The fence at Carnegie Mellon University is reopening less than a week after university officials temporarily closed it in a clash that played out on campus as politicians — including President Donald Trump — and industry leaders gathered for a massive summit.
The battle about the fence — a structure at the center of campus historically used as a forum for student expression — broke out at the university after administrators had crews paint over students’ messages on the fence Tuesday, when the university hosted the inaugural Energy and Innovation Summit, featuring Trump, U.S. Sen. Dave McCormick, Gov. Josh Shapiro and industry leaders in the tech and energy sectors.
CMU President Farnam Jahanian initially addressed the incident in a letter to the campus community the day after the summit, writing that the message from students “crossed a line.” Students had painted “shame on you” on one side and “no rapists on our campus” on the other.
The administration had the fence painted “not because of its viewpoint, but because of its personal, unaccountable nature, which undermined the spirit of civil discourse that had led up to it,” the letter said.
In the letter, Mr. Jahanian said the fence would be temporarily closed to new messages and indicated a potential departure from its traditional use.
But in a statement Monday, Mr. Jahanian said the fence was reopening without any changes to previous rules. He acknowledged that Trump’s visit to campus “angered and hurt” many students, which, he said, is a separate issue from the “future of The Fence tradition.”
Read More
“I am committed to creating space for both conversations,” he wrote.
Among other broader free speech concerns, students said they took issue with how Mr. Jahanian handled his response to the subject of the messaging.
“Sexual violence causes profound harm, and I regret that my previous message did not unequivocally acknowledge the pain of sexual assault,” he wrote in the Monday letter. “I am deeply sorry.”
In his subsequent letter, Mr. Jahanian also said he will create a “dedicated working group” in the fall to discuss these issues and assured he would “not undermine the cherished legacy of The Fence.”
The Carnegie Mellon Student Government will host two town halls on Aug. 30 at 11 a.m. to allow students to share their thoughts about the fence and student expression on campus.
“Currently, there appears to be clear opposition to updates to the Fence policies and procedures,” the student group said in a statement. “We want to hear more directly from CMU undergraduate and graduate students.”
The insight gathered at the town halls will be used to “directly inform” the recommendations shared with university leadership as “future policy development is considered,” the statement said.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.