OBJECT341544b3-18a3-413d-a23c-9491ba0ac83dOBJECT341544b3-18a3-413d-a23c-9491ba0ac83dPittsburgh resident Erin Koper took the stage at the Republican National Convention in Milwaukee last week to expound on the second night’s theme: “Make America Safe Again,” helping to make the case that drugs, border security and lax support for law enforcement have created a public safety crisis that only the GOP can fix.

Ms. Koper — who lives in a large brick house in Elliott, a quiet, hilly neighborhood in the West End — told the national audience that local Democratic officials’ “soft on crime policies” in Pittsburgh have “unleashed criminals” into her community.

Public safety is a central issue for the Republican party, similar to abortion for Democrats, despite the GOP presidential nominee having been convicted of multiple felony counts and at least six of his close associates having been sent to prison.

While Republican candidates hope the law and order message will help drive in votes for conservatives in the November election, it remains unclear how successfully that message will land for key swing voters and how pivotal the issue will be for down-ballot candidates.

Advertise with us

Former hedge fund CEO David McCormick is making it a centerpiece of his GOP campaign to unseat Democratic U.S. Sen. Bob Casey in Pennsylvania.

“Republicans are trying to steal some votes in urban areas,” said Paul Sracic, a political analyst at Youngstown State University. “In places like Pittsburgh or Philly, they think urban voters are getting fed up with crime and are tying it to the Democratic party through weak prosecutors and district attorneys.”

But crime in cities tends to be a more local issue, said Larry Ceisler, a Democratic Philadelphia-based public affairs executive who is originally from Washington County: “You don't look at a senator and think it's their fault people are getting mugged on Main Street.”

In her speech at the RNC, Ms. Koper named Pittsburgh Mayor Ed Gainey as a key figure in the problems that she sees.

Overall, Republicans are tying their anti-crime campaign tightly to concerns about immigration and what they term President Joe Biden’s “open borders” policy, noting that Mr. Biden early in his term asked Vice President Kamala Harris to help address border issues.

Advertise with us

Republicans at the convention called her the “Border Czar,” but that’s an exaggeration. Mr. Biden didn’t put her in charge of the border, but rather asked her “to lead our efforts with Mexico and the Northern Triangle and the countries that ... are going to need help in stemming the movement of so many folks, stemming the migration to our southern border.” It’s a distinction easily lost in a campaign.

The federal government might have limited control when it comes to local crime issues, but bringing the border into the discussion can connect the two, said Mr. Sracic. Immigration remains a major issue for Republican voters, he said, right behind the economy.

“It doesn't matter that Pennsylvania is landlocked,” he said. “It’s kind of a symbolic issue, it’s about protecting the nation.”

From the moment former President Donald Trump descended an escalator in his New York City skyscraper and announced his first candidacy, he has tied — many would argue unfairly and contrary to statistics — illegal immigration to violent crime. This election cycle, especially in down-ballot races like the one between Mr. McCormick and Mr. Casey, the argument hinges primarily on the southern border being a principal inlet for drugs such as fentanyl.

Mr. McCormick recently held a public safety campaign event in Butler County, a Pennsylvania Republican stronghold. The gathering featured former U.S. Attorney General Bill Barr, who cited federal statistics about the amount of fentanyl and other potentially fatal drugs crossing the southern border. He tied that to a surge in crime in cities.

Advertise with us

Mr. McCormick, a veteran, promised to address the scourge of fentanyl by destroying cartels across the Mexico border.

Fentanyl has become an explosive issue for Republicans, said Mr. Ceisler. The drug has taken the lives of over 3,000 people last year in Pennsylvania lalone.

In the 2022 midterm elections, a CBS News and YouGov poll found 67% of Pennsylvanians considered drug or opioid addiction to be a major problem in the state.

The issue of “crime and immigration is at the top of voters’ minds,” said Charlie Gerow, longtime Harrisburg-based Republican strategist. Mr. McCormick, he said, “is not only doing the right thing politically, he’s showing why he’ll be a great U.S. senator — he sees a problem and takes action.”

