Republicans on Thursday took the latest fight over improperly dated mail ballots to the state Supreme Court, asking for an emergency stay and a directive that counties be “bound to enforce the mandatory date requirement for absentee and mail-in ballots.”
The stay request came a day after Commonwealth Court ruled 3-2 that disqualifying a mail ballot due to a missing or incorrect date on the envelope is unconstitutional.
Although the lower court ruling applied only to a special election for two House seats held in Philadelphia on Sept. 17, national and state Republicans who sought action by the Supreme Court said the ruling violated that court’s recent statement against changing rules so close to an election. They also said it had “unleashed chaos” in the runup to the Tuesday election.
“The law is well established: The General Assembly’s date requirement for mail ballots is mandatory and must be enforced as a matter of state and federal law,” the appeal said
Widespread use of mail ballots in Pennsylvania was ushered in by a sweeping 2019 election reform law. Among the numerous court fights since then, a significant number have related to dates voters are required to write on the outer envelope in which the ballot is returned.
On Sept. 17, two special elections were held in Philadelphia to fill state House seats left vacant by the resignations of former Reps. Donna Bullock and Stephen Kinsey.
Read More
A few days later, the Philadelphia Board of Elections decided not to count 69 ballots that had improperly dated or undated envelopes. A series of court proceedings followed, leading to Wednesday’s Commonwealth Court ruling that the ballots should be counted.
An opinion by Judge Ellen Ceisler said Commonwealth Court had been put in the position of deciding “whether the application of certain provisions of the Election Code, held to be unambiguous and mandatory but found to be otherwise meaningless, violates the free and equal elections clause of our Constitution.”
The appeal to the Supreme Court was filed Thursday by the Republican National Committee and the Republican Party of Pennsylvania.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.