WASHINGTON — Sen. Bob Casey on Thursday conceded a contentious and costly U.S. Senate race to Republican challenger David McCormick, marking the close of nearly 20 years in the Senate for one of Pennsylvania’s best-known politicians and sealing yet another loss for Democrats on Capitol Hill just as the second Trump administration is poised to come to power.

Announced in a speech Mr. Casey shared in a social media video Thursday evening, the concession came after mounting pressure from Republicans across the country who said the three-term Democrat had no chance of overcoming Mr. McCormick’s nearly 17,000-vote margin even with thousands of ballots embroiled in court and an automatic recount already underway.

“Thank you for your trust in me for all these years, Pennsylvania,” the characteristically reserved Mr. Casey, 64, said straight into the camera. “It has been the honor of my lifetime.”

According to the McCormick campaign, Mr. Casey had netted only seven additional votes after 16 counties had completed recounts thus far.

Advertise with us

First elected in 2006, Mr. Casey was the son of a popular former governor and he previously served as auditor general and state treasurer. He has long been one of Pennsylvania’s most well-known politicians, perhaps second only to his friend and fellow Scranton native President Joe Biden. Until this year, Mr. Casey had won each of his Senate races by at least 9 percentage points, and he received more votes than President Barack Obama in Pennsylvania in 2012.

“I want to thank the people of Pennsylvania for granting me the privilege of serving them for 28 consecutive years in public office,” he said. “Every day I served in public office, I fought for Pennsylvania workers, our children, seniors, people with disabilities and our veterans.”

Mr. Casey added that he called his Republican opponent to congratulate him.

Mr. McCormick, 59, is a former hedge fund CEO and Army veteran who previously served treasury and national security roles in the George W. Bush administration. He narrowly lost a 2022 Senate primary bid to celebrity doctor Mehmet Oz, who later lost to Democrat John Fetterman.

"Senator Bob Casey dedicated his career to bettering our commonwealth,” Mr. McCormick said in a statement.

Advertise with us

As he did in a victory speech in Pittsburgh after the Associated Press called the race two weeks ago, Mr. McCormick thanked the senator and his family “for their decades of service, hard work and personal sacrifice.”

"I am so honored to represent every single citizen in Pennsylvania in the United States Senate and will fight for you every day,” Mr. McCormick added.

Most Republicans had maintained that the race should be long over, including Mr. McCormick himself, who had urged Mr. Casey to concede.

But Mr. McCormick’s lead dipped to below 18,000 votes last week, well within the margin of the half-percentage-point needed to trigger an automatic recount. The recount was poised to be completed by Tuesday, with the final results coming from the State Department Wednesday.

Mr. McCormick, who rode a wave of support for President-Elect Donald Trump across many demographics, allowed a recount to go forward in 2022 after he lost to Dr. Oz by fewer than 1,000 votes. His campaign told reporters last week that no recount in Pennsylvania or elsewhere had ever flipped an election when the margin was anywhere near Mr. McCormick’s lead this year.

Advertise with us

“I also recognize what it's like to lose a close election,” Mr. McCormick said in his victory speech two days after Election Day. “But Senator Casey is going to have to work through this, and so I wish him the best and his family the best.”

Mr. Casey on Thursday said the race was “one of the closest in our commonwealth’s history — decided by less than a quarter of a point.”

“I am grateful to the thousands of people who worked to make sure that every eligible vote cast could be counted, including election officials in all 67 counties,” he added. “When a Pennsylvanian takes the time to cast a legal vote, often waiting in long lines and taking time away from their work and family, they deserve to know that their vote will count. That’s democracy. I’m proud of the work we’ve done since Election Day to enfranchise voters across the state no matter whom they voted for and to ensure that the democratic process could unfold.”

In a statement shortly after the concession, Mr. Fetterman said Mr. Casey’s legacy “is a better Pennsylvania.”

"It’s been a supreme honor to have Bob Casey as a colleague, friend, and mentor,” said Mr. Fetterman, who has worked alongside Mr. Casey in the Senate since winning his 2022 race to assume former Sen. Pat Toomey’s seat. "Unassuming while delivering for PA for nearly two decades, he fought for working Pennsylvanians and unions, rural communities, seniors and people with disabilities — all of us.”

Advertise with us

The often bitter race — with the candidates sharply divided over the economy, abortion, immigration and more — sparked hundreds of millions of dollars in spending on campaign ads across the Keystone State.

It also ignited dozens of court battles and appeals from both sides with several counties’ boards of elections over what ballots should be counted.

The Pennsylvania Supreme Court on Monday ruled that undated or misdated mail-in and absentee ballots “shall not be counted” by any of the state’s boards of elections — including in the handful of counties where Democratic officials already voted to defy the high court’s previous rulings on the matter in the middle of a high-stakes U.S. Senate race.

State and national Republican leaders had pledged to fight what they describe as a brazen betrayal of public trust by Pennsylvania Democratic election officials.

The race was also tied up in the court system after at least Philadelphia, Bucks and Montgomery counties chose to count batches of hundreds of undated or misdated mail ballots — with some officials openly acknowledging they’re doing so in defiance of state Supreme Court rulings.