Penn State student journalists and free speech advocates are voicing concerns after Penn State removed The Daily Collegian’s newspapers and newsstands from their on-campus locations Wednesday evening over an advertising dispute.

School officials say that advertisements featured on nine of the stands violated university policy. Three racks featured ads supporting the presidential candidacy of Vice President Kamala Harris, and six had ads promoting voter registration.

But all 35 of the Collegian’s indoor newsstands — and the newspapers inside of them — were removed from their locations on Wednesday.

Most of the stands were returned on Friday, Collegian Editor-in-Chief Amy Schafer told the Post-Gazette Friday afternoon.

Advertise with us

One rack is still missing, though, and removal disrupted the distribution of this week’s paper at some locations. The Collegian, which is student-run and independent from Penn State, distributes a weekly paper on Fridays.

Ms. Schafer described removal of the stands and newspapers as “overreach.”

“I do think it is an issue of censorship and certainly overreach by the university,” said Ms. Schafer, a junior studying public relations and global and international studies. “Even if [Penn State] only removed [the racks] for 24 hours, there was still a 24-hour censorship impact on the student body that reads our papers.”

Penn State officials say the rack’s advertisements violated two university policies. The first prohibits “the use of university facilities and/or property for commercial sales activities by individuals or non-university organizations.”

The second policy deals with use of university facilities by non-university groups. It does not specifically mention advertising.

Advertise with us

“The display of the paper version of the Daily Collegian is permitted, as the university supports free news and information sources specifically for its students,” Penn State spokesman Wyatt DuBois said in a statement. “The university is not challenging the Collegian's distribution of newspapers on the racks or otherwise; it is prohibiting the sale by the Collegian of advertising space on university premises that is occurring outside the actual publication of its newspaper.”

Ms. Schafer said the university voiced concerns over the advertisements earlier this week, but never informed the outlet that it planned to remove the ads, racks or papers. The ads were supposed to run until Oct. 1.

Prior to this, the Collegian would run other ads on the racks without issue, she added.

This sends a “chilling message” to those who wish to distribute publications at Penn State, said Robert Shibley, special counsel for the Foundation for Individual Rights and Expression, or FIRE. The Philadelphia-based nonprofit has reached out to the Collegian and is investigating the issue.

“It strikes me as a wild overreaction to a dispute over displaying advertisements on newspaper racks,” Mr. Shibley said. “It’s hard for me to imagine that was the most efficient and least disruptive way that Penn State could have addressed the dispute they were having.”

Advertise with us

Ms. Schafer is concerned that this incident could impact the future of advertising at the outlet, which relies on that revenue and fundraising to sustain itself after Penn State slashed all of its university funding this year.

Prior to the 2023-24 school year, the Collegian would receive $475,000 from the school. This funding was cut by more than half last year and axed altogether in 2024-25. The outlet now receives roughly $200,000 from the Student Fee Board through a newly created Student News Consortium.

Looking to the future, Ms. Schafer hopes Penn State will be more communicative and transparent with Collegian journalists.

“This was definitely discouraging to our reporters,” Ms. Schafer said. “I think it sent a message — between them cutting our funding and then not notifying us that this happened — that they don't really respect student journalism. [That’s] the message it sends, whether or not that was their intention.”