It may only be two weeks since President Joe Biden dropped out of the presidential race, but the impact is already being felt across Pennsylvania, as former president and Republican nominee Donald Trump and the presumptive Democratic nominee Vice President Kamala Harris jockey for swing voters on TV and radio airwaves.
From July 21 — the day Mr. Biden announced he was ending his bid for a second term — through Aug. 4, more than $20 million has poured into TV markets in the most populous swing state, much of it from Super PACs that aren’t allowed to coordinate with campaigns, but also don’t face contribution limits that federal election law places on candidates.
Trump’s campaign and Republican PACs have spent just under $11 million in the state, while Ms. Harris and Democratic PACs have countered with about $9.7 million, according to AdImpact, which tracks political spending.
“It’s a good time to own a television station in Pennsylvania,” said Christopher Nicholas, a veteran GOP political consultant based in Harrisburg.
In the coming weeks, advertising will be crucial as both Trump and Ms. Harris vie to define her candidacy. Trump is well-known to voters, Ms. Harris — in comparison — is not.
“Public opinion is like cement,” said John Conway, a strategist with Longwell Partners in Washington. “It's soft and malleable at first. It hardens over time. So there's this window where these ads can be incredibly effective.”
Mr. Conway, who is director of strategy for Republican Voters Against Trump, a $50 million campaign to help capture moderate voters to support Ms. Harris, said it’s unclear when messaging will eventually stick — a lot of casual and swing voters haven’t tuned into the election like political insiders and the media.
But the window for effective messaging closes a bit every day, he said.
The Trump team switched its focus almost immediately after Mr. Biden’s exit. Pro-Trump PAC Maga Inc., released its first Harris attack ad the day Mr. Biden dropped out of the race, claiming that the vice president “covered up” Mr. Biden’s “obvious mental decline.”
Democrats, however, were slow to shift their messaging. Although Mr. Biden withdrew on July 21, there were still at least two ads from “Biden for President” circulating until July 28, according to AdImpact. The Harris campaign began to release ads of its own under “Harris for President” on July 30 with “Fearless,” a minute-long spot that is mostly audio of Ms. Harris outlining her vision for a country where “every person has the opportunity not just to get by, but to get ahead.”
According to AdImpact, the other pro-Harris ads currently showing in Pennsylvania are Future Forward PAC’s “Harris Bio” and “Kamala,” both of which list the vice president’s claimed achievements. Future Forward PAC is the largest Democratic super PAC funding ads for the Harris campaign.
“Harris Bio,” a 30-second spot, began airing on July 27 and makes broad claims about Ms. Harris’ legacy as her service in California, lauding her as “The district attorney who protected children from sexual predators” and “The attorney general who stood up to the big banks to protect homeowners.”
The PAC’s other ad, “Kamala,” features speech audio from Ms. Harris stating that she will support working-class families and protect reproductive rights nationwide.
Trump for President followed up on the initial speedy pivot with more detailed ads that frequently show Ms. Harris dancing and laughing as headlines of her perceived failures flash on the screen. Ms. Harris’ laugh echoes in the background of one spot, a clear riff on Trump’s nickname for her, “Laughing Kamala,” which he debuted at a July rally.
The campaign’s most recent spot dubs Ms. Harris the “Border Czar,” a term used in the media at the time for her assigned focus on root causes of illegal immigration. Although Ms. Harris was not put in control of immigration policy overall, the ad claims that she allowed 10 million illegal immigrants into the country and was responsible for over 250,000 fentanyl-related deaths.
U.S. Customs and Border Protection has logged 10,351,846 border encounters since fiscal year 2021; of those, 8,410,951 took place at the “Southwest Land Border.”
Fentanyl-related deaths have spiked dramatically since 2013. That’s when only 3% of Allegheny County’s overdose deaths involved fentanyl, according to data tracked by the county and the Drug Enforcement Administration. But by 2016, fentanyl turned up in roughly two-thirds of county overdose deaths, and the following year it was found in 67% statewide.
The National Safety Council, which focuses on eliminating causes of preventable deaths andinjuries, said a 70,891 Americans died from opioid overdoses, including fentanyl, in 2022, its most recent year of tracking, but annual deaths more than doubled during Trump’s presidency, from 26,211 in 2017 to 53,480 in 2020.
And most fentanyl comes over the border at legal ports of entry. During the first 11 months of fiscal year 2023, Field Operations officers intercepted 89% of the 25,600 pounds of fentanyl seized. Most of the traffickers were U.S. citizens. Only 4% were potentially in the U.S. illegally, according to the Government Accountability Office, the investigative arm of Congress.
It currently is a “pollster’s dream” as each campaign tests which messages might work on undecided voters, said Mike Butler, a Democratic political consultant based in Pittsburgh.
But it’s unclear how long it will take for messaging to stick, he said.
Mr. Butler added that having multiple strategies to swing voters and win Pennsylvania’s 19 Electoral College votes can be trickier to execute than one single pathway — noting the 2016 election when Trump beat Democratic nominee Hillary Clinton, despite many political observers seeing multiple options for the latter.
Another messaging battle that is hitting the airwaves hard, with potential knock-on effects for the presidential race is the U.S. Senate contest between incumbent Democratic Sen. Bob Casey and his Republican challenger, Dave McCormick.
Whereas Mr. Casey’s ads are almost solely focused on Mr. McCormick, who is characterized as an out-of-touch millionaire from Wall Street who hasn’t voted in Pennsylvania for 15 years, Mr. McCormick’s ads focus almost exclusively on Ms. Harris and Mr. Casey’s support of her.Mr. Casey is barely mentioned in McCormick for PA Senate’s “Most Liberal Nominee,” which spends its minute-long runtime accusing Ms. Harris of supporting “Voting rights for terrorists” and banning fracking, a position she has since walked back.
While some said it’s tricky effectively to tie Mr. Casey to Ms. Harris because he is an established political figure in Pennsylvania, the McCormick campaign’s focus on “branding” Ms. Harris a “radical” in favor of “open borders” and banning fracking could be an assist in the Trump campaign’s attempt to mold the political cement in their favor before it sets for good.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.