Kayla Johnson waited for her 4-year-old daughter to burst through the school doors on a chilly fall day and wondered how much longer she’d be able to pick her up from the same building.

“We don’t got too many schools within the Hill,” Ms. Johnson said outside the Miller PreK-5 doors, her toddler bundled up in his stroller next to her. “Are you trying to push us out?” 

Miller, Pittsburgh Public’s only African-Centered Academy, could soon be among nine schools permanently closed under a sweeping Pittsburgh Public Schools proposal that would reshape classrooms across the city. For the Hill District, where most residents are Black and generations of school closures have already hollowed out the community, the possibility feels like history repeating itself. 

Miller sits across from Neighborhood Resilience Project, a nonprofit focused on trauma-affected communities, and next to the Bedford Hill apartments, which include low-income units. In the afternoon, the block fills with families walking to pick up children, teachers guiding students to their parents and chatter spilling from the school steps. 

Advertise with us

If the closure goes through, the Hill District will be left with just one elementary, Weil PreK-5. That would mark the loss of four Hill elementary schools in 25 years. The neighborhood’s Milliones 6-12 would also be reconfigured into Sci-Tech 6-8 at Milliones.

The proposed changes are part of a plan Pittsburgh Public Schools officials are considering that would permanently shutter nine school buildings citywide, close several others and reopen them as different schools, and change grade configurations at 10 others. School directors could vote this month on the proposal, which if approved would start to go into effect at the end of the school year.

Two children walk along Bedford Avenue after Pittsburgh Miller PreK-5 let out on Monday, Nov. 10, 2025. (Giuseppe LoPiccolo / Pittsburgh Post-Gazette)

The school closure plan will affect 43% of the district’s 17,949 K-12 students. More than half of those who will be impacted are Black, while 26% are white, based on numbers compiled from the district’s enrollment summary dashboard. PPS is a majority Black district, with 8,810 Black students and 5,290 white students.

Other predominately Black schools, including Manchester and King, both North Side PreK-8 schools, could close, prompting parents across the city to question whether the plan can truly promote equity without disproportionately harming communities already impacted by past closures. 

“The amount of closures and the impact of closures that are disproportionate on the Black and poor communities and students, that's a serious problem,” school director Sala Udin, whose district includes the Hill District, said. “We're going to have to learn how to face it.”

Advertise with us

A national problem 

Pittsburgh’s struggles mirror a national trend.

A 2023 analysis by Stanford Graduate School of Education professors found that majority-Black schools, which made up about 10% of the overall U.S. public school population, were more than three times as likely to close as non-majority Black schools. 

That’s because students of color and those economically disadvantaged are more likely to be enrolled in schools labeled as “underperforming,” a 2024 Research for Action report found.

And less investment is often put into buildings in lower income neighborhoods and areas serving students of color, said Douglas Harris, chair of the economics department at Tulane University and director of the National Center for Research on Education Access and Choice, noting that building quality is often considered when choosing which schools to close.

That leads to major impacts for students of color.

Advertise with us

When a community or neighborhood school closes, Hetal Dhagat, a senior attorney with the Education Law Center, said parent engagement often decreases because families have to travel farther.

It also increases transportation distances for students and could impact academic achievement.

But if done right, school closures can benefit students, Mr. Harris said, through smaller class sizes, more teachers and better buildings. 

“It's easy to see why nobody wants to [close schools], but sometimes looking a little bit down the road and past the immediate pain of the closure, it's actually probably about the best thing for the vast majority of students,” Mr. Harris said. 

That’s the goal at Pittsburgh Public, where leaders are touting the school closure plan as a way to improve equity issues districtwide. 

Advertise with us
Children exit Pittsburgh Miller PreK-5 after the end of the school day on Monday, Nov. 10, 2025. (Giuseppe LoPiccolo / Pittsburgh Post-Gazette)

Reconfiguring the district’s footprint, Superintendent Wayne Walters said, would help “address these inequities by really ensuring that it’s not just about some students, but every student having access to a safe, modern learning environment.”

