The environmental group PennFuture took its “Toxic Neighbor” campaign to the Allegheny County Health Department board meeting Wednesday, saying a lack of leadership has resulted in chronic air pollution from U.S. Steel Corp.’s Clairton Coke Works that is damaging public health.
Jacquelyn Bonomo, president and chief executive officer at PennFuture, one of a dozen speakers from multiple environmental organizations who paraded to the health department podium, said the nation’s largest coke works racked up more than 6,700 air pollution violations between 2012 and 2015, but a March 2016 consent order between the company and the health department still hasn’t brought the coking operation into compliance.
“Over the past seven years, the health department has entered into 10 consent agreements with U.S. Steel, and none of those have resulted in (the company) operating the Clairton Coke Works in compliance with the law,” Ms. Bonomo said.
She asked the health board, at its next meeting, to provide information about the steelmaker’s progress in compliance, as well as an accounting of all continuing violations.
“There is no justification for ACHD to allow this one company to continue to pollute the lungs of its neighbors,” Ms. Bonomo said. “U.S. Steel must be required to comply with the law now. The citizens of Allegheny County, including those most susceptible to harm, have a right to grow up breathing clean air. And the health department has an obligation to protect those rights.”
The latest consent agreement requires the company to inspect coke ovens in three of 10 batteries and submit repair plans if needed. It also must increase baking times to reduce emissions during pushes of the hot coke from the ovens. The facility produces about 4.7 million tons a year of metallurgical quality coke, used as a fuel in steelmaking.
The company, which declined a request to comment, has three years to bring the plant into compliance with emissions limits. It has paid fines to the county totaling almost $4 million since 2009.
Jim Kelly, ACHD deputy director, said much of the problem stems from three old coke batteries, Nos. 1, 2, and 3, that U.S. Steel said it would shut down when it announced a $1.2 billion upgrade of the facility in 2008. The old batteries are still operating but U.S. Steel has made some repairs to make them operate more cleanly.
“We asked them to put together a plan to fix the three batteries and they did four,” Mr. Kelly said. “And compliance has already improved. But it’s a process. We have to keep marching forward.”
But many of the speakers at the meeting wanted faster action.
“Better than it used to be is no longer good enough,’ said Mark Dixon, a Squirrel Hill resident and independent environmental filmmaker, who wants the health department to revoke the operating permits of non-complying facilities. “Pittsburgh stinks under your watch.”
Blaine Martin, who moved to Morningside a year ago with his wife, Lisa Minetti, said an industrial “sulfur stench” has brought back his wife’s asthma and dampened his enthusiasm for the city.
“The 6,700 violations in three-and-a-half years is appalling,” Mr. Martin said. “Those aren’t violations but rather an operational strategy.”
Sue Seppi, a project manager with the Groups Against Smog and Pollution, said the sulfurous smell in Pittsburgh’s eastern neighborhoods is linked to the hundreds of hydrogen sulfide violations recorded since 2012. She submitted a letter signed by 11 environmental and community groups calling on the health department to enforce hydrogen sulfide emissions regulations.
After the meeting, the health department director, Dr. Karen Hacker, said bringing the coke facility into compliance would take time because the department must make a strong legal case for its enforcement decisions.
“We don’t want to spend two or three years in court where nothing happens, but we are committed to doing everything we can to improve the air quality in the county and will continue to do so,” Dr. Hacker said. “But we hear you. We know it’s our responsibility to do everything we can to control emissions.”
Don Hopey: dhopey@post-gazette.com, 412-263-1983, or on Twitter @donhopey






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.