Four years ago, Joseph Cassidy and Amy Terchick were confident in the slate of candidates they joined as they successfully ran for a seat on the Pine-Richland School Board. The four members were focused on the shared values of parental rights and common sense.
But during their time on the board, the two described watching those values shift for some directors.
Arguments have broken out at board meetings between the community and school directors — who clinched a conservative majority in 2023, continuing the trend from 2021 — over library books and the role of student voices in board decisions.
Some board members, Mr. Cassidy said, are focusing on a “political agenda.”
“We've somehow swung the pendulum far right now, and we need to get back to middle ground somewhere,” Mr. Cassidy said.
The two candidates embody a shift playing out in school board races across the country as residents compete for seats on what have become, in some cases, divisive boards.
Read More
The goal of many candidates: Restoring boards to moderate standpoints.
The apparent shift comes after normally mundane school boards were thrown into the center of culture wars in recent years. Heated debates persist as angry parents and school leaders argue over the rights of LGBTQ+ students, the appropriateness of books, and national politics. They are fueled by outside conservative commentators, groups such as Moms for Liberty and political action committees funneling millions of dollars into local elections.
But now, communities are pushing back.
Locally, Pine-Richland has 10 candidates competing for four open seats in the election May 20. That includes three different slates of candidates — two that are opposed to the library book policy and a slate that includes incumbent Christina Brussalis, who voted for the policy.
In Moon, where directors recently voted to shutter an elementary school next school year, nine candidates seek four open seats.
And Norwin has five candidates running for four open seats. Three candidates, including current director Alex Detschelt, were removed from the ballot based on technical errors on nomination petitions. Now, one slate of candidates is running to restore order and remove politics from the board.
The busy election season follows the 2023 balloting in which voters rejected candidates aligned with Moms for Liberty, a conservative, parents-rights organization known for leading efforts to ban from school libraries books it deems inappropriate and for pushing back against ideas related to LGBTQ+ students.
At the time, voters in Pennsylvania, Iowa, Virginia, Minnesota, New Jersey and others instead chose candidates focused on improving traditional public education, The Washington Post reported.
And in Pennsylvania, the Central Bucks School Board in Bucks County that year saw Democrats clinch five seats on the board, three of which had been held by Republicans. The shift came after the board made headlines over Pride flags, policies banning books and directives to not use students’ preferred names and pronouns, NPR reported.
“A lot of ordinary Americans were caught flat-footed and were really surprised at the sudden acceleration of right wing politics at the local level in school board races,” said Jack Schneider, director of the Center for Education Policy at the University of Massachusetts Amherst.
Now, people who “had become disengaged from local school board races, local electoral politics” have been “jolted awake and suddenly realized, actually elections really matter,” Mr. Schneider said,
Fight for change
Rob Bunovich, president of the Norwin Soccer Club, has watched over the past few years as some Norwin board members have made what has been deemed as inappropriate comments about their fellow school directors.
“I want to come on board and try to set an example for our children and not have them see what our board is doing now. … I don't think that they should be making decisions for our children while acting in such a manner that they do now,” Mr. Bunovich said.
Norwin, a district of more than 5,000 students across three Westmoreland County communities, has been rocked by political turmoil after a conservative board majority was elected in 2021. It has focused on things such as the appropriateness of curriculum books and critical race theory despite the fact that graduate-level academic framework is not being taught.
But the politicization was short lived. In 2023, residents voted for a bipartisan slate of candidates who wanted to move away from politics. The four candidates faced a conservative slate of candidates who criticized their opponents for “teaching our kids to be woke.”
Now, a second slate of bipartisan candidates hopes to fully restore the board to a more moderate stance. The slate includes Chelsea Thomas, Jakub Sadowski, Mr. Bunovich — all of whom are cross-filed Democrats — and Monica Kitta, a cross-filed Republican. Ella Thompson, a 34-year-old cross-filed Democrat, is also seeking a seat on the board after not seeing enough young people involved in local politics. If elected she hopes to focus on how board decisions affect the community at large.
Three others — Alex Detschelt, the incumbent, Tammy Moreno, who ran on the conservative slate in 2023, and Randall Pedder — were taken off the ballot after a judge found technical errors in their nomination petitions, court documents show.
