WASHINGTON — A presidential candidate is shot. A sitting president decides not to run for re-election. The Democrats gather in Chicago to nominate a candidate amid fear that antiwar demonstrators will disrupt the proceedings. And, yes, a Robert F. Kennedy is running for the White House.

Welcome to 2024. Or is It just a repeat of 1968?

“The more things change, the more they stay the same,” said U.S. Rep. Dina Titus, D-Nev., a former political science professor.

“There’s no doubt that history does repeat itself, the past is prologue, and sometimes that’s not a good thing,” said the longest-serving member of the U.S. House, New Jersey Republican Chris Smith. “We don’t seem to learn from our mistakes and we recommit them over and over again, so it does have that feel of chaos.”

The parallels between those two years are too significant to ignore.

Advertise with us

The year has seen the attempted assassination of a presidential candidate — Donald Trump at a rally in Butler County on July 13. It immediately brought back memories of the killing of U.S. Sen. Robert F. Kennedy, D-N.Y., who was seeking the 1968 Democratic presidential nomination. Now Mr. Kennedy’s son, Robert Jr., is running for the White House as an independent.

This is the first time since 1968 that a sitting president — then Lyndon Johnson, now Joe Biden — decided not to run again in the middle of a re-election campaign. 

In both cases, the party then turned to the sitting vice president. Hubert Humphrey won the 1968 nomination and Vice President Kamala Harris is about to do the same in 2024, both without running or winning a primary election.

And the Republican nominees — former Vice President Richard Nixon in the 1960s and former President Donald Trump now — lost their previous run for president. 

Both Nixon and Trump ran on law and order platforms, and both had ethical problems. Nixon would go on to resign the presidency in 1974 due to the Watergate scandal. Trump has 34 felony convictions and three other indictments on his ledger.

Advertise with us

“As Yogi Berra says, ‘This is deja vu all over again,’” Democratic consultant Peter Fenn said. “The parallels are fascinating and ironic. For those of us old enough to have very complete memories of 1968, it is a little scary to contemplate.”

The similarities don’t end there. Both sitting presidents faced protests at home for their handling of conflicts abroad. For Johnson, it was Vietnam; for Mr. Biden, the Israel-Hamas war.

When they announced they would not seek re-election, both men cited their desire for an end to the fighting.

“We are prepared to move immediately toward peace through negotiations,” Johnson said on March 31, 1968. “So, tonight, in the hope that this action will lead to early talks, I am taking the first step to de-escalate the conflict. We are reducing substantially, reducing the present level of hostilities. And we are doing so unilaterally, and at once.”

When addressing the nation on July 24, Mr. Biden talked about a desire for peace in the Middle East conflict that began Oct. 7, when Hamas attacked Israel.

Advertise with us

“I’m going to keep working to end the war in Gaza, bring home all the hostages, and bring peace and security to the Middle East and end this war,” Mr. Biden said.

It remains to be seen if Chicago — home to the 1968 Democratic National Convention when antiwar protesters violently clashed with police while chanting, “The whole world is watching” — will see a similar confrontation with pro-Palestinian protesters during next month’s gathering.

“Hopefully,” Mr. Fenn said, “there will not be riots in the streets and there will not be a mayor of Chicago flipping the bird to a distinguished senator,” which Mayor Richard Daley reportedly did after hearing U.S. Sen. Abraham Ribicoff nominate South Dakota Sen. George McGovern for president with these words: “With George McGovern as president of the United States, we wouldn't have to have Gestapo tactics in the streets of Chicago.”

Rutgers University political science professor Ross Baker said one reason history repeats itself is that most American politicians regularly follow the same rules, so the same situations come up over and over again. 

“The ground rules of American politics are very old,” he said. “We’re always playing within the same constitutional structure.”

Advertise with us

Watergate led to fears that Nixon would seize control of the federal government to stay in office even as evidence of his wrongdoing mounted. He didn’t, but Trump supporters stormed the U.S. Capitol on Jan. 6, 2021, in an unsuccessful effort to stop Congress from certifying Mr. Biden as the next president of the United States. 

“Trump encouraging the seizure of the Capitol was such a departure,” Mr. Baker said. “It’s frightening when the rules of the game are flouted.”

Both years also saw new ways of reaching Americans. Then there was the expansion of color television and FM radio. Now there’s TikTok and social media.

Despite the similarities, historian Julian Zelizer says there are huge differences as well.

“The party is much more unified today and there is not a single issue that divides Democrats in the same way that Vietnam did,” said Mr. Zelizer, a professor of history and public affairs at Princeton University. “Moreover, the Democrats were always deeply divided in that era (north-south) in a way that is not true today.”

Advertise with us

In addition, Ms. Harris, who would be the first woman to win the White House, represents a much sharper break with the past than Mr. Humphrey ever did, he said.

“Finally,” Mr. Zelizer said, “as much as Democrats hated Nixon, I think the intensity of opposition is much greater today toward Trump, and Trump, unlike Nixon, has a record as president that shows what he can do.”

It remains to be seen until November whether there will be another parallel. 

Without a Democratic incumbent on the ballot in 1968, Republicans won the election and ushered in an era that saw them occupy the White House for 20 of the next 24 years. Democrats have held the presidency for 12 of the last 16 years, but once again will be trying to keep the White House without an incumbent on the ballot.

Jonathan D. Salant: jsalant@post-gazette.com, @JDSalant