A federal judge has ordered the University of Pittsburgh to lift its suspension of a pro-Palestine student group that Pitt officials argued violated school conduct.

U.S. District Judge J. Nicholas Ranjan found Thursday that Pitt suspended its Students for Justice in Palestine chapter over speech protected by the First Amendment.

After a nearly six-month suspension, the university is now required to reinstate SJP’s full privileges as a student organization, including its ability to recruit new students and host events.

The American Civil Liberties Union sued Pitt on SJP’s behalf in April, several weeks after the March suspension tied to communications during a conduct hearing.

Advertise with us

ACLU Pennsylvania Legal Director Witold "Vic" Walczak argued that this case demonstrates that speech “needs protection” — particularly “unpopular speech.”

“It all comes down to pro-Palestine speech,” Mr. Walczak said during Thursday’s hearing. “... If Pitt is allowed to punish them for this, it will do incalculable damage to free speech in this country and at the University of Pittsburgh.”

In a statement, Pitt said it will comply with the order.

“Pitt is committed to maintaining a campus community where free speech is affirmed and free expression is assured,” a spokesman said. “We will comply with the order issued on Thursday but cannot comment further as litigation is ongoing.”

About 40 people packed into a federal courtroom in Downtown Pittsburgh Thursday morning to hear the arguments. Most of the attendees appeared to be college-aged. Many wore keffiyehs — checkered scarves that have come to represent Palestinian solidarity amid the Israeli-Palestinian conflict— and several wore face masks.

Advertise with us

In his three-page decision, Judge Ranjan wrote that Pitt caused irreparable harm to SJP by preventing the group from gathering as a student organization and recruiting new members, particularly at the beginning of the school year. Pitt’s first day of fall classes was Monday.

There is also a public interest in “increasing the level of association and speech on campus,” the judge wrote.

Pitt suspended the Students for Justice in Palestine chapter in March after alleging that the group had “intimidated” members of a Conduct Hearing Board during a deliberation process over a disputed “liberation study group” that SJP had hosted in the winter.

During the conduct hearing process, SJP had sent an email to Pitt administrators and conduct board members that condemned what it described as the “selective repression” and “political suppression” of the group. The student group also alleged that actions taken by Pitt against the group had “disproportionally penalized students of color” and eroded campus free speech.

The letter was co-signed by several Pitt organizations, including a purported signature by the Pitt School of Law. Law school administrators denied signing the letter.

Advertise with us

Thursday, lawyers representing Pitt argued that this email amounted to “intimidation” that “distressed” board members. These actions were not protected by the First Amendment, they said.

“What we’re getting at here is conduct,” attorney Joshua Richards said Thursday. “It’s the intimidation that is an issue — which is the conduct, not the speech.”

But the ACLU argued that Pitt’s suspension violated SJP members’ First Amendment rights. In a 220-page complaint, the ACLU said Pitt had intimidated, retaliated against and hindered events sponsored by the Students for Justice in Palestine chapter over the course of a year.

During the conduct hearing process, students were never told they couldn’t send email communications, Mr. Walczak said. And the email was not threatening, he added.

“There’s nothing in that letter that is threatening or improper,” Mr. Walczak said.

Advertise with us

SJP frequently hosted protests, teach-ins, film screenings and other events in support of Palestine. It is the sole registered student group on campus with the direct mission to support Palestine. Another student group, Pitt Divest from Apartheid, is not registered with the university.

The war in Gaza has seen colleges become hotbeds for discourse and protest. While some schools have faced criticism for not doing enough to enforce their conduct rules or to protect Jewish or pro-Israel students, others have been accused of going too far in inhibiting pro-Palestine students’ free speech rights.

At Pitt, most pro-Palestine protests have remained peaceful, although one last summer escalated into an occasionally violent scene that saw arrests, defacement of the Cathedral of Learning and numerous clashes between police and protesters.