When it comes to elections and how they’re run, Thad Hall has had a fair amount of experience.

He’s been deputy director of the Richland County Voter Registration and Elections department in South Carolina, and elections director in Coconino County, Ariz. He’s been director of elections in Mercer County, a position he’s held since August 2020. Before that, he researched election operations and systems for the Fors Marsh Group, University of Utah, and The Century Foundation, since about 2000.

The Fors Marsh Group is an Arlington, Virginia-based consultant that does research on several political issues, and The Century Foundation is a progressive think tank with headquarters in New York and an office in Washington. 

In recent cycles, the election process has come under more scrutiny. Former President Donald Trump and other Republicans have called the 2020 election rigged, including in Pennsylvania — and have said that Trump can only lose in 2024 if Democrats cheat. What was once a mundane part of electoral politics is now a closely watched issue by both Republicans and Democrats.

Advertise with us

For Mr. Hall, combating misinformation about what he and his staff do in Mercer County has become more of a difficult task in recent cycles. The 2000 presidential election was a good benchmark for election integrity, he said, because of how long it took for a victor to be decided — Al Gore, the Democratic candidate, finally conceded to former Republican President George W. Bush in December of that year.

The cable media landscape, social media and overall political environment have contributed to more inaccurate or incomplete information about how election operations work, he said. And many Americans don’t know how elections work, period, Mr. Hall and other election experts agreed.

The process is actually pretty boring, Mr. Hall said. Training election workers, making sure voting machines work, and getting ballots securely from polling places to election warehouses is not exciting stuff, he said.

“When people say things like: How did you know that such and such happened? … the answer is typically very mundane, right?” Mr. Hall said. “It's like, Oh, why did this happen? Well, let me tell you why: boringness… the answers to these problems are not rocket science.”

That could be as simple as explaining why a voting machine might not be working at a particular moment or how there is a post-election audit where both Democrats and Republicans can see how it’s conducted — and where that process includes a hand count of some of the ballots.

Advertise with us
Republican presidential nominee and former President Donald Trump departs after speaking during a campaign rally at the Suburban Collection Showplace in Novi, Mich., on Saturday, Oct. 26, 2024. (AP photo / Alex Brandon)

Election integrity, like four years ago, will be an important topic in the coming weeks, especially for the former president. When Trump lost in Pennsylvania — and nationwide — in 2020, his campaign tested the courts with multiple lawsuits, almost all of which ultimately failed in federal courts.

Perhaps one of the most notable opinions was from Judge Matthew Brann, a Republican federal judge appointed by former President Barack Obama. He serves in the Middle District of Pennsylvania, and flatly dismissed Trump and his campaign’s claims in a decision that made national headlines.

“[T]his Court has been presented with strained legal arguments without merit and speculative accusations, unpled in the operative complaint and unsupported by evidence,” Judge Brann wrote in an opinion dated Nov. 21, 2020. “In the United States of America, this cannot justify the disenfranchisement of a single voter, let alone all the voters of its sixth most populated state. Our people, laws, and institutions demand more.”

Academics and local election officials agree that American election systems, while not perfect, are fair, secure and represent the will of voters. The leaders of multiple election divisions have said in recent weeks that there are many safeguards within the system.

Teams of both Democrats and Republicans work at polling places and also to count mail-in ballots in warehouses in counties across the state, according to multiple local election officials.

Advertise with us

Joseph DiSarro, a political science professor at Washington and Jefferson College, said there is no such thing as a perfectly-run election. There will always be the chance for irregularities and mistakes, he said.

But Mr. DiSarro, a Republican who has been involved in local election recounts in Allegheny County, said he has “tremendous faith in the process” of how elections are run in the county.

Any widespread claims of voter fraud, voting irregularities, or unfairness are a sad statement on the current political landscape, he said. People who make such claims haven’t watched ballots being counted, or the overall mundane activities that occur within a local elections division.

“The integrity of American elections is pretty good when you compare it … to other elections in the world, right?” Mr. DiSarro said. “American elections are pretty fair and pretty reasonable when it comes to the counting procedures, etc. This is not a country which engages in widespread election irregularities. It's almost laughable.”

When voters have questions about how the process works at polling places, front-line election workers are often the first ones to answer them. Linda and Tim McGuire have both worked at the same polling place — the Mary Queen of Apostles School’s Greenwald location in New Kensington — in recent years.

Advertise with us

The McGuires said that voters might have questions about how the election machines work or other parts of the process. Bipartisan teams work together at their location, and a list of registered voters is always at hand so workers know who is allowed to vote at that location.

Mr. McGuire said that another thing that could help local election workers is state politicians agreeing to what rules should be around elections, like how a mail-in ballot and its envelope should be filled out and mailed in. Legislators should be doing their jobs and establishing clear rules, he said.

Dems, GOP come together

Despite what might make headlines, recent history tells us that Democrats and Republicans have come together on the issue of voter integrity and making sure elections are secure, said Martha Kropf, a professor of political science and public administration at UNC Charlotte.

Ms. Kropf, who studies electoral processes and operations, said voter integrity can mean different things to Democrats and Republicans in today’s political environment.

Advertise with us

For Democrats, it could mean ensuring access to the vote, she said. For Republicans, it could mean supporting voter ID — although some Democrats have supported voter ID, too — cleaning voter rolls, or other similar issues, she added.

Voter integrity is a “loaded word politically,” Ms. Kropf said.

But compromise is possible, she said. The Help America Vote Act, passed by Congress in 2002, is one example.

Most Americans don’t know how elections are funded, what happens to a ballot after you vote, or how they are audited and certified, Ms. Kropf said.

And in today’s political and media environment, that’s problematic, she said.

Advertise with us

“When there's a lack of knowledge about any political subject, it becomes a lot easier for mis and disinformation to take on a life of its own,” Ms. Kropf said.

Part of that is the idea that Mr. Hall, the Mercer County elections official, mentioned: that the process isn’t inherently interesting, she said.

“I would think watching people just doing their civic duty is probably in some ways like watching paint dry,” she said.

In some ways, it’s not the most exciting story for the media either, she and Mr. Hall said. It can be a better story when things go wrong than if things are running smoothly, they added.

‘It’s an act of civil service’

Advertise with us

Ultimately, the election systems are, in many ways, only as good as the people that help run them, officials said. Mr. Hall said he’s fortunate to have dedicated election officials and poll workers operating alongside him.

Those people come from both political parties, and work in schools, churches, libraries and other public buildings in communities across Pennsylvania. They are all paid, but when asked why they choose to help run elections, many say the same thing: it’s not about the pay.

“It’s an act of civil service, just like jury duty or something else that you’re called to do,” said Ms. McGuire, the election worker at Mary Queen of Apostles in New Kensington. “It’s hard to get help, [and] it certainly isn’t for the money.’

But political leaders, both Republican and Democrat, have done a good job to bridge the gap and educate residents about how elections work, Mr. Hall said. He added that if people would stop “doomscrolling” on X or their social media feeds — and actually take time to see how they are run, a lot of misconceptions about election and voter integrity issues would likely be addressed.

“I think that people don't realize that most stuff is pretty straightforward … and it’s because there's no trick to what we do,” Mr. Hall said. “It's just a lot of hard work in a very short period of time. And I think once people see that, it makes everything a lot easier.”