Election integrity is at the forefront of the 2024 presidential race between former President Donald Trump and Vice President Kamala Harris.
Trump and other Republicans have falsely claimed the 2020 election was stolen, including in Pennsylvania, and that the only way Trump can lose in 2024 is if Democrats cheat.
What was once a mundane part of electoral politics is now a closely watched issue by both Republicans and Democrats.
With the race possibly hinging on the Keystone State’s 19 Electoral votes, Pennsylvania’s election integrity will come under intense scrutiny. Our reporters prepare you for one of the key issues in this year’s cycle as Election Day rapidly approaches.
Pennsylvania at the center of election fraud allegations
Pennsylvania, the largest battleground state, once again finds itself as Ground Zero for claims about irregularities or fraud swirling around registration forms, mail ballot applications and access to the polls.
Officials in Lancaster and York counties say they’re digging into recent deliveries of large batches of election materials, including suspicious voter registration forms.
Read More
The Pennsylvania Democratic Party, meanwhile, filed suit against the Erie County Board of Elections, claiming that mistakes made by a vendor and actions of the board were part of a situation in which voters had received two mail ballots; 10,000 to 20,000 voters who sought mail ballots had not received or submitted them; and other mail ballots could not be accounted for. The issues, the suit said, have “caused registered voters substantial delays and hardships in casting ballots.”
And Trump’s campaign won a court victory on Wednesday, when a judge agreed to extend the option for applying and filling out mail ballots in person in Bucks County after long lines led to complaints that voters were being disenfranchised, according to the Associated Press.
Secretary of State Al Schmidt and local officials this week have sought to calm voters’ nerves and confront perceptions of turmoil impacting confidence in the election in the wake of social media posts and dramatic claims of faults in the state’s electoral system.
— Benjamin Kail
Fight over noncitizen voting could foreshadow battle over election results
Threats of unauthorized immigrants voting in presidential elections have become an issue in the 2024 campaign, and some experts say it could spark new challenges to election results in Pennsylvania and other battleground states.
Trump and various GOP officials have raised the specter of voter fraud as they refuse to say that they will accept the results of this year’s election. Similar allegations disrupted Pennsylvania’s vote count four years ago.
“We are certainly seeing attempts in 2024 to set the stage for that type of attempt to subvert the outcome of elections, putting hooks in the wall now so they have some place to hang their hats on later,” said Sean Morales-Doyle, director of voting rights at New York University’s Brennan Center for Justice.
This fall, the U.S. House sought to pass a law blocking noncitizens from voting. Opponents argued the measure also could have prevented legal voters from casting ballots, and it was deemed dead on arrival in the Senate. But Trump has been leaning into accusations that his rivals are bringing immigrants into the country illegally so they can vote Nov. 5.
Experts who track elections say instances of noncitizen voting are both illegal and rare, but not unheard of.
— Jonathan D. Salant
Mail ballot counting process will look different this year
Nov. 5 will be the first presidential election where most Pennsylvania counties will have to pre-canvass mail ballots nonstop starting at 7 a.m. and begin a final, nonstop count of those same ballots starting at 8 p.m.
It remains to be seen how those nonstop provisions of Act 88 of 2022 will affect presidential vote-counting. They were put in place as part of a tradeoff for counties being given grants to help cover election costs.
But positive effects of the “election integrity grants” already are being felt: Allegheny County last year put more than $665,000 of the grant it received toward staff costs for pre-canvassing and canvassing of mail ballots. The county will have 220 people scheduled for Nov. 5 to assist with pre-canvassing and canvassing.
— Ford Turner
Inside the Allegheny County vote-counting process
Mail-in ballots in Pennsylvania are widely expected to take days to count after the election, but not in Allegheny County. Officials said they are confident in-person and mail-in ballots will be counted by midnight on Election Day.
Like in 2020, this year’s election figures to be heavily influenced by mail-in ballots, with more than 255,000 mail-ins sent to Allegheny County voters as of Thursday, according to the county’s elections dashboard. The county is still waiting on about one-quarter of the mail ballots to be returned.
