The Allegheny County Health Department has fined U.S. Steel more than $1 million for ongoing violations of an air-quality agreement at the Clairton Coke Works.

If the plant continues to pollute, its two worst-performing coke batteries will be ordered to cease operation until the health department determines the plant is back in compliance with the agreement.

“This lack of compliance at the Clairton facility has had a direct impact on the nearby Liberty Monitor, which has begun to measure increasing levels of fine particulate matter, thus reversing a long-term trend of improvement,” said Dr. Karen Hacker, director of the health department, said Thursday. “The Liberty Monitor is the only monitor in the county that is out of compliance with federal EPA air quality standards. The decrease in compliance has to be remedied to protect the health of our residents.”

The health department and U.S. Steel agreed on a plan in March 2016 to resolve air quality violations at the Clairton plant. It was supposed to bring the coke works into compliance with standards in the fastest way possible, health department officials said at the time.

Advertise with us

The plant showed early progress, but recent data have shown a downward trend in compliance, the health department said.

Data from the third and fourth quarters of 2017, as well as the first quarter of 2018, showed continued emissions problems at the plant, according to the health department.

The enforcement order issued Thursday by the health department includes a fine of more than $1 million and requires U.S. Steel to submit a comprehensive assessment of its coke batteries to the health department within 60 days. The assessment must include details of all current emissions at the plant and a proposal on how it will reduce future sulfur dioxide, particulate matter and visible emissions, the health department said.

The facility must implement any proposed remedy within 30 days of the heath department’s approval. The health department said if pollution does not decrease over two consecutive calendar quarters, the two worst-performing batteries at the plant will be ordered to halt operation.

A U.S. Steel spokeswoman said the company was reviewing the enforcement order and offered no further comment.

Advertise with us

The health department and U.S. Steel reached the 2016 agreement after an environmental group, PennFuture, threatened to take the steelmaker to court over decades of air pollution violations at the coke works.

“We’re pleased and think it’s a positive step that Allegheny County is messaging to U.S. Steel that public health is a priority and cleaning up Pittsburgh’s air is a priority,” George Jugovic Jr., vice president of legal affairs for PennFuture, said Thursday. “We’re fully prepared to support any enforcement action that demands as an end result full complaince at this facility.”

Mr. Jugovic said he wasn’t able to comment on the $1 million-plus fine because he did not know specifics of the violations.

Under terms of the consent decree, U.S. Steel agreed to inspect the oven walls of three of the batteries and submit a plan for any necessary repairs. It also agreed to keep coal in the coke ovens longer unless it could prove it would be in compliance with shorter baking times. U.S. Steel also agreed to pay penalties of $20,000 a month if the batteries did not achieve compliance in a timely manner and penalties up to $800 for individual violations.

Between 2009 and 2016, U.S. Steel paid fines to the county totaling almost $4 million.

Advertise with us

Making coke, a baked coal used to fuel blast furnaces, is one of the dirtiest jobs in the steel industry. Clairton, North America’s largest coke plant, operates 10 batteries of ovens and produces about 4.3 million tons of coke annually.

Andrew Goldstein: agoldstein@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1352.