Voters made Lincoln Kretchmar the first Democratic mayor of Beaver in at least 80 years

In a small Chester County borough, the state’s first openly transgender mayor, Democrat Erica Deuso, was elected.

And in Bucks County, voters picked Joe Khan to be the county’s first Democratic district attorney in modern history — the same day Democrat Danny Ceisler ousted incumbent Fred Harran in the sheriff’s race.

Nearly every corner of the country’s largest swing state saw Democrats maintain and flip seats in public office, from mayoral races to school board elections.

Advertise with us

Even in Allegheny County, with by far the most registered Republicans of any county in the state, Democrats flipped seats and voted to retain Democratic Supreme Court justices — and Mayor-elect Corey O’Connor won every district in the city of Pittsburgh in defeating Republican Tony Moreno, garnering at least 29,400 more votes than fellow Democrat Ed Gainey did in 2021.

“When you look at other places across the country, literally every major race is moving in the same direction,” said Christopher Nicholas, a Harrisburg-based GOP consultant. 

The success for Democrats transcended Pennsylvania — and served as a rebuke of President Donald Trump’s agenda, analysts and political operatives told the Post-Gazette.

In Allegheny County, Democrats, Republicans and analysts agreed on at least one thing: Voters set out to send messages to Washington, D.C., and the Republican Party.

“What happened in Allegheny County and in Pennsylvania is a conversation with these broader national factors,” said Christopher Borick, director of the Muhlenberg College Institute of Public Opinion. “This is a clear picture of dissatisfaction. People don’t like where the country is headed.” 

Advertise with us

Sending a message

Tuesday’s results reflect what political experts refer to as a “wave election,” when one political party makes substantial gains and creates an electoral shift. 

While it can be expected that a party sees more wins after losing a presidential election, the scope of Democratic dominance shocked many.

Mr. Nicholas argued that wave elections — especially one of this magnitude — can lead to candidates “who did not deserve to win” getting voted into office. 

“They were at the right place at the right time,” he said. “Voters wanted change away from the Republicans.”

Those feelings were made clear on Monday, the day before millions of voters cast their ballots in municipal and statewide elections nationwide. 

Advertise with us

That day, Trump’s net approval rating for his second term hit a low of negative-18%, according to the Economist. 

Ten months prior, on Feb. 3, he was at 2% positive. 

The state of the economy seemed to drive the dissatisfaction, according to voter polling done by the Associated Press. 

In New Jersey, where voters elected a Democratic governor a year after Kamala Harris earned the lowest percentage of votes for a Democratic presidential candidate since 1992, there was concern about property taxes. 

Virginians, who flipped partisan control of the governor’s office to Democrat Abigail Spanberger, who will become the state’s first female governor, said they were feeling the effects of government layoffs and funding cuts. 

Advertise with us

New York City residents said the cost of living there was a “major problem.” They voted for a Democratic socialist, Zohran Mamdani, to lead their city as mayor.

While there was no exit polling data available for Pennsylvania, political analysts and members of both parties agreed that the government shutdown, which began Oct. 1, played a large role in Tuesday’s results and voter turnout.

“The impacts of the shutdown hit right around the time of the election … and voters were definitely sending a message to the Republican Party that they don’t like how things are going,” said Jason Richey, chairman of the Republican Committee of Allegheny County. 

But even before federal employees missed their first paychecks and food stamps were held up, discontent was bubbling across Western Pennsylvania. 

From Downtown Pittsburgh to Butler County, thousands of people flooded the streets for the “No Kings” rally on Oct. 18 to protest actions of the Trump administration. 

Advertise with us

“We have been building up to this moment. It didn’t appear out of nowhere,” said Tracy Baton, director of Indivisible Pittsburgh, which organized the Downtown event.

Several political analysts told the Post-Gazette they believe new voters may have been drawn to the sense of community and empowerment that came out of such rallies.

“Anytime you can get millions of people across the country to show up on a Saturday afternoon to let their voices be heard, it gets them more engaged and more invested,” said one Pittsburgh-based Democratic consultant.

