Math proficiency rates have improved in recent years among Pittsburgh Public third graders, but more work needs to be done to close gaps seen in different student subgroups.
In all, 39.9% of students who were third graders last year were proficient in mathematics, Superintendent Wayne Walters said during Tuesday’s education committee meeting. That number exceeded the district’s 30.3% proficiency goal previously set for the year.
But significant gaps remain in proficiency rates for students with individualized education plans, those who are economically disadvantaged, Black students and English language learners.
According to Mr. Walters, 66.8% of white students scored proficient in math last year. That number dropped to 22.7% — a 44.1% difference — for Black students. Additionally, 23.7% of students with IEPs scored proficient, 25.5% of English learners and 29.6% of students who are economically disadvantaged.
“It’s still troubling to me that this exists,” Mr. Walters said. “But also it gives me more of a moral imperative to be very focused on those students unapologetically. Even though some may feel we should just teach to the middle, this data warrants a different approach that has to be focused on making improvements for African American students in a majority African American school district.”
PPS is now working to make those changes.
Read More
The district recently adopted new K-8 math curriculum, Illustrative Mathematics, which will impact current third graders. Illustrative Mathematics works to blend math and language while focusing on problem-based curriculum.
Since the new curriculum was implemented, the district saw a 5.9% increase in the percentage of students performing at or above grade level between this fall and winter, the PA Classroom Diagnostic Tool, which is given three times a year to test math proficiency, found.
Increases also were recorded in all student subgroups. White students saw the biggest jump, 12.4%, between fall and winter. That was followed by English learners, 6.5%; those who are economically disadvantaged, 3.9%; Black students, 2.6%; and students with IEPs, 2.1%.
The district is now implementing a three-part strategy to improve those scores in an equitable manner.
The first part, Mr. Walters said, focuses on building positive math identity, which he defined as a student’s belief in their ability to learn and do math. The goal is to build a strong math identity to empower Black students to reach their full potential in math and beyond.
To do that, the district plans to create and implement universal math norms in all district classrooms; develop and deliver targeted mini-lessons to help students build confidence; and use student survey data to track student perceptions of themselves.
The second strategy looks into curriculum-based professional learning.
According to Mr. Walters, one of the challenges the district faces is with professional development attendance rates. In August, 93% of math teachers attended an initial professional learning for Illustrative Mathematics. By the second session in November, that number dropped to 53%. Part of the problem, Mr. Walters said, is that nearly half of the district’s third grade math educators teach multiple content areas. A smaller number teach multiple grade levels.
To help, Pittsburgh Public plans to deliver professional learning for school leaders during monthly meetings; expand curriculum-based professional learning through unit unpacking sessions; provide train the trainer sessions; and deploy math coaches to support teachers in implementing new curriculum.
The final strategy focuses on math language routines, which were designed with English learners in mind, although leaders say they will help all students. The routines develop mathematical language and reasoning skills, alongside English language proficiency, by having students read math problems three times with a specific intention.
During the first read, students will aim to understand the overall context of the problem rather than focusing on the numbers. In the second read, students will look at the quantities and mathematical terms. By the third read, students will put it all together to develop a solution strategy considering the different approaches to solve the problem.
To implement the strategy, PPS will create clear, accessible visual models outlining math language routines; focus on professional learning to help teachers feel confident; and provide family support to teach families how to use the routines to support their child with making sense of and solving word problems.
“This is positive,” Director Sylvia Wilson said. “The strategies are all key and obviously to be clear and concise. So I’m expecting to see some real progress.”
Board President Gene Walker stressed the challenges facing the district, especially when it comes to educators teaching multiple subjects or grade levels. He asked Mr. Walters how directors can create space for teachers wanting to excel in specific subject areas.
That answer, Mr. Walters said: “It will require significant change.”
“Every teacher would want to be able to teach one subject area dedicated in one space,” Mr. Walters said. “I think they would feel a lot more successful. The current reality [is] based on a variety of things: size of school, schedule that they’ve been given, trying to meet demands, trying to make it work, time and space. All of those are variables but it will require change. If we do nothing then we should dedicate ourselves to the definition of insanity.”





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.