Pittsburgh Public School directors on Wednesday approved the Manchester-Chateau Transit Revitalization Investment District, or TRID — a funding mechanism to support nearly $54 million in infrastructure upgrades tied to the $600 million Esplanade development in Manchester.
The Esplanade project — which would turn a North Side industrial site into a riverfront destination anchored by a giant Ferris wheel — has drawn criticism from community members concerned about gentrification and its impact on Manchester, a predominantly Black neighborhood.
The TRID was approved 5-1 during the board’s legislative session. School board Director Dwayne Barker, who represents Manchester, voted against it, while Director Sala Udin abstained.
Ahead of the vote, Mr. Barker made a motion — seconded by Mr. Udin — to table the TRID for 30 additional days, citing a petition the board received Monday that was signed by about 300 Manchester residents who “feel like they haven’t been included in discussions.”
Some fear the project will displace longtime residents and formed Manchester Neighbors, a group that aims to provide data and information to the neighborhood regarding the proposal.
Mr. Barker said the vote should be postponed until developers met with concerned Manchester residents.
Read More
“They are residents within the neighborhood, and at the end of the day, we should be taking all voices seriously because it's just the right thing to do,” he said.
He was met with pushback from other directors, who voted him down and emphasized that multiple community meetings have already taken place.
“To even apply for this thing, you have to go through just rigorous underwriting and process. … We're talking about a conversation that's been going on for seven, eight years,” board President Gene Walker said.
He added: “If this group is not being heard, are they not being heard because they are looking for special treatment? Are they just not showing up to the meetings or are they showing up to the meetings and not hearing what they want to hear so they're going to react differently?”
The Esplanade project — approved in November by the Pittsburgh Planning Commission — would feature the Ferris wheel, a 408-unit apartment tower up to 19 stories high with as many as 308 parking spots, retail space and a food emporium.
The first phase of the plan would include the apartment tower, Ferris wheel and a three-story, 64,256-square-foot space featuring a food emporium, a four-seasons garden and restaurants. It would be connected to an outdoor amphitheater. Developers are also proposing a marina, 17 homes similar to houseboats that would be built on barge-like bases, retail and a 651-space parking garage.
Second-phase projects could include an office or residential addition that could be built above the garage, a “destination aquarium” and two more residential projects.
Some directors cited the developers’ promise to designate 20% of the units as affordable to households at 80% of the area median income.
But Mr. Udin said he wouldn’t support the plan until there was a “written list of commitments” from developers.
“In many urban communities across the country, there has been a total disruption of urban communities for the sake of development, with very little benefit going to the communities who get displaced by the development projects,” he said.
“I hope that the community will not move forward until there is a legal document, a community benefits agreement, that the developers are held to and they are not allowed to get away with verbal handshakes. There's too much at stake.”
Director Yael Silk emphasized that the TRID vote had been on the board’s agenda for months and wouldn’t preclude a meeting between community members and developers.
“I do think that this development is different from a lot [of others], like East Liberty, and that we will not see the removal of current housing and push out in that way,” she said. “I don't know how reasonable it is for every group to get that kind of face time in the particular way that they want to.”
The vote to approve the TRID also came after a group of union workers Monday expressed support for the Esplanade project.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.