A desire to engage

Ruth Quint, co-president of the League of Women Voters of Greater Pittsburgh, said that even people who hesitate to participate in protests — for fear of jeopardizing their jobs or compromising their safety — are more actively engaging in politics.

“These people do not join the protests, but this sense of intimidation makes them highly motivated to express their opposition by voting,” she said. 

Advertise with us

Ms. Quint described a rise in voter engagement and a shift to a younger, more diverse generation of leadership in the county.

“So there is a sense that change is possible here and that voters can make a difference,” she said.

In 2025, there were more than 913,000 registered voters in the county — up nearly 13,000 from 2023, a Post-Gazette data analysis showed. 

But voter registration and participating in political rallies don’t always translate to high turnout. That wasn’t the case Tuesday.

In Pittsburgh, turnout increased by more than one-third compared to the mayoral election in 2021. And for the statewide retention election for three Pennsylvania Supreme Court justices, turnout jumped by nearly two-thirds compared to the 2017 retention election.

Advertise with us

While court retention races can typically fly under the radar, they gained a heightened level of advertising — and funding — from both political parties, which planted “vote yes” and “vote no” signs across the state.

Douglas Keith, deputy director of the Democracy program at the Brennan Center for Justice, told the New York Times he estimated that $15 million was spent in favor of keeping the justices and about $5.5 million being spent against them.

Some community organizations also jumped in on the effort to spread awareness. 

In addition to organizing rallies, Indivisible Pittsburgh trained volunteers on how to educate voters on the importance of this year’s statewide judicial retention election.

At Pittsburgh Pride events this summer, Ms. Baton noted that the thing that got young engaged the most was when she mentioned things they cared about.

Advertise with us

“Voting rights, reproductive rights, LGBTQ right to marry – these are all a part of judicial retention. And it was those issues that people were fired up about; it was about protecting their rights and protecting their neighbors’ rights,” she said.

Voters kept Justices Christine Donohue, Kevin Dougherty and David Wecht on the bench for another 10 years, preserving the court’s 5-2 Democratic majority.

“Unfortunately, out-of-state special interests, unions, and trial lawyers were the big winners on Tuesday — not the people of Pennsylvania,” Matthew Brouillette, president and CEO of the conservative Commonwealth Partners Chamber of Entrepreneurs, told the Post-Gazette in a statement. 

‘Ominous’ outlook for GOP?

The results from Tuesday also had strategists and operatives wondering how Pennsylvanians might vote in the 2026 midterm elections, when U.S. House seats will be on the ballot along with the race for governor.

“Things are looking ominous,” said Mr. Borick of the Muhlenberg College Institute of Public Opinion. “A lot of these conditions are likely to still be in place a year from now, and if so, there will be a price to pay for Republicans.”

Advertise with us

He said he’s most interested in seeing how future campaigning plays out as members of the party grapple with whether to align themselves with national party leadership and the presidential administration — or try to distance themselves. 

“Failure breeds division,” he said.

At the University of Pittsburgh, Julia Cassidy, a junior and president of the Pitt College Republicans, said she thinks the results will motivate the party heading into the next election cycle.

“Seeing such a large sweep like that in our county, and also across the board with the elections in New Jersey and Virginia, I think it actually kind of gives Republicans a kick in the behind a little bit to do a better job heading into the midterm,” she said.

She added that members of her club plan to join Pennsylvania Treasurer Stacy Garrity’s campaign in her run for governor. In addition to the club’s weekly meetings and voter registration events, they’ll knock on doors and attend Ms. Garrity’s events in the coming months.

Advertise with us

Mr. Richey, chairman of the Republican Committee of Allegheny County, said he believes this election cycle was impacted by a “one-time intervening event” — the federal shutdown — and he remains hopeful that “good days are ahead.”

In preparation for 2026, Mr. Richey said the top priorities are expanding the county party’s local committees, training all candidates in door-knocking and ways to engage voters, and getting more members to sign up for mail-in ballots.

“If we do that, I think we’re going to be fine in the next election,” he said.