A court-appointed receiver who is helping the Duquesne City School District right-size its budget and academics as part of a state oversight program will remain with the district through at least 2028, a judge ruled last week.
Judge Alan Hertzberg, of the Civil Division of the Allegheny County Court of Common Pleas, issued a ruling Friday to extend the district’s receivership for the next three years. The order begins Tuesday and runs through March 31, 2028.
Superintendent Sue Mariani told the Post-Gazette on Monday that she wasn’t surprised by the decision, which, she said, is a normal step in the state oversight process.
“I would have been way more shocked if he had not [extended receivership],” Ms. Mariani said. “But the fact that he did, to me, just goes to show that when you have some continuity things can kind of progress and get done.”
The extension follows years of struggle for the small, suburban K-8 school of 450 students.
Duquesne was first put into financial recovery in 2012, allowing the state to seize control of the district’s finances and appoint a recovery officer to form a financial plan. In 2013, a receiver was assigned to put together and carry out the proposed recovery plan.
That came after the district’s high school shuttered in 2007 following longstanding financial problems. Today, high schoolers attend East Allegheny or West Mifflin school districts. The middle school program was also initially cut in 2012 because of continued economic and academic problems.
Since the state takeover, Duquesne has made several improvements such as adopting new curriculum aligned with state standards; improving fiscal management; and hiring a new business manager and Ms. Mariani in 2018 to lead the school.
Three years after her appointment, seventh graders returned to the district, a decision approved by the state after district officials wrote an amendment to their recovery plan, showing financial projections and detailing educational programming. Eighth graders followed in 2022.
Since then, district officials have been working to bring back high school students.
But Duquesne last March received news that the Pennsylvania Department of Education denied the district’s plan to restart the high school program because of the district’s finances. Ms. Mariani said last year she hopes to revisit the idea in coming years.
For now, the district will continue working with their receiver, William Kerr, who has served in the role since 2021.
The latest extension came after the state’s education department earlier this month filed a petition for extension to continue the receivership.
“The District has made substantial efforts to achieve financial and academic recovery,” the petition reads. “However, the District’s current financial status, longterm financial sustainability, and educational outcomes require additional attention over the course of the next three years.”
The petition pointed to district revenues, which “continue to be inadequate to meet operating expenses.” The district also pays tuition to West Mifflin and East Allegheny, a number that increases annually. According to the petition, annual tuition to both districts during the current school year totaled more than $17,300. That could increase to $21,200 by 2030-31. Ms. Mariani also pointed to rising cyber and charter school tuition costs.
As for academics, the petition stated the district “has demonstrated growth in student learning,” but scores on the Pennsylvania System of School Assessment, or PSSAs, “are very low” compared to statewide averages. The district, the petition reads, “must continue to pursue academic initiatives that are currently underway to achieve the Plan’s goal of re-establishing high-quality education for the District’s students.”
To exit receivership, Duquesne must meet several criteria: be financially stable with no unpaid or contested invoices and that all payroll, benefit expenditures and bonds are current; have a positive fund balance and financial projections showing balanced general fund budgets; show an annual debt service not exceeding $750,000; and ensure district students are receiving a high-quality public education.
“The extension of Receivership will ensure a stable educational environment and will help sustain the existing school system,” Mr. Kerr said in a statement. “By addressing the root causes of the School District's academic and financial challenges coupled with reasonable solutions, Receivership will provide ‘a steady at the helm’ approach for academic and financial success in the future.”
Financial recovery plan
In addition to extending receivership, the judge also approved the district’s 2025 financial recovery plan.
The plan, which is a complete rewrite of previous versions, aims to improve existing elementary and middle school programs by focusing on administration, academic performance and financial management, according to court documents.
Financial aspects will include investments to improve K-8 academics, student achievement and professional development; reduce and stabilize payments to East Allegheny and West Mifflin; increase local revenues to support facility improvements; implement cost saving initiatives; and contain salaries and benefits through contract negotiations.
“This recovery plan is a little more streamlined,” Ms. Mariani said. “In my mind we have a very clear path to getting out of at least receivership and then back down into a category called recovery with the ultimate goal of, obviously, being out of recovery totally.”
The plan also includes an internal tool to highlight documents the district is collecting showing that they’ve met particular goals.
Moving forward, the district will continue working with the receiver, who Ms. Mariani said she has a “great relationship with.”
She noted that during a public hearing for the court case several community members also spoke in favor of continuing receivership.
“The community supports it, but at the same time they want to be able to say, ‘Look what we've overcome. Look at this major hurdle we've overcome, and we did it together,’” Ms. Mariani said. “And so we can do that by collectively working with the parents and community, with the school district, and that's being aligned in the vision for the future of the city of Duquesne and the school district specifically.”






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.