Mail-in ballots in Pennsylvania are widely expected to take days to count after the election, but not in Allegheny County. Members of the Allegheny County Board of Elections expressed confidence in the county’s ballot-counting system during a pre-election meeting Tuesday afternoon, but also discussed some practical concerns about mail-in voting as the number of Allegheny County mail-ins approaches a quarter million.

The Board of Elections’ three members, County Executive Sara Innamorato, Republican Council Member Sam DeMarco, and Democratic Council Member Bethany Hallam, spoke to a panel of elections officials led by David Voye, manager of the Division of Elections.

The county’s 222 elections workers should be able to canvass the mail-in votes – in other words, count them and ensure that they are valid – by the end of election night, and workers will not stop counting the ballots once they have started, said Jessica Garofolo, the director of the Department of Administrative Services.

Mr. DeMarco said that he was confident that Allegheny County would not be a part of any delay in election returns and praised Mr. Voye’s leadership.

Advertise with us

“I have no concerns that we won’t be able to get all of our mail-in or absentee ballots, except the military and overseas, which don’t have to be in until the following Tuesday. So they’ll trickle in, but for the most part, you know, 99.9% of the ballots will be counted on Election Day,” Mr. DeMarco said.

Like in 2020, this year’s election figures to be heavily influenced by mail-in ballots, with the number of mail-ins sent to Allegheny County voters approaching 227,000, according to the county’s elections dashboard.

The law that vastly expanded mail-in voting in Pennsylvania was signed by then-Gov. Tom Wolf as the COVID-19 pandemic began to sweep through the United States, vastly changing how elections were carried out. Among other things, Pennsylvania’s primary election that year was put off from April until early June.

That year, election officials statewide approved more than 2.6 million requests for mail ballots, and more than 2.2 million were cast in the presidential election. In the presidential race between Democrat Joe Biden and Republican incumbent Donald Trump, the Democrat received more than 1.9 million votes by mail while the Republican received fewer than 600,000.

That discrepancy — and the fact the mail-ins took days to count — fueled Trump’s baseless claims that the election was “stolen.”

Advertise with us

Since then, some Republican leaders, including Trump himself, have adjusted their messaging to a more favorable tone on voting by mail. X CEO Elon Musk, who has been holding events across Pennsylvania in support of Trump, has also encouraged his audience to vote early.

Going into the presidential election this year, a Democrat-to-Republican comparison of mail ballot involvement is still lopsided, but not quite as bad as it was in 2020.

As of Tuesday, the Department of State said counties had approved 1,870,065 mail ballot requests. Among the total mail ballot requests that were approved, 1,079,726 came from Democrats and 561,634 from Republicans. Of the 1,051,655 mail ballots that have been returned, 649,060 were from Democrats and 300,862 from Republicans.

In Allegheny County, as of Tuesday according to the Department of State, 229,247 mail ballot requests were received, including 153,843 from Democrats and 49,812 from Republicans. Among the 141,087 ballots returned in Allegheny, 100,329 were from Democrats and 28,405 from Republicans.

Mr. Voye told the Elections Board that 913 mail-in ballots had to be sent back to be cured, meaning that the voter did not properly sign or date their ballot and that 462 of those ballots have since been properly cured.

Advertise with us

Ms. Hallam asked Mr. Voye to explain why Allegheny County does not release a list of voters who submitted “erroneous” mail-in ballots so that “the public could come together to attempt to cure it.” At least three counties statewide release publicly accessible lists, including Beaver County and Philadelphia County.

Mr. Voye responded that Allegheny County mails uncured ballots back to the voters, unlike other counties, and that releasing a public list of voters who submitted uncured ballots would be a privacy concern.

Mr. DeMarco told the Post-Gazette that he didn’t agree with Ms. Hallam’s suggestion to make the lists public.

“I don’t think that you want to be in a position where, if you make a mistake, that you have all these third-party groups trying to hunt you down at your home and beat down your door to try to force you to get to the polls or something like that, because your ballot isn’t going to count,” he said.

Allegheny County will send back deficient ballots until the Saturday before the election, said Chet Harhut, the deputy manager of the Division of Elections. Voters will have the ability to cure their ballots in person through Election Day, he said.

Advertise with us

As of Monday, there were 9,088,583 registered voters in the state, including 3,971,607 Democrats, 3,673,783 Republicans, and more than 1 million with no affiliation and the rest signed up to third parties.

It’s the smallest registration advantage the Democrats have had in 16 years.

In Allegheny County, there were 943,221 registered voters as of Monday, including 522,563 Democrats, 270,952 Republicans and more than 100,000 with no affiliation. Mr. Voye reported that the increase in the county’s registered voters was roughly 1,000 from 2020.

Mr. DeMarco raised a concern about ballot envelopes becoming sealed in the mail due to recent humidity, meaning that voters cannot use them once they arrive.

Mr. Voye estimated that there have been around 500 such incidents so far. Allegheny County sends voters fresh envelopes the same day they report the problem, and has provided satellite voting locations with extra envelopes in case voters there have issues, he said.

Advertise with us

Allegheny County’s elections budget is around $9.5 million this year, said Ms. Garofolo.

Ms. Innamorato said that administering elections comes “at a significant cost” and thanked the panel for their work.

She added that voting should be about “celebrating with your community, about joy, and about exercising your right as an American citizen.”

“Let’s show people that we truly are ‘Mister Rogers’ Neighborhood,’” she said.

Correction, posted Oct. 23, 2024: An earlier version of this story misrepresented the number of Allegheny County mail-in ballots.

Staff writer Ford Turner contributed to this story.