In an email, Mr. Detschelt said he decided to run this year “so that we would have someone on the Republican ticket.” He would consider running again in 2027 only “if something dramatic occurs like the community being collectively sick of tax increases and wasteful spending in two years and asking a true Republican to run.”
The slate, dubbed “Norwin Now,” “is running to end the toxic, partisan politics that have taken over the school board,” a press release says. And a recent election video starts by saying, “Norwin’s had enough of the chaos. The headlines, the lawsuits, the name calling. It’s time for leaders who lead with integrity, not ego.”
Mr. Bunovich said one of his biggest goals if elected is to return adult conversations to the decision-making process.
Ms. Thomas said she started paying attention to the school board in 2022, when a referendum was put on the ballot asking voters if a library tax should be reduced. Around the same time Mr. Detschelt was also voicing objections to the children’s book “All Are Welcome.”
“I want the board to be made up of people who aren't politicizing things,” Ms. Thomas said. “It should really not be a political role at all. We're here to represent a diverse student body, and I think that we need to be able to do that effectively.”
In the Moon Area School District, made up of 4,100 students from two communities, several candidates were spurred to run after the current school board voted to shutter Hyde Elementary at the start of the next school year.
Now, nine candidates are running. The slate “Families for Moon Schools” includes Bryan Seybert, Jen Suehr, Morgan Mihok and Ben Brands, all of whom are cross-filed Democrats. Four others — Aaron Smith, Joshua van Asakinda, Scott Yoder and Alex Reinig — were endorsed by the Moon GOP. Incumbent William G. Kammerer is seeking reelection.
For the “Families of Moon Schools” slate, Hyde was a driving factor in their decision to run. But for most, they wouldn’t reopen the school if elected; rather, they would “see how these transitions go that they have planned for this year, and we'll see how the community responds, and then we'll try our best to be the voice of the community,” Ms. Mihok said.
Mr. Seybert, a South Fayette High School teacher, said the Hyde closure is “more of a symptom of a more underlying cause that has been festering, for lack of a better term, within our district for the last few years” in regard to the response of what Moon families want and how the administration and school board operate.
Mr. Kammerer, a Republican finishing up his first term, seeks a second term to continue the work he’s done during the past four years.
Closing Hyde, Mr. Kammerer said, was a “no decision, decision” that will better utilize district resources and provide students with a better education.
At Pine-Richland, a district of 4,500 students, the election is seemingly a pressure point for the community.
Mr. Cassidy and Ms. Terchick, the incumbents who are both cross-filed Republicans, are running on a slate titled Commonsense Leadership for PR. The Together for PR slate features Liz DeLosa, Amy Cafardi, Melissa Vecchi and Randy Augustine. Mike Barber, who has spoken out against the library book policy, is running independently. He is a cross-filed Democrat.
Most want to return the policy — which focuses on parental rights and gives final decisions to the board — back to its previous format with some possible tweaks.
A third slate, Common Sense for PR, seemingly agrees with the policy in its new format. That slate includes Ms. Brussalis, the incumbent who is running as a Republican, and Chris Griffin, a cross-filed Republican.
Robert Stein, who is cross-filed, is also seeking a seat on the board.
“Me, personally, I believe that there are a number of books that are in question that are not appropriate for young people,” Mr. Griffin said. “How that happens from a policy standpoint, that's what the board is there for and what the decisions are all about. But I definitely stand with strong conservative values and a conservative stance on that issue.”
Mr. Griffin, who has four children in the district, also pointed to academics and the budget as key points he would prioritize if elected, while also increasing parental involvement.
But his views seemingly vary from those on other slates.
Ms. Terchick said some board members have become “political ideologues and extremists.”
“What I'm hoping to do is to bring order back and balance, and bring things out into the sunshine and talk about them. … Because we're not getting that right now,” Ms. Terchick said.
Mr. Barber said he decided to run after seeing some current board members “undercutting our teachers, undermining our [administration] and dismissing all of our students.”
For Mr. Augustine, a cross-filed Republican, his decision to run stemmed from the book policy, which he said was “not a good use of time, not a good use of resources for the district.” He was also spurred to run by the “disrespect and disregard for the community” he saw coming from the board, Mr. Augustine said.
“I would like to remove the politics from the school board. … In years past, school board meetings were boring and no one really attended because they were boring,” Mr. Augustine said. “I'd like them to be boring again.”





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.