Parents and guardians of Pine-Richland students will be able to challenge library books rather than the broader community, school directors decided Monday as they continue revising a controversial library book policy.

The change was approved as part of the second reading of Policy 109.1, which lays out how library books are selected and the process to challenge books. Under the new language, parents or legal guardians can request reconsideration of library materials located in the school their child attends. It previously said challenges could be made by individuals.

The second read passed in a 5-4 vote. Directors Amy Cafardi, Liz DeLosa, Ashley Fortier, Melissa Vecchi and Randy Augustine approved the motion. Directors Leslie Miller, Michael Wiethorn, Phillip Morrissette and Marc Casciani voted against it.

“I can no longer support this, so you guys lost my vote,” Mr. Casciani said. “I think it was a big enough exclusion for me that I can’t support it anymore.”

Advertise with us

The vote came after directors last month tabled the policy’s second reading over disagreements about who can bring challenges. Several language changes were proposed Monday, including one that permitted taxpayers to bring challenges. Most of those failed.

The issue dates back to October 2023 when a group of residents asked school directors to remove books from libraries they described as sexually explicit and obscene.

At the time, 14 books in the middle and high school libraries were challenged, launching a review of the novels. A 10-person committee was compiled to read the books. Following the review, Superintendent Brian Miller determined the books could remain in the libraries.

Afterward, the former school board overhauled the policy, which went into effect in March 2025.

Under those revisions, if someone asks for a book to be removed from the school library, the superintendent will review the request. The complainant, after being informed of the decision, will then have 21 days to appeal the decision to the board president. The board would make a final decision.

Advertise with us

Additionally, a list of books librarians want to purchase must be made public for 30 days, and a new section was added around parental rights.

But in December, new board members — many of whom opposed the policy — were sworn in. And, in February, the board suspended the policy until Monday as they considered revisions. Directors on Monday once again suspended the policy until the next board meeting.

On Monday, directors continued to disagree over who can bring library book challenges.

Mr. Casciani proposed language that would have permitted reconsideration requests if the challenger has a student enrolled in the district or currently pays property taxes. It would have also established a filing limit — no more than one formal request within a school year. That request could include no more than five materials.

The proposal was supported by Ms. Miller who said, “I’m not thrilled with how this is all here, but I feel like we really work together to try to come to something that we could all live with.”

Advertise with us

Mr. Morrissette agreed, calling the proposal “sufficient.”

The amendments were headed by Mr. Casciani and Ms. DeLosa in an attempt to find middle ground between board members. But on Monday, Ms. DeLosa said she “never got to a place” where she found common ground while respecting the district, librarians and teachers.

“I won’t be voting for this language even though I wrote it,” Ms. DeLosa said. “But I don’t think that the exercise of working with my fellow board members was a waste of time.”

Ms. Cafardi also raised concerns about the language excluding residents. She suggested that someone living at St. Barnabas with grandchildren in the district wouldn’t be able to challenge books. But a Florida resident who owns rental property and pays taxes in the district could.

The motion ultimately failed.

Advertise with us

Ms. Miller proposed additional changes, including minor language tweaks, which passed.

Other changes that will be considered in the final read of the policy include the process for reconsideration with the re-establishment of a review committee, how library books are acquired and elevating the diversity of literature, including those some may find controversial.

Near the end of the meeting, several directors suggested the policy wasn’t needed. Many said other districts across the region don’t offer a reconsideration option to parents or the community.

“I don’t think we should have a reconsideration policy at all. … I don’t think we need this regulation, this extra work for the administration,” Mr. Augustine said.

Mr. Casciani, in response to the conversation, said, “that’s for another day.”

The board will likely consider the third and last reading of the policy at next month’s meeting.