Mr. Gerow, who was born in Brazil, added, “I am a legal immigrant, so I feel very, very strongly about illegal immigrants. I carried a green card for close to 20 years.”

Advertise with us

“2020 primary Democrats did a lot of damage to themselves" during the presidential primary debate that year, said Mr. Sracic. “A majority raised their hand for the idea of open borders … they tagged the party with the idea that they don't care about border security.” All of the candidates on stage were responding to a question about whether their government health plan would cover undocumented immigrants.

Mr. McCormick — who last week was endorsed by Pennsylvania’s Fraternal Order of Police and State Troopers Association — and the political action committees backing him have poured more than $2.5 million into ads focused on the border and crime, according to AdImpact, a campaign ad tracking firm.

Mr. McCormick argues that Mr. Casey was alongside Mr. Biden “every step of the way” and characterizes the president’s recent border security measures as a last-ditch effort.

“[Bob Casey] has been supportive of all these policies that have left open the borders: the lack of funding for the border wall, the lack of border control, the lack of enforcement of case law … so I think what you’re seeing is another cynical ploy,” he said during the recent Butler campaign event.

Mr. Casey, for his part, can point to a number of things to counter the GOP attack, namely the Border Act and FEND Off Fentanyl Act.

Advertise with us

The Border Act, a bipartisan border security bill that Democrats failed to advance earlier this year, was endorsed by Mr. Casey and blocked by Republicans. Democrats say congressional Republicans’ sudden opposition was a Trump-inspired effort to keep the issue of the border and immigration alive on the campaign trail.

“It was very tough immigration and border security legislation, the toughest that’s ever been proposed by a bipartisan coalition,” Mr. Ceisler said. “It’s very hard for the Republicans to criticize Democrats on that when Trump torpedoed legislation so he could talk about it in his election with Biden.”

The FEND Off Fentanyl Act imposes sanctions on foreign persons involved in fentanyl trafficking and was signed into law in April. According to his campaign website, Mr. Casey spent several months traveling across the state advocating for its passage. He calls it a law to “crack down on the cartels” in a campaign commercial.

Mr. Casey and the political action committees backing him have spent almost $1.9 million on border and crime ads, but have created just one on the issue compared to Mr. McCormick’s four, according to AdImpact. Mr. Casey has long been a supporter of law enforcement while simultaneously supporting criminal justice reform in the legal system, according to his campaign website.

“To say that Bob Casey has turned a blind eye to a fentanyl and opioid crisis just won’t ring true with voters,” Mr. Ceisler said.

Advertise with us

But that argument is “paper thin,” Mr. Gerow said. “The problem not only continues, it grows.”

“Let me be very clear,” Mr. Gerow added: “Bob Casey is a good man; he’s a friend. But in 18 years, he hasn’t done much. Ask an average Pennsylvania voter, ‘What has Bob Casey done for you?’ and you’re going to get a blank stare.”

Other than inflation and the economy, “the number one concern on people’s minds is their own safety,” he said. “Bob Casey is concerned about how many potato chips are in a bag rather than the public safety of voters.”

Mr. Ceisler is skeptical that in the end Mr. McCormick’s campaign rhetoric will make a successful case. Even as Mr. McCormick tries to tie Mr. Casey to the president’s border policy, border crossings have been declining since February.

Either way, this might be a more challenging year than usual for incumbents such as Mr. Casey.

Advertise with us

He has become an established figure since taking his Senate seat in 2007, but a presidential election year can make a win more difficult than a midterm election, Mr. Sracic said.

“This year, the top of the ticket will pull a lot of voters along,” he said. “Are people going to go in and vote for Donald Trump and Bob Casey?”

Polls across the country indicate that, in states with well-established incumbent Democrats, Trump is doing much better than Republican Senate candidates, he said. Based on 32 polls, Mr. Casey has a 8.3% lead over Mr. McCormick.