When news broke earlier this week detailing which Penn State commonwealth campuses could close, a sense of relief initially washed over professors and students at the Greater Allegheny campus.
The campus was among five across the state that will likely be spared from closure.
But undercurrents of worry over the fate of their counterparts at three other Western Pennsylvania campuses — Fayette, New Kensington and Shenango — quickly swept in. Those three are among seven campuses recommended for closure.
“My co-workers and I are relieved that Penn State Greater Allegheny doesn't appear to be in imminent danger of closing,” Michelle Gordon, a business administration professor at Greater Allegheny, said. “However, we're heartsick at the fates of our colleagues, the students, and the communities impacted by this unnecessarily detrimental plan.”
Penn State released a report Tuesday that proposes closing seven campuses across the state, including DuBois, Fayette, Mont Alto, New Kensington, Shenango, Wilkes-Barre and York. Five campuses originally considered for closure would be spared: Hazleton, Schuylkill, Beaver, Greater Allegheny and Scranton.
A final decision on the proposal has not yet been made by the board of trustees.
Read More
The announcement ended months of worry and fear over which campuses would close. Still, it sparked new waves of anger and confusion over why campuses need to shutter. And at places like Greater Allegheny, the news brought mixed emotions.
“We know well our colleagues at the other campuses,” Douglas Charles, a history professor at Greater Allegheny, said. “They're fantastic and accomplished teachers, scholars, and staff. I would describe our feelings, having survived the chopping block, as something akin to survivors' guilt. Sure we survived but our colleagues face extreme uncertainty.”
Penn State leaders began toying with the idea of shuttering some of the 12 campuses in February as the university faced declining enrollment at branch campuses and a projected decline in Pennsylvania's college-aged population.
At the time, officials decided the seven largest campuses — Behrend in Erie, Abington, Altoona, Berks, Brandywine, Harrisburg and Lehigh Valley — would definitively remain open.
Enrollment drops at the commonwealth campuses have been a years-long struggle. At Western Pennsylvania campuses between fall 2020 and fall 2024, student declines have varied from 7% (Penn State Behrend in Erie) to 29% (Penn State Fayette).
These enrollment challenges are exacerbated by a looming demographic cliff that will particularly impact the Northeast and Midwest. The Keystone State’s share of high school graduates is expected to drop 17% by 2041.
In a statement released Tuesday, President Neeli Bendapudi said the recommendation “balances our need to adapt to the changing needs of Pennsylvania.”
No campuses would close before the end of the 2027 semester.
Rationale for closure
Locally, Fayette, New Kensington and Shenango were flagged for similar issues.
According to the report, Penn State Fayette has seen a 43% drop in enrollments over the past decade. The campus currently enrolls 407 students. That’s 64% below the campus's 2006 peak when it housed 1,139 students, the report reads.
Additionally, the Fayette campus faces “strong competition” from larger institutions including PennWest California and Waynesburg University. Other factors in its consideration for closure include a lack of residential housing and infrastructure that “does not warrant reinvestment given current and projected usage levels.”
“The challenges are structural, not programmatic: they stem from regional population loss, economic distress, and limited demand for in-person education in this location,” the report reads. “Penn State Fayette’s commuter-heavy student body and absence of regional momentum make it difficult to justify continued investment at the level required to reverse the current trajectory.”
New Kensington saw a 35% enrollment decrease over the past decade. Today, the campus has 432 students. Given enrollment declines, the campus is “significantly underutilized,” the report reads, and the scale of academic and student services makes “operations inefficient and cost-intensive.”
The campus is also one of three commonwealth campuses within close proximity including Greater Allegheny and Beaver. Programs offered at New Ken are similar to those offered at other area campuses, “reducing the need for a stand-alone presence.”
Penn State Shenango in Mercer County has a similar plight. The campus has seen a 43% decrease in enrollments over the past decade. There is also limited regional growth potential and high operational inefficiencies associated with its size and infrastructure.
“Fixed costs per student are high, and the campus relies heavily on central subsidies to maintain operations,” the report reads. “Despite the best efforts of its leadership, the campus lacks the scale needed to sustain core student services, extracurricular engagement, and academic breadth at the level expected of a Penn State campus.”
Greater Allegheny and Beaver
Pavel Marin, who recently wrapped up his freshman year at Greater Allegheny, called the recommendation to keep the campus open “a win.”
“The decision is a win for my sake and for students, but I think it will be a win in the future as well because we'll be able to see what will happen when we add more students, when we have a bigger commuter dorm population. … If you have more students in a campus, you can offer more programs,” Mr. Marin, 19, of Squirrel Hill, said.
He pointed to several perks such as the campus’s proximity to Pittsburgh, available programs and a diverse student population, all things highlighted in the Penn State report.
Despite a 42% enrollment decrease of the past 10 years, Greater Allegheny “is uniquely positioned to serve as a vital educational institution in the Greater Pittsburgh region,” the report reads. The campus, officials said, provides higher education access to a diverse and underserved student population. Of enrolled students, 50% are first-generation college students, 42% receive Pell grants and 27% identify as underrepresented minorities.
The campus houses Penn State’s only bachelor’s degree in social work and the university’s only undergraduate clinical research program. It’s “strategically located in Allegheny County,” allowing the campus to benefit from Pittsburgh’s economy and large population center. That also gives students opportunities to access internships and employment opportunities.
“Its diverse student body, unique academic offerings, strategic location, and potential for growth make Penn State Greater Allegheny a critical part of the Commonwealth Campus ecosystem,” the report reads. “Continued investment will enable Penn State Greater Allegheny to develop its strengths, address regional credential gaps, and provide educational opportunities for Southwestern Pennsylvania students.”
Beaver has seen a 31% enrollment decrease in the past 10 years. While its 496 students makes it smaller than other campuses recommended for closure, Beaver’s proximity to Pittsburgh and the airport positions the campus “to serve as a regional hub for Penn State’s operations in the Greater Pittsburgh region,” the report reads.
Officials touted campus leaders’ desires to launch new programs while maintaining a strong housing occupancy.
“Strategic investment in this campus can further leverage its momentum, enhance recruitment and retention, and strengthen Penn State’s visibility and impact in this critical region of the Commonwealth,” the report reads.
But at Greater Allegheny, Mr. Charles, the history professor, expressed doubt about the campus closure process, which was “rushed, clouded in mystery,” and had little transparency.
“I have never seen my colleagues so down and feeling dejected and abandoned,” Mr. Charles said.
While it was a relief to hear Greater Allegheny was spared from closing, Mr. Charles and others have “also commented about how conflicted we feel.”
Still, the proposal was touted by McKeesport Mayor Michael Cherepko, who said his administration and regional agencies and organizations worked to communicate how vital the campus is to the McKeesport area.
“I know firsthand the value of having a regional campus that’s accessible to students in the Mon Valley,” Mr. Cherepko said. “I received a first-class education from Penn State University, and that began here at the McKeesport campus. Today’s students will continue to have access to a wealth of Penn State programs from right here in their backyard, whether they stay home to pursue their degree or use this campus as the first step in their journey to University Park.”
The board of trustees must hold a public vote on closures. The board has an executive session scheduled Thursday where they will discuss the possible closures. More information regarding a public meeting will be shared following the executive session.
For now, students and staff are contending with the proposed changes.
“There are a lot of terrific folks at each of these campuses doing hard work and making a positive impact,” Mr. Charles said. “Many are going to be adversely affected by this. Some students who cannot up and move to another campus will be negatively affected, as well. Communities will be affected by the absence of these campuses. I cannot help but think this could have been handled differently or better.”





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.