Major changes to Pine-Richland School District’s controversial library book policy were put on hold as school directors clashed over who should be allowed to challenge books.

In a 5-4 vote Monday night, directors tabled the second reading of Policy 109.1, which lays out how library books are selected and the process to challenge books.

At the center of the debate is whether only parents and guardians of children in district schools should be permitted to challenge books or if the process should be open to the wider community.

“As a board we are under the school code,” director Marc Casciani said. “We are not to discriminate and segment taxpayers in different groups and then decide as a board what to allow them to have a stake in. … We are going down a slippery slope.”

Advertise with us

Directors Mr. Casciani, Liz DeLosa, Leslie Miller, Philip Morrissette and Michael Wiethorn voted to table; Ashley Fortier, Randy Augustine, Amy Cafardi and Melissa Vecchi voted against it.

The lengthy discussion followed last month’s first reading in which language was altered to say parents and guardians of students can challenge books rather than the general public.

The issue dates back to October 2023 when a group of residents asked school directors to remove books from libraries they described as sexually explicit and obscene.

At the time, 14 books in the middle and high school libraries were challenged, launching a review of the novels. A 10-person committee was compiled to read the books. Following the review, Superintendent Brian Miller determined the books could remain in the libraries.

Afterward, the former school board overhauled the policy, which went into effect in March.

Advertise with us

Under those revisions, if someone asks for a book to be removed from the school library, the superintendent will review the request. The complainant, after being informed of the decision, will then have 21 days to appeal the decision to the board president. The board would make a final decision.

Additionally, a list of books librarians want to purchase must be made public for 30 days, and a new section was added around parental rights.

But in December, new board members — many of whom opposed the policy — were sworn in. And in February, the board suspended the policy until Monday as they considered revisions. Directors on Monday once again suspended the policy until the next board meeting.

During Monday’s meeting, Mr. Casciani and Ms. Miller reintroduced wording to once again allow the general public to challenge school library books. Mr. Casciani added that guardrails should be put in place to “keep maybe someone with an improper motive from causing a ruckus.”

“But I do think there’s something to be said about allowing a taxpayer in our community to raise a legitimate challenge because they’re concerned about the book,” Mr. Casciani said.

Advertise with us

A debate quickly broke out over that language with major questions centering on if the word “resident” or “taxpayer” should be used.

Taxpayers, Ms. Cafardi said, may own property within district boundaries, but they don’t necessarily live in the community. Residents, she said, don’t necessarily pay property taxes. She suggested the board keep language to parents and guardians.

Mr. Morrissette, in response, suggested the board define those words in the library book policy.

Mr. Wiethorn also quickly pushed back to Ms. Cafardi, saying it’s “somewhat rich that we do not want taxpayers to have the ability to bring a challenge but in a very short period of time we’re going to up all their taxes. So we don’t want to hear from them but you’re going to increase all of their taxes.”

In response Ms. Cafardi said, “Do taxpayers get to choose the color of our carpet? They’re buying the carpet. What if they don’t like green? Are we going to listen to a taxpayer cause they’re paying for it?”

Advertise with us

Mr. Miller, the superintendent who spoke following the vote to table, said keeping language to parents and guardians finds a middle ground between those on both sides of the argument.

To try to find middle ground among board members, director Ms. DeLosa suggested implementing guardrails to ensure the policy does not get abused.

Many were concerned over the timing of book challenges — the first round in 2023 came before an election. The district is currently facing another round of challenges, which were submitted after the board said it would revise the policy.

Guardrails could include limiting the number of challenges a person without a child in the district could make.

Other changes being considered in the policy include the process for reconsideration with the reestablishment of a review committee, how library books are acquired and elevating the diversity of literature, including those some may find controversial.

School directors will now formalize language for the guardrails and on who can challenge library books. They will discuss the changes at the April 13 board meeting.