Standing in front of a group of Manchester residents in the middle of a vacant lot, Stanley Lowe held up a sign:
You didn’t tell the whole story!
The founder of the Manchester Neighbors, a nonprofit that represents the small North Side community, then gestured at his surroundings, empty today, but slated to become a $600 million riverfront development with a Ferris wheel, high-rise apartments and a marina — possibly with floating homes on the Ohio River — within the next few years.
“How do you show and tell everyone all that glitters is gold, and there’s dirt and pollution and garbage beneath our feet?” Mr. Lowe said.
The neighborhood group held an event Thursday to release a report that identifies toxic, contaminated soil and groundwater at the site of the “Esplanade” project, the ambitious development approved in the Chateau neighborhood over the last two years despite intense pushback from some residents.
The 15-acre site is a brownfield, vacant today but previously used for industrial use for more than 140 years. Redevelopment of such sites is common across Western Pennsylvania — on the other end of Pittsburgh, SouthSide Works was once a steel mill, while another former mill in Hazelwood is in the midst of an ongoing yearslong transformation.
Read More
At all former industrial hubs, state law requires developers to clean up the land before building on it to prevent future health and environmental concerns.
A spokesperson for Piatt Companies, the Pittsburgh-based developer behind Esplanade, said Thursday that it has “met and exceeded” all local and state environmental standards since it began working on the project in 2016.
The state’s Department of Environmental Protection received an assessment of the site and approved a clean-up plan from the developer seven years ago, the spokesperson said.
In line with state law, “practically all of the chemicals” deemed hazardous “were considered and are addressed” at the site, according to KU Resources environmental engineer Mark Urbassik. The environmental consulting firm is working with developers on the project.
“We are confident that no health or environmental problems will result from the site,” Mr. Urbassik added.
Still, some neighbors, many of whom worry that the project will fundamentally change the North Side for the worse by driving up housing prices and dislocating current residents, said they remain concerned.

The report states that previous soil and groundwater tests revealed 58 “hazardous compounds,” including arsenic, lead, mercury and other carcinogenic substances at the site — yet, residents at the Thursday event said they were never made aware of it during the approval process.
The 95-page report, compiled by the Manchester Neighbors and Carnegie Mellon University postdoctoral fellow Daniel Holland, is based on assessments of the development site between 2002 and 2018. All were obtained from Pittsburgh’s Urban Redevelopment Authority and the state’s Department of Environmental Protection through public records requests.
“This is all publicly available data and information,” said Mr. Holland. “Why wasn't it exposed to the community before?”
Residents did not push back against the project’s completion Thursday, but demanded more transparency from developers.
“We’re asking for a community impact study,” said Mr. Lowe. “We’re asking for a community benefits plan.
“How do we negate what may be harmful effects coming to the neighborhood?”
Plans for the 15-acre development just downriver of the West End Bridge include a Ferris wheel angled to face the Downtown skyline, a 408-unit apartment building up to 19 stories high, several parking garages and a 64,000-square-foot venue with a garden and restaurants connected to an outdoor amphitheater.
A marina and houseboat-like floating homes are also planned, along with a “destination aquarium” and two more high-rise apartment buildings.
Piatt has promised to designate 20% of the units across all apartment complexes affordable to households at 80% of the area’s median income.
A number of Manchester residents and union employee groups have voiced strong support for the project, which is projected to create thousands of permanent jobs in the neighborhood.
But the Manchester Neighbors and others have raised concerns about the gentrification of their community, a majority-Black neighborhood. They said rents in the neighborhood have already risen as new apartment buildings go up, and as other large projects — including an 11-story luxury building and outdoor entertainment complex on the North Shore — gain approvals.
“When the rents continue to go sky high — and they will, as they did in East Liberty — what do you think is going to happen?” Mr. Lowe asked the group. “It's the writing on the wall.”
Also included in the new report is a call for the preservation of several warehouses within the 15-acre site. The industrial buildings are the last standing remnants of a once-bustling community that was dismantled when families were displaced during the construction of the nearby highway, Mr. Holland said.
The buildings could be candidates for historic preservation, he added. The Pennsylvania Historical and Museum Commission expressed an interest in the properties in 2023, the report says.
“This is the erosion of our history,” Mr. Lowe said.
Piatt Companies chief executive officer Lucas Piatt said this is the “first we’re ever hearing” of the buildings’ historic significance. He said Piatt has held hundreds of meetings over years of engagement with local community groups and residents, and used that input to make changes to the project.
“I feel like we’ve been very open and transparent with this project from the beginning,” he said.
Piatt Companies said it did not receive an invitation to today’s event at the Esplanade site or a copy of the report from Manchester Neighbors.
The community group said that’s because they wanted to share their findings with the community first.
“The mission of our organization, plain and simple, is to provide education to the neighborhood, to keep them informed about what's going on,” Mr. Lowe said.
The first phase of the Esplanade project is not slated for completion until 2027 or 2028. In the meantime, Piatt Companies said they will continue to work with state and local partners to clean up the site and ready it for development.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.