But the county remains an outlier from other jurisdictions, which will likely take longer — including in Philadelphia and elsewhere. Mr. Schmidt said that if results are close, it will take days to determine which presidential candidate won the state.
In November 2020, the Associated Press did not call Pennsylvania for President Joe Biden until the Saturday after Election Day.
View this post on Instagram
Allegheny County votes will be counted in a large brick warehouse on the North Side. It will be a beehive of activity Tuesday, as more than 230 county workers will descend on the building along Pennsylvania Avenue, sit in a massive room, and help pre-canvass mail-in ballots. State law says the county cannot start that process until polls open (7 a.m. Tuesday).
Officials have suggested that if voters haven’t returned their mail ballot yet, they should take it to one of 10 drop-off locations across the county, rather than put it in the mail this close to Election Day. For mail ballots to count, the county must receive the ballot by 8 p.m. on Election Day.
— Steve Bohnel, Adam Babetski and Hallie Lauer
Law enforcement prepare for the threat of political violence
After a botched assassination attempt on Trump at the Butler Farm Show grounds in July left one person dead, two injured and the former president slightly wounded, fear of the potential for more violence has been heightened across the Keystone state. Several voting advocacy organizations pulled their canvassers from the streets and halted operations throughout the summer.
Effective Monday, Pittsburgh police leaders will be able to extend officers’ shifts at their discretion to ensure maximum coverage of the city and polling sites, public safety spokeswoman Cara Cruz said Tuesday.
In separate statements, Pittsburgh police, Allegheny County police and Pennsylvania State police said no reports of election-related threats have been received in the city or commonwealth as of Tuesday.
There will also be nearly 5,000 state police troopers proactively prepared to “execute a smooth, safe Election Day where Pennsylvanians can visit their local polling places, run by local officials from both parties,” Myles Snyder, a spokesperson for state police, wrote in an email.
— Laura Esposito
Washington County taking election security a step further
As municipalities across the Commonwealth bear down on their pre-election preparations, Washington County has added two dozen armed guards to their roster of election workers.
The county decided to hire Charleroi-based RiP Security after between 25 and 50 longtime poll workers quit or retired since the 2020 election, citing concerns about their safety, Washington County Elections Director Melanie Ostrander told the Washington Observer-Reporter.
“It’s one of the top questions we have from poll workers, about their safety and the polling places,” Ms. Ostrander said. “We want our poll workers to feel safe, since we’ve lost poll workers over the past few years from concerns about safety.”
Ms. Ostrander said the guards could cost the county $18,000 for the day, which they’ll pay for using funds from the state’s election integrity grant program. She said the county has not yet received any reports of election-related threats.
In Allegheny County, officers have been stationed at ballot return sites and will be on-site at the election warehouse in the North Side on Election Day where the votes will be counted, according to James Madalinksy, a spokesperson for the county police.
— Hallie Lauer
State Republicans appeal to the courts
Republicans on Thursday took the latest fight over improperly dated mail ballots to the state Supreme Court, asking for an emergency stay and a directive that counties be “bound to enforce the mandatory date requirement for absentee and mail-in ballots.”
The stay request came a day after Commonwealth Court ruled 3-2 that disqualifying a mail ballot due to a missing or incorrect date on the envelope is unconstitutional.
Although the lower court ruling applied only to a special election for two House seats held in Philadelphia on Sept. 17, national and state Republicans who sought action by the Supreme Court said the ruling violated that court’s recent statement against changing rules so close to an election. They also said it had “unleashed chaos” in the runup to the Tuesday election.
Earlier in the week, Pennsylvania Republicans asked the U.S. Supreme Court to decide a court fight over Pennsylvania provisional ballots cast by voters whose mail ballots have been rejected for a technical reason.
They sought a new ruling following a state Supreme Court 4-3 ruling which held that elections officials must count provisional ballots cast by voters whose mail-in ballots were voided because they arrived without mandatory secrecy envelopes, the Associated Press reported.
Republicans asked the nation’s highest court to put the ruling on hold or have the provisional ballots in question excluded from the vote count while the legal fight plays out, the AP reported.
— Ford Turner





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.