has found a total of 44 people associated with the church who are accused of sexual or other egregious misconduct with minors.
Those 44 names include cases that emerged since 2004.
And it includes not only priests and deacons but also religious brothers and one sister, a wider category than in the 2004 report. And it includes some cases with virtually no public details, making it difficult to assess whether they reach a basic threshold of credibility.
Others cases are solid: criminal convictions, multiple witnesses or other corroboration.
The accused range from the likes of O’Connell, who allegedly carried on his predations for years at one parish beginning in the 1950s, through various headline-grabbing scandals all the way through April 2018, when the diocese suspended a deacon upon his arrest for charges involving alleged child pornography and unlawful contact with a minor via the Internet.
If another recent grand jury offers any precedent, we will soon learn a much fuller picture of the scandal in Pittsburgh, which has often been seen as a national model for taking a hard line on abusers more than a decade before bishops adopted a nationwide zero-tolerance policy in 2002.
The attorney general’s office, working with the grand jury, has subpoenaed internal records dating as far back as 1947 from six dioceses.
A likely precedent is a 2016 statewide grand jury report on the Diocese of Altoona-Johnstown, which identified at least 50 priests and other church workers accused of sexual abuse since the mid-20th century. Many of the accused had not previously been named; most were dead, and some of the living disputed the claims.
Anticipating the current grand jury’s report, the Diocese of Erie last month released a list of 51 people — 34 priests and 17 others — credibly accused of abuse or failing to prevent it within its 13 northwestern Pennsylvania counties.
In both cases, the dioceses’ numbers were significantly higher than previously known.
Between the John Jay report and annual church reports since then, nearly 6 percent of priests and deacons serving since 1950 have been accused, according to calculations by BishopAccountability.org. Such percentages rise to as high as 9 or 10 percent in dioceses whose documents have been extensively exposed through court cases, such as in Covington, Ky. and Manchester, N.H.
On the other hand, Erie’s most recent list would still put it at no more than 3 percent.
“We know from the first John Jay report in 2004 that the abuse was homogenous across regions, so that’s at least a little evidence that we really shouldn’t expect peaks and valleys in these data,” said Terry McKiernan, founder of BishopAccountability.org. “Two percent would surprise me in any diocese.”
The Diocese of Pittsburgh and Cardinal Wuerl declined to comment for this story, citing the pending grand jury deliberations.
More than a decade ago, 32 people sued the Pittsburgh diocese, alleging abuse by 17 priests across the second half of the 20th century. Because of a strict statute of limitations, not only did they settle for a relatively small amount in 2007 — $1.25 million — but they could not obtain the church documents, which the grand jury now has, as evidence of how bishops handled abuse.
Regardless of numbers, the trail of human devastation caused by abuse spans decades.
It often takes years or decades for a victim to come to terms with his or her abuse, but several plaintiffs and others in recent years have reported abuse by local clerics as far back as the mid-20th century.
One case did emerge spectacularly into public view in 1969. Pittsburgh police, acting on a tip, raided the Squirrel Hill apartment of the Rev. Richard Ginder and found a large cache of child pornography and incriminating diary entries.
Ginder, a nationally known Catholic journalist, pleaded guilty, got probation and psychiatrict treatment and finally got himself suspended from ministry by Bishop Vincent Leonard in 1976 — not for criminal acts but for publishing a challenge to the church bans on such things as homosexuality, premarital sex and artificial birth control.
Ginder was convicted again in 1978 for molesting two teen boys, sentenced to prison and in 1984 died in a car crash.
Another public case emerged in 1978, when the Rev. Anthony Cipolla was charged with molesting a boy in a North Side parish. The boy’s mother later testified in a separate lawsuit that she dropped the charges under heavy pressure from Bishop Leonard and a lawyer claiming to represent the church.
Cipolla went on to molest a teen seminarian for years and became a signature case for the diocese’s tougher policy on abuse. In the 1990s, after Cipolla secured a Vatican ruling to return him to ministry, then-Bishop Wuerl successfully appealed and retained the ban. Cipolla died in 2016.
Now-Cardinal Wuerl of Washington and others have long cited another case as pivotal to changing his and the diocese’s approach to abuse.
After three priests were arrested in 1988 for molesting two brothers in a notorious case that drew a lawsuit from the family, Bishop Wuerl met with the parents and came away convinced of the need to take a hard line on abusers.
Two of the priests, Robert Wolk and Richard Zula, were convicted and removed from the priesthood. A third, Francis Pucci, had charges dropped on a technicality and was restricted to ministry at a convent until his death in 2002.
That year, U.S. bishops and the Vatican finally codified law that entirely banned abusers from ministry for one or more offenses. Also in 2002, Bishop Wuerl removed several more unnamed priests from ministry after reviewing their files amid the global scandal unleashed by the “Spotlight” revelations in Boston.
Several other criminal cases emerged before and after that, from a school headmaster to several parish priests on charges ranging from corruption of a minor to child pornography.
In 2014, a cascade of revelations emerged from just one institution, North Catholic High School, which operated in Troy Hill for much of the 20th century. More than 20 people alleged abuse by nine Marianist brothers who had staffed the school between the 1940s and 1990s, the diocese acknowledged.
Details in many cases are sketchy, but one of the brothers, Ralph Mravintz, pleaded guilty to disorderly conduct in 1986 after originally being charged with corrupting a minor — a boy who sought extra help on his algebra. Another, Bernard Hartman, just completed a two-year prison sentence in Australia, where he taught between stints at North Catholic.
In 2005, the public got a glimpse of what the current grand jury might be looking at when an earlier grand jury report on the Archdiocese of Philadelphia.
The Philadelphia grand jury obtained Pittsburgh records because Philadelphia Archbishop Anthony Bevilacqua, who had been bishop of Pittsburgh from 1983 to 1988, had found assignments for a New Jersey priest arrested on an abuse charge in that state. That priest, John P. Connor, worked in Pittsburgh and later in Philadelphia.
Taking on a problematic priest from another diocese was a case of “bishops helping bishops,” a reluctant Pittsburgh diocesan official wrote in an internal document. Bishop Bevilacqua himself wrote, “I cannot guarantee that there is no serious risk.”
It was an ominous admission. In 2015, the Diocese of Pittsburgh reached a settlement with a man who said he was abused here by Connor.
Shelly Bradbury, Torsten Ove, Jon Silver and Paula Ward contributed to this report. Peter Smith: petersmith@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1416; Twitter @PG_PeterSmith.



Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.