A quarter century ago, Allegheny County entered the new millennium with a reimagined local governmental structure, leaving its three-person county commission in the past to adopt a more expansive 15-member council.
In the years since, the Allegheny County Council has maintained bipartisan representation — one Republican and one Democrat — in its two at-large seats.
In January, for the first time ever, that won’t be true as a former Democrat-turned-Labor-Party candidate defeated a Republican in the general election Tuesday.
Alex Rose was elected to the at-large seat formerly held by Republican Sam DeMarco, who resigned earlier this year to work for U.S. Sen. Dave McCormick. The seat has been filled in the interim by Mike Embrescia, a Republican who sought election to a full term but lost as a blue wave swept Democrats into office across the state and country.
Mr. Rose’s election represents a situation some creators of the county charter did not consider likely two decades ago when they were trying to ensure political balance in the new government — that someone running as an independent could garner enough support to win an at-large seat.
“I was a little shocked to be honest,” said magisterial district judge and former Pennsylvania House Rep. Ralph Kaiser, who helped draft the Allegheny County Home Rule Charter.
Read More
The creation of the county charter and Mr. Kaiser’s involvement with it stems back to the 1984 closure of the U.S. Steel Duquesne Works, where Mr. Kaiser had worked for more than a decade.
The impact of that closure and of others across the Mon Valley — where blight began to set in — stuck with Mr. Kaiser, a Democrat, as he considered his next career choice.
In 1988, Mr. Kaiser took out a loan, printed thousands of pieces of campaign literature and began knocking on doors. It paid off when he successfully ousted Republican state Rep. Raymond Book, who had represented the 41st legislative district for three terms.
A decade later, Mr. Kaiser began working with the Allegheny Conference on Community Development to figure out how to combat blight and bring more jobs to the region after watching thousands of people lose work due to the closure of the steel mills.

After studying how other county governments were structured, they decided to propose replacing the three-person commission with a county executive and a 15-person county council that would give more targeted representation to communities hard hit by the collapse of heavy industry.
“The county council took care of the neighborhoods,” Mr. Kaiser said. “The neighborhoods meant so much to me because if you have strong neighborhoods, you have strong communities. Strong communities equal less blight and less crime.”
During an election on May 1, 1998, voters approved the charter, which went into effect in 2000.
Most of the new council members would be assigned to specific neighborhoods — such as a district that includes Braddock, Monroeville, North Versailles, Plum and Turtle Creek and another that covers places like Aspinwall, Etna, Fox Chapel, Hampton, Sharpsburg and West Deer — but the charter also included two at-large seats representing the entire county.
To ensure balanced leadership, the draftees of the charter included a rule prohibiting the same party from holding both at-large seats. The previous county commission had, for years, been dominated by either a Republican or Democratic majority as the parties battled for control of the region’s largest government.
Mr. Kaiser said those drafting the charter did not think of a situation like the one that played out in the election on Tuesday, which effectively upended that bipartisan leadership model.
“It was a bit of a curve thrown to me because I didn’t think that would ever happen,” he said.

Although he ran as a member of the Labor Party, Mr. Rose — an Erie native who lives in Squirrel Hill — had been a Democrat for years, and had worked on campaigns for Hillary Clinton, Kamala Harris and Gov. Josh Shapiro. He said earlier this year that he switched his party registration to independent so he could run for the council seat.
Ahead of his election, he also worked with the county’s Democratic committee to challenge Green Party candidate Theron Gillland Jr.’s attempt to get on the general election ballot. Mr. Gilland withdrew from the race weeks later.
Mr. Rose’s longtime involvement with the Democratic Party drew the ire of Allegheny County Republicans, who branded Mr. Rose’s registration switch a ruse to insert Democrats in both at-large seats.
“This is an attempt by the ‘progressive left,’ socialist Democrats, and Democrats to take over the Republican at-large spot on County Council,” Jason Richey, chairman of the Republican Committee of Allegheny County wrote in a campaign email in April urging people not to sign Mr. Rose’s election petition. Mr. Richey called the attempt “illegal and against the spirit of the law.”
Mr. Embrescia — who was appointed to the seat in January — sued the county board of elections and council in the spring, contending that he did not need to take part in this election but should hold the seat until Mr. DeMarco’s term concluded at the end of 2026.
In July, Mr. Embrescia told the Post-Gazette that he believed he did not need to run — and that the county charter was written to ensure Republicans held an at-large seat and a spot on the county’s Board of Elections.
“There is no doubt that the method of electing at-large members of County Council was intended to protect and preserve minority party representation within County government,” Mr. Embrescia said in court filings.
But the charter says only that two people of the same party cannot hold both at-large seats, not that one is guaranteed for Republicans, Allegheny County Common Pleas Judge John McVay noted in his ruling against Mr. Embrescia.
During an October 1997 meeting of the group that drafted the document, Brian Jensen, former senior vice president at the Allegheny Conference, noted that “somebody could run as an independent,” according to a transcript that is now part of a special collection that Mr. Kaiser donated to the University of Pittsburgh’s library.
“While [Mr. Embrescia] is correct in asserting that the [Allegheny County Home Rule Charter] aimed to protect minority party representation, the legislative record demonstrates that the intent extended beyond mere minority party protections,” Judge McVay wrote in a June ruling.
That ruling was affirmed in September by the Pennsylvania Supreme Court which said that Mr. Embrescia did, in fact, need to run against Mr. Rose, who had gathered enough signatures to get on the ballot.
While Mr. Rose’s right to enter the at-large race as an independent was outlined by the framers of the county charter, Mr. Kaiser said he always considered it a long shot.
“You wouldn’t expect a third-party candidate to win,” he said.
Following Tuesday’s election, Allegheny County Council will be dominated by 13 Democrats and Mr. Rose. The council’s lone Republican is Suzanne Filiaggi in District 2.
“Hopefully, everyone will work together,” Mr. Kaiser said.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.