By all traditional measures of the success of a statewide campaign, Republican Doug Mastriano appears to be losing the race for Pennsylvania governor.
But though he may be massively out-fundraised and down in many of the most conventionally accepted polls, the GOP state senator is warning observers that their eyes may be deceiving them — and that he’s tapping into grassroots energy on the ground that’ll carry him to victory this November over Democrat Josh Shapiro.
Foot soldiers on the ground say they see it: Mastriano lawn signs flying off the shelves, reminiscent of the so-called silent majority that pushed Donald Trump to the presidency in 2016.
Experts and insiders say it’s certainly in the realm of possibility that Mr. Mastriano has an underrepresented base of support, but note that there are key differences between his underdog narrative and, say, Glenn Youngkin’s campaign for governor in Virginia or Mr. Trump’s.
For one, the polls have Mr. Mastriano down by a significant margin, and he’s up against an opponent in Mr. Shapiro who is not taking anything for granted, expanding his base by day and reaching voters in every corner of the commonwealth unlike many past statewide campaigns. Mr. Shapiro also has flooded the airwaves with ads, without almost any counter from Mr. Mastriano.
Nonetheless, Mastriano supporters on the ground insist that the narrative isn’t so cut and dry. Bill Bretz, who heads the Republican Party in Westmoreland County, said there’s tremendous grassroots energy for his party’s gubernatorial candidate, and that because he’s not running a conventional campaign with TV ads and media outreach, pundits aren’t picking up on it.
Read More
“Those are maybe gauges of enthusiasm or success for a conventional campaign,” Mr. Bretz said. “But you could liken it to a guerrilla war. You're not necessarily seeing the masses of troops, but they're out there.”
In what sounds like echoes of Mr. Trump in the lead-up to the 2016 election, Mr. Mastriano has been taking to Facebook recently to tell his supporters that polls — showing him down by double digits, in some cases — are not reflective of reality. They’re over-sampling Democratic strongholds and missing the “wind shift” in politics — a shift, he says, that shows itself in large weekday afternoon crowds, for one.
“History is in our hands. History is at your fingertips. Just get out the vote. It’s important,” Mr. Mastriano said in a live-stream this past week. He told NewsMax, too, that at a recent event in Lancaster, there were members of the Pennsylvania Amish community in the crowd.
A poll this past week by USA Today and Suffolk University had Mr. Shapiro in the lead 48% to 37% over Mr. Mastriano. That’s been consistent with most of the polling in recent weeks, but the Mastriano camp is encouraged by a poll conducted by the Republican-funded Trafalgar Group, which pinned Mr. Shapiro’s lead at 2 points, within the margin of error, according to ABC27.
FiveThirtyEight, which rates pollsters on historical accuracy and methodology, gives Trafalgar an “A-“ rating. That’s higher than the “B+” it gives Suffolk University.
Mr. Mastriano and his supporters have likened his underdog status to Mr. Youngkin’s rise in Virginia, as well as Florida Gov. Ron DeSantis’ election and Mr. Trump’s in 2016. To hammer that point home, Mr. Mastriano says Mr. DeSantis cautioned him, in a visit to Pittsburgh in August, to “stay away from those polls.” Polls are used to discourage people from going out to vote, Mr. Mastriano has said.
Democratic insiders and analysts say that from the looks of it, Mr. Mastriano’s campaign isn’t doing some of the things that made them squirm about Mr. Trump’s or Mr. Youngkin’s prospects. Notably, Mr. Mastriano isn’t raising the same amount of money, hasn’t been on TV consistently with advertisements, isn’t getting help from some of the institutional GOP groups like the Republican Governors Association and isn’t engaging with the media as a means to get his message out.
Mr. Trump got “as much free media as you could ever want,” noted Christopher Borick, director of the Muhlenberg College Institute of Public Opinion.
Mike Mikus, a prominent Democratic strategist in Western Pennsylvania, said Mr. Shapiro, meanwhile, is doing all the things a candidate is supposed to do, from fundraising and organizing to crafting a solid message. Over the past four months, Mr. Shapiro outspent Mr. Mastriano by more than 27 to 1, spending more than $27 million on the race.
