Carnegie Mellon University has temporarily shut down its campus fence — a storied tradition that has long served as a forum for student expression — following a protest message that appeared just hours before President Donald Trump attended Tuesday’s high-profile energy and AI summit.
The message, which read “No Rapists on Our Campus” and a reference to Trump being found liable in a civil trial of sexual abuse and defamation, was painted over by university staff. On Wednesday, CMU President Farnam Jahanian addressed the incident in a message to the campus community saying he “made the decision to have this message painted over and to take the Fence offline.”
The protest message had no attribution. Later an Instagram post from @CMUfence with the caption “You know who” appeared online.
In his message, Mr. Jahanian said earlier Wednesday he met with two student government presidents to discuss future engagement at the fence and will also meet with other groups, including faculty senate and staff council.
“Once we determine how we will proceed, I will communicate again with the campus community. In the meantime, in order to afford time for these important discussions, the Fence will not be open for any new messages until sometime next week,” he said in his message.
The message comes following days of protests from CMU students and community activists of the inaugural Energy and Innovation Summit, organized by U.S. Sen. Dave McCormick, R-Pa. In addition to Trump, at least 60 industry CEOs, six Trump administration cabinet members, and Gov. Josh Shapiro attended the summit.
Read More
In the days leading up to the summit, students painted slogans such as “No Trump,” “CMU Community Says Stop the Summit,” and most recently, “Protest the Summit” on the fence.
Earlier in the week, the university helped students arrange a safe space for a news conference on Monday so they could “share their perspectives through broader media platforms,” Mr. Jahanian said.
“The university supported their right to express their views without hesitation,” Mr. Jahanian wrote.
But the “No rapists on our campus” message “crossed a line — not because of its viewpoint, but because of its personal, unaccountable nature, which undermined the spirit of civil discourse that had led up to it,” he said in his message.
“The Fence tradition has long symbolized the power of visible expression representing diverse viewpoints. But in recent years, it has too often been used to broadcast polarized, one-sided messaging — often anonymous, sometimes ad hominem, and increasingly disconnected from meaningful dialogue,” he wrote.
CMU Democrats denounced the university’s decision to censor Tuesday’s messages on the fence.
“We strongly condemn the university’s censorship of the Fence, which undermines a century-long history of free expression on campus,” the group said in a statement.
Carnegie Mellon College Republicans echoed those sentiments, “strongly” opposing any efforts by the university to “curtail free speech” and raising concerns about further restrictions on expression at the fence in light of Mr. Jahanian’s message Wednesday, club president Anthony Cacciato said in a statement.
The last time The Fence became a point of controversy was during nationwide Black Lives Matter protests in 2020, when someone painted over “Black Lives Matter” with “All Lives Matter.” Students quickly gathered afterward to restore the original message.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.