Through the equity-informed approach, district leaders are hoping to provide resources based on student needs and ensure consistent programming in languages, the arts and STEM — science, technology, engineering and math — and equitable staffing districtwide.

Mr. Walters also pointed to Miller’s African-Centered Academy, which “looks very different” today from when it started. At the time, the school focused on African-centered teachings. But now, schools districtwide have implemented programs such as African drumming. 

“We’re looking to ensure that over time every child has access to modernized, well-resourced schools, and focusing on building equity into the plan so that no one community is carrying the weight of this alone,” Mr. Walters said.

Historical inequities

But for those in the Hill District, the possible closure of Miller feels like another hit for the community that saw one of its largest impacts in the mid-1950s when the Lower Hill was razed to make way for the Civic Arena and Interstate 579. Officials are now in talks to redevelop the area. 

Advertise with us

Since then, the community, like most of Pittsburgh, has continued to lose residents.

In 1950 there were 62,500 people in the Hill District and Uptown, the National Trust for Historic Preservation found. Today, there are 9,358 living in the five communities making up the Greater Hill District, documents from Pittsburgh’s Department of City Planning show.

As residents left, schools closed.

Central High School, built in 1872 at the intersection of Bedford Avenue and Crawford Street was razed in 1946.

Fifth Avenue High School in Uptown shuttered in 1976.

Advertise with us

Schenley High School also served Hill District students, although it was located in North Oakland. It closed in 2008.

Three Hill District elementaries closed in the past 25 years, Jake Oresick, a Pittsburgh Public graduate and author of “The Schenley Experiment: A Social History of Pittsburgh’s First Public High School,” said. Those include McKelvy, which closed in 2001, (Miller later moved into the building); Madison K-5, which closed in 2006; and Vann K-5, which closed in 2010.

“The Hill District has taken a lot of punches over the years,” Sam Black, director of the African American Program at the Heinz History Center, said, adding that school closures force people to “sort of remake their lives, either having to relocate or if not relocate then send their children to different schools.”

Miller’s roots run deep.

The school traces its history to the basement of Bethel A.M.E. Church, predating the Civil War. It moved into a new building in 1867 as enrollment grew. By the late 1960s, Miller served primarily Black children and in 1998, community leaders pushed to restore its African-centered focus. 

Advertise with us

Under the plan that would close Miller, students would instead attend Weil, a 13-minute walk away. To Miller parents, it’s more than an inconvenience. 

Shakira Baker, standing outside the Ammon Community Recreation Center this summer, didn’t doubt that students of color will “be impacted a lot” by the closure plan.

“Other communities or more suburban communities, their kids are able to grow up and go to elementary, high school, see the familiar faces … not be spread and displaced all over,” said Ms. Baker, whose children attend Weil and Schiller 6-8, a STEAM magnet, in East Allegheny. 

As a mother of four, she worries her kids could encounter racist incidents if they’re forced to attend schools outside the Hill District. And she’s frustrated with the process so far, saying it feels like plans have already been set in motion despite community pushback.

At public hearings about the proposal, parents and advocates have echoed similar concerns. Many, including the advocacy group 412 Justice, say the district’s talk of equity rings hollow without an audit or deeper community engagement.

Advertise with us

Others see the issue differently. 

Maraizhia Gordon, 25, while waiting to pick up her son from Miller one October day said, “I don’t think it’s a Black or white thing … Everyone is impacted, not just Black folks.”

For Ms. Johnson, whose 4-year-old daughter attends Miller, her concerns largely focused on her children’s education. She’s already begun to stress to her kids that education comes first. 

“If they want to change the curriculum or change some type of dynamic of the inside of Miller, great, but to just close it and then force kids to go either to [Weil] or even further, I’m sorry, I don’t agree with that,” Ms. Johnson said.

“I don’t think that they should close Miller.”