“Every candidate that I’ve ever consulted, I’ve said to always run like you’re 10 points behind, and I expect Josh Shapiro to do that all the way through Election Day,” Mr. Mikus said. “That said, Mastriano ain’t no Youngkin. He ain’t no DeSantis. They had money, he does not.”
In response to a Post-Gazette inquiry about what they’re seeing on the ground that makes them confident the polls are wrong, a Mastriano campaign spokesperson responded — in an email — that the polling industry is plagued by many of the same issues that were exposed in the 2016 cycle.
“The devil is in the details with these polls — corporate media buys polls to discourage voters from turning out,” the spokesperson said. “But they frequently oversample women, Democrats, and college-educated voters — and often only poll registered voters, instead of likely voters.”
The Mastriano spokesperson noted that pollsters didn’t accurately predict the outcome of the May GOP primary that the candidate won by a blowout margin. Most polls had him up by double digits, yes, but he ended up winning by about 24% over second-place finisher Lou Barletta.
“Our campaign is propelled by a powerful grassroots movement that is determined to restore freedom in Pennsylvania, which is why Doug Mastriano will defeat his opponent in November,” the Mastriano spokesperson added.
Mr. Borick said there’s no doubt that Mr. Mastriano has a passionate base of supporters, but it begs the question: is it big enough to carry him to victory? His following is loyal, Mr. Borick said, “but he’s not a figure like Donald Trump who could rely on past name recognition.”
Mr. Borick said Mr. Mastriano’s success will “truly rely on having exceptional mobilization of the grassroots that we really haven’t seen before in Pennsylvania.”
Supporters: Energy there
Ron Werkmeister, a Mastriano supporter in Bethel Park, said when he talks to undecideds and even Shapiro supporters about the facts of the race, the energy is there for Mr. Mastriano. He said people come to understand that Mr. Mastriano is not the candidate that the prevailing narrative has made him out to be.
Mr. Werkmeister said he tells voters that Mr. Mastriano is a patriot and a defender of the country, of parents and families and of the Constitution. He insists that the momentum is changing in the race.
“I'm a believer that it’s a very close race — that it’s just where, we need to get the message out,” Mr. Werkmeister said. “I would not be surprised if Mastriano won by 10%.”
“He could lose by 10% if we just sleep and don't get the facts out,” he added.
Mr. Mastriano’s supporters note that he’s been assembling his following since the early days of the COVID-19 pandemic, well before he announced his bid for governor. He became one of the leading voices railing against mandates and lockdowns and opposing Democratic Gov. Tom Wolf’s mitigation efforts.
Mr. Bretz said Mr. Mastriano made a real impression with people during the pandemic, and now, there remains enthusiasm for him.
“I can’t keep Doug Mastriano yard signs in stock,” Mr. Bretz said. Asked if it was like that for Republican gubernatorial contender Scott Wagner’s run against Mr. Wolf in 2018, he said it wasn’t. There wasn’t the same passion.
“You saw that [passion] with Donald Trump. That’s really the only thing that I can liken that to,” Mr. Bretz said.
Mr. Borick noted that in Mr. Trump’s case in 2016, his opponent, Hillary Clinton, had about as big an unfavorable rating toward the end of the race as the Republican. This isn’t the case so far in the gubernatorial race; Mr. Mastriano hasn’t been able to drive down Mr. Shapiro’s favorables.
In the USA Today/Suffolk poll, Mr. Mastriano’s favorable-unfavorable rating was split at 31%-47%, while Mr. Shapiro’s was almost precisely the opposite: 46% favorable, 31% unfavorable.
In a statement, Shapiro spokesman Manuel Bonder said the candidate is focused on “bringing people together all across Pennsylvania” and talking about the issues that matter most.
“That is what this campaign is about, and we will keep running hard to build a broad coalition of Democrats, Republicans, and Independents to win in November and build a better future for Pennsylvania,” Mr. Bonder said.
The election is Nov. 8. The deadline to register to vote is Oct. 24. Learn more about how to